They have the potential to make way more than a lifestyle business at scale. The idea that they can't is either disingenuous (i.e. greedy) on their part or complete incompetence.
When I went to Patrecon and asked Conte "so what happens if the VC decides it wants a return on its investment" and I think the tl;dr of his reply was "our VC is a bunch of wonderful supporters of the arts who are perfectly fine with not making big bucks off us". I felt like he was blowing sunshine up my ass then and I kinda feel like that even more now.
I wonder what's going on with Kickstarter, Drip, and KS's handing Drip off to XOXO. I would be a lot more comfortable using a membership site that's run by a Public Benefit Corporation instead of a corporation that's got VC to pay back.
I'd love to get your input as a creator and hear your thoughts. If interested, send me an email at [email protected].
Getting such a co-op into a position to actually be preferable to everyone involved might sometimes, in some cases and scenarions, work out to be less pleasing and wonderful.
The question is, would Patreon have succeeded had they not taken in $2 million in seed funding or would they have been beaten by someone who did? Since the second they took seed funding they were no longer on the path of a lifestