News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by pier25 on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @03:22PM (#19434625)
Sounds great on paper but I'm skeptical.

Not only you will need a really good internet connection and wifi, but also being close to a Stadia data center. The best possible case scenario will probably be a latency of around 50 ms, but I'm guessing the average will be closer to 100 ms which is too much for many types of games (specially competitive games the streamers play).

Heck, even streaming in your local network isn't such a great experience these days.

I love the idea, but realistically we are still very far away from streaming games replacing consoles or PCs. Many companies have tried (Nvidia, Sony, etc) but no one has succeeded for the simple reason that latency is not there yet.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by nsfmc on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:54PM (#19437451)
i tried this and found it to be pretty satisfying. i played entirely on a macbook while traveling during my winter vacation. It worked surprisingly well even with mixed wifi, i would compare it to the experience you get from using PS4 Remote Play or Steam Link over ethernet.

The only time i found it lagging was similar to the times when both of the above lag: during particularly complex visual scenes (i.e. you're circle strafing around a target and the entire screen is constantly redrawing). I thought it was great for playing a game casually: i.e. story mode. Lots of people use that phrase as a put-down, but the system is well suited for a game like ACO where you are mostly being tactical, planning, exploring, and moving the story forward.

I think of a game like 2016 hitman: i hesitated to install 30G of it to my ps4, but if you told me i could drop into the demo/prelude in less than a minute, even at 720, it's a very appealing concept for somebody like me that plays video games the way other people watch netflix while they're eating dinner: basically whenever i have some downtime and want to dip into a story or mechanic i like for ~30 mins.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by beefsack on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:37PM (#19437706)
> Steam Link over ethernet

Note that even Steam Link over Ethernet is too laggy to play KB/M FPS at any serious level - the input lag makes FPS almost unplayable.

I can see the growth of services like these, especially with more gamers being unable to access dedicated hardware, but there will always be a niche for dedicated hardware. The only way I think they could solve that problem with streaming is using some sort of hybrid streaming approach where some of the UI is remote and some is local and they could do client side simulation somehow for input.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by nsfmc on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @02:00AM (#19439436)
i perhaps have diminished standards, but i found steam link over ethernet to be totally serviceable for playing through most of hyper light drifter on a controller. the input lag was fairly minimal and the computer was already quite long in the tooth, but to your point, i wasn't getting 60fps, that's for sure (probably realistically it was a firm 30fps).

i don't doubt that consoles will remain useful, but i think that services like this will satisfy a pretty legit niche for a vast swath of games that aren't really dependent on low latency input (i.e. puzzle/turn based/rpg/simulators/board game conversions) and that are often 'discovered' by people finding letsplays on youtube.

for some variety of mmorpgs, i can imagine devs being excited about the reduced surface area for cheating/exploits. for somebody like me that uses a mac, i'm looking forward to playing a version of Civ that doesn't cause my laptop to sound like it's about ready to take flight. i don't think the idea is meant to replace consoles, though more, it seems like a way to grease the wheels of commerce and get people playing (and buying) games that they've been traditionally priced out of because of the not-insignificant startup cost of building and maintaining a gaming pc/console.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by bobthepanda on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @10:25PM (#19438332)
I guess my question is; how would something like this scale? With Netflix and Spotify, the media is the same every time you play it, and even stuff like the Black Mirror CYOA have a limited number of combinations, so it's very easy to cache.

Every game has an extremely high number of potential combinations and outcomes, so it's effectively uncacheable. Fan that out to Steam level popularity and diversity of games and it sounds a bit nuts.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by pier25 on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @11:16AM (#19443004)
The only way is adding more servers closer to the users, which means Stadia will only offer really low latencies to users living close to the data centers. So probably only people in large cities.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by reanimated on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @05:11AM (#19440292)
I don't really have a need to stream a full game, but your idea about the demos actually sounds great. I would like to play the demo instantly, evaluate if the gameplay/controls are good and if it does and I'm interested, I would purchase and download full game to my system.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by yegle on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:16PM (#19435289)
I was a beta tester for Project Stream. FWIW, I traveled with a Pixelbook and played Project Stream with the hotel WiFi in Seattle. Everything is smooth and similar (if not the same) experience when I played with my home WiFi.

