Re:IPv6 Address Unmasking via UPnP
by JohnFen on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @06:11PM
(#19447522)
> So how does the privacy extension not protect the privacy of users by hiding the mac address?
I never said it didn't. I stated that people overstate the protection the facility provides, not that it didn't provide protection.
The deficiencies of the privacy extensions have been discussed widely for years. A quick internet search will show the various criticisms and responses better than any reply I can make here will.
I should, however, clarify what I was trying to say -- I was not trying to say the privacy extensions aren't worthwhile. They're great, and people should use them!
What I was trying to say is that people often think of them as a panacea or a 100% solution. They aren't exactly that (what is?), and the nature of the design of the privacy extensions are such that they make other important network management activities more difficult.
My main criticism of PE (and it's not a showstopper sort of criticism) is that the extensions are hacky and it shows. They were thought up after-the-fact to try to mitigate a security mistake made in the original IPv6 protocol.
Re:IPv6 Address Unmasking via UPnP
by sliken on Thursday March 21, 2019 @01:20AM
(#19449435)
Sure, but the original parent was complaining about the mac address (not any larger privacy issues) and the PE does a good job of hiding the mac address and is enable by default in many common operating systems (Mac, Windows, Ubuntu, etc.)
I never said it didn't. I stated that people overstate the protection the facility provides, not that it didn't provide protection.
The deficiencies of the privacy extensions have been discussed widely for years. A quick internet search will show the various criticisms and responses better than any reply I can make here will.
I should, however, clarify what I was trying to say -- I was not trying to say the privacy extensions aren't worthwhile. They're great, and people should use them!
What I was trying to say is that people often think of them as a panacea or a 100% solution. They aren't exactly that (what is?), and the nature of the design of the privacy extensions are such that they make other important network management activities more difficult.
My main criticism of PE (and it's not a showstopper sort of criticism) is that the extensions are hacky and it shows. They were thought up after-the-fact to try to mitigate a security mistake made in the original IPv6 protocol.