Re:IPv6 Address Unmasking via UPnP
by segfaultbuserr on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @12:23PM
(#19443752)
The question is, why is UPnP even needed on IPv6?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I assume to open the firewall. If you're going to run IPv6 at home, you probably want the firewall equivalent of NAT: Connections are allowed outbound, but not inbound unless on a specifically whitelisted IP/port.
You can continue to use NAT with IPv6. If/when I have to run IPv6 on my LAN, I plan on doing exactly that. I explicitly don't want outside connections to be made directly to arbitrary machines inside my LAN. I have a DMZ for a solid reason.
Almost nobody uses NAT with IPv6. There's not much reason to. You want a firewall, not NAT.
Well, a router more than a firewall. Either way, a mechanism to do this is essentially a NAT.
What I want is a single IP address that is exposed to the internet at large, which is serviced by various different servers behind the firewall depending on the ports. The outgoing traffic from these servers should be from the same single IP address.
That's a NAT in my book.
Technically, this is PAT: port address translation. Why do you want this?
Re:IPv6 Address Unmasking via UPnP
by phalangion on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @02:16PM
(#19445127)
> I explicitly don't want outside connections to be made directly to arbitrary machines inside my LAN.
That's exactly what a firewall is for.
For the love of god, don't do this. NAT is not a security feature.
I never claimed that it was.
>I explicitly don't want outside connections to be made directly to arbitrary machines inside my LAN.
It seems that you did to me.
NAT is not a firewall. IPv6 doesn't need NAT.
I'm not sure why I'm getting so many replies like this. I agree, a NAT is not a firewall. I also agree that IPv6 doesn't need NAT.
All I was saying is that you can use a NAT with IPv6 if you wish, and I'm interested in the sort of routing that a NAT can accomplish.