The latency is good from my experience. There are occasional resolution drop but that happens <1 per hour. Mind you my experience was based on playing ACO which probably is not sensitive to latency.

I also played Nvidia Shield Now on Mac while it was beta. I would say Project Stream is a much much better experience (no need to signup a new account is a plus, no client required a HUGE plus).

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by pier25 on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:36PM (#19435535)
I'll try Stadia for sure when it gets to my country, probably in 2020 or 2021 since Google is not very fond of Mexico.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by bitxbit on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @05:07PM (#19435889)
Agreed. Enthusiast gamers fret/obsess over a small difference in FPS, refresh rate and lag especially when it comes to competitive gaming. Until Google can deliver a service that is indistinguishable, it’s DOA in my view.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by rifung on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:05PM (#19437062)
> Agreed. Enthusiast gamers fret/obsess over a small difference in FPS, refresh rate and lag especially when it comes to competitive gaming. Until Google can deliver a service that is indistinguishable, it’s DOA in my view.

I work for Google, opinions are my own.

I agree but I don't consider this service to be for hardcore enthusiasts. The enthusiasts will continue to buy their powerful gaming machines because they really care about having the best experience.

I think this is great for someone like me, who likes video games, but doesn't want to spend that much money on a computer. Before I would not be able to play the latest titles because my computer is 6 years old, but this would make it so I could.

There are probably tons of kids out there whose parents would scoff at the idea of giving them a $1000+ computer but now would be able to play the latest games with this technology.

All that assuming it works, of course, which is no guarantee.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by thirdsun on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @08:19AM (#19441307)
> I think this is great for someone like me, who likes video games, but doesn't want to spend that much money on a computer. Before I would not be able to play the latest titles because my computer is 6 years old, but this would make it so I could.

> There are probably tons of kids out there whose parents would scoff at the idea of giving them a $1000+ computer but now would be able to play the latest games with this technology.

Isn't a console affordable enough in that case?

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by nilkn on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:35PM (#19437315)
Presumably this service is not going to be free, and the overall cost for someone who plays a lot of games would probably be similar to just getting a $1000+ PC and using it for 3-4 years. Of course maybe the pricing will prove me wrong.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by odessacubbage on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:43PM (#19437363)
how are those parents gonna react when their entire month's data plan gets used up in a weekend? honestly i would rather see google try and cut in on the handheld market by creating peripheral controllers for android devices. every smartphone in the world is four buttons and a dpad away from being the best gameboy ever made.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by Orphis on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @12:47PM (#19444013)
In the civilized internet world, we don't have any data caps though.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by bitxbit on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @10:09PM (#19438249)
Fair enough and I do want to see services like this and the developments from solving these difficult problems.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by Orphis on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @12:44PM (#19443988)
This is like saying that car sharing services like Uber are DOA because there are people who like to have racing cars or are professional pilots.

It's a niche market overall, and each is a different segment you can target independently.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by remyM on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @06:11PM (#19436591)
With current internet solutions in many countries this is purely impossible.

Nothing can deliver the ~25ms input latency that local gaming can, but when you can't game locally it'll do.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by AcerbicZero on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @03:30PM (#19434731)
This is a very valid point. Adding 100ms of latency to games that already struggle to deal with their built in ~100-150ms already is basically a non-starter. So you're left with casual games, single player games (with no modding), and maybe some less latency sensitive multi-player games.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by ppseafield on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @03:43PM (#19434877)
Even the best hardware right in front of you can still currently cause a bad user experience for latency-sensitive games. All it can take is one player with high latency or an unreliable connection, and it can detract from the enjoyability of a game.

And games already have latency from input devices, inputs registering, the game calculating the next frame, the monitor displaying it, and the user perceiving what has happened on screen. Every millisecond of network delay gets sandwiched between all of those.