Re:High Court ruling implies headlines are copyright
by ig1 on Saturday November 27, 2010 @12:52PM
(#1945409)
I'm not saying newspapers should be granted any specific protection beyond other websites. I think any website should be allowed to ask someone not to link to them.
The URL protocol allows hotlinking just as much as it allows normal linking. What the protocol does and doesn't allow doesn't define the ethics or the situation.
I'm sure all the companies that want to control inbound links would love to have an inbound link based rights management system. However sites they want to block just use various redirect tricks to cover up the referer.
Re:High Court ruling implies headlines are copyright
by carbocation on Saturday November 27, 2010 @01:05PM
(#1945436)
Providing a link to a website about X is the ethical equivalent of telling your friend where they can learn about X.
Re:High Court ruling implies headlines are copyright
by ig1 on Saturday November 27, 2010 @01:09PM
(#1945457)
You missed the critical conditional of "when the owner's asked you not to do it".
A closer comparison might be passing information onto a friend, when the person who told you the information in the first place asked you not to pass it on.
Re:High Court ruling implies headlines are copyright
by carbocation on Saturday November 27, 2010 @01:12PM
(#1945466)
No, I said what I meant. The ethics of the situation may indeed be driven by the conditionals, but the isomorphism is valid across all conditionals that you might apply. Thus, you can imagine some situations in which linking (or telling a friend) is unethical, just as you can imagine others in which it's not.
No, these are fundamentally different issues. Hotlinking an image causes the image itself to show up in the context of your content. Linking—not hotlinking—to the image is no different from linking to a story or any other piece of content available on the WWW.
If you don't want the rest of the Internet to be able to access your resource, don't give it a uniform resource locator. If you must, simply implement rights management. You are free to tell people not to link to your content, but they are free not to care, or even to be aware of your wishes.