Re:Scientists rise up against statistical significance
by nostrademons on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @07:10PM
(#19447911)
I remember hearing psych-major classmates discussing that experiment in the dorms after class. It's kinda mind-blowing when you think about it.
I read (in a book sitting in a science museum giftshop, so take with the appropriate grain of salt) that most of Freud's theories have been shown to be bullshit in the century and a half since he lived, but his enduring influence was showing that the vast majority of human behavior is unconscious. Instead of thinking of your consciousness as the primary actor that determines what you do, you have to think of it as a vague overseer that occasionally notices the body doing something and can intervene with enough time, exposure, and practice. And whole industries have been built upon that principle - advertising, mass media, propaganda, behavioral finance, therapy, coaching, education, gaming, gambling, cigarettes, coffee, travel, social media.
There was a HN thread 2 days ago about the rise and fall of scientific authority and how to bring it back. I cynically commented that the rise of the physical sciences came from the ability to win wars with them. You could look at the rise of the psychological and social sciences as coming from the ability to make money with them.
I read (in a book sitting in a science museum giftshop, so take with the appropriate grain of salt) that most of Freud's theories have been shown to be bullshit in the century and a half since he lived, but his enduring influence was showing that the vast majority of human behavior is unconscious. Instead of thinking of your consciousness as the primary actor that determines what you do, you have to think of it as a vague overseer that occasionally notices the body doing something and can intervene with enough time, exposure, and practice. And whole industries have been built upon that principle - advertising, mass media, propaganda, behavioral finance, therapy, coaching, education, gaming, gambling, cigarettes, coffee, travel, social media.
There was a HN thread 2 days ago about the rise and fall of scientific authority and how to bring it back. I cynically commented that the rise of the physical sciences came from the ability to win wars with them. You could look at the rise of the psychological and social sciences as coming from the ability to make money with them.