News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by ameister14 on Thursday March 21, 2019 @04:57PM (#19457235)
Whether you disagree with the practice of sheltering in place or not, it still doesn't seem like a good idea to mock execute teachers. You don't need to get shot to get training.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by ryanmarsh on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:03PM (#19457296)
Unfortunately such training is for the limbic system, so pain and fear are required. The limbic system doesn't speak English and cannot reason.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by penagwin on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:11PM (#19457358)
Okay but we aren't training solders here, they took teachers, told them to kneel against the wall, and shot them in the back repeatedly without telling them what was about to happen.

These are elementary schoolteachers - they're job is to educate (and half baby-sit) children.

I'm not making any statement with training, I'm just saying the method here is inappropriate.

EDIT: Plus how is this training? Are they expected to "fight back"? Okay cool a pellet gun hurts - what's the point? A gun hurts more anyway - if it doesn't kill you.

Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by ryanmarsh on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:27PM (#19457516)
Okay but we aren't training solders here

Maybe not but it sure looks like a battlefield[0].

0: when you’re in the midst of a school shooting

Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by penagwin on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:36PM (#19457599)
Does it? According to the US Naval Postgraduate School, 56 people died in school shootings during 2018 (includes shooter). While this is terrible, I'm not sure this counts as a "battlefield"? According to the CDC, over 3x more children died from the flu (185)!

[0] https://www.chds.us/ssdb/number-killed-by-year/ [1] https://www.cdc.gov/flu/about/season/flu-season-2017-2018.ht...

EDIT: Yes during a shooting your environment does resemble a battlefield. Shootings are not common however (see above statistic) so I feel resources may be more valuable elsewhere.

Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by bootlooped on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:09PM (#19457342)
I think it's a little absurd to think that shooting somebody with a pellet gun once is going to benefit them in an active shooter situation. With repeated training, maybe, but this is something that is never going to happen again.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by b_t_s on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:39PM (#19457627)
The training is fairly reasonable for someone who has a reasonable expectation of engaging in combat. You need to drill reactions under duress until you stop thinking and just do what you've drilled instinctively. The problem is that that this is not a reasonable expectation for school teachers. They shouldn't and don't really have a statistically significant chance of seeing combat. They're also a population that strongly self selects for physical and mental inability to be effective in combat. For the majority of school teachers, trying to turn them into halfassed semi-trained soldiers is hopeless and cruel.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by bootlooped on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:47PM (#19457702)
If you read the article it sounds like they just put them up against a wall and shot them in the back. It doesn't sound like training, it sounds more like punishment or hazing.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by b_t_s on Friday March 22, 2019 @11:36AM (#19463567)
I did read the article, and I maintain that it is training. It can save lives. They're trying to make you more afraid of dying through inaction than dying through action, and get you familiar with the fear so you don't freeze. This sort of training can be traumatic but it can also be effective. For young high agressive males, it's high on effeciveness and arguably lower on trauma, and reasonably justified if they are going into combat. For your average middle age female school teacher who has probably never even been in a fist fight let alone a firefight and probably never will, it's largely ineffective, much more traumatic, and likely pointless. I'm sure there were even a few teachers in that session who got some benefit from it. What is training for one person can be hazing for another. Try stepping into a ring with a thai kickboxer for some medium sparing in preparation for a fight. For some people that's just another day at the gym, while for others it's assault, and the most violent traumatic thing they've ever experience. The training has to be calibrated to the students, and in this article it clearly wasn't. To me it sounds more like executive incompetence/misunderstanding than deliberate malice.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by bootlooped on Saturday March 23, 2019 @01:23PM (#19471337)
I'm not against pain being incorporated into training, but for this specific scenario I don't get how you go from "I have been shot in the back once with an airsoft gun" to "I must rush the active shooter or I will die".
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by b_t_s on Friday March 22, 2019 @02:08PM (#19465207)
Also, these _were_ just recreational airsoft guns, very comparable paintball. Lots of people play airsoft and paintball for fun in their spare time. Yea, you're supposed to have goggles on, and point blank shots are frowned on 'cause they hurt more, but it's not all that bad. Sure you might end up with some bruising and broken skin particularly with close range shots to exposed skin, but I'll still play in shorts and tshirt on a hot day and if I get lit up on exposed skin, meh, at least I'm not sweating as much. For the guys running these trainings who are used to shooting each other with paintballs fired from real firearms, airsoft is consumer grade toys, one step above nerf guns. This situation is like having a cross training day between the competitive cagefighting gym and the over 50 cardio kickboxing class...there's just _so_ much potential for that to go poorly.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by ryanmarsh on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:27PM (#19457523)
That’s because you’re thinking. The limbic system doesn’t think.
Re:Teachers unknowingly shot with plastic pellets during act... by bootlooped on Thursday March 21, 2019 @05:43PM (#19457666)
I'm not arguing against the limbic system, I'm arguing against your assertions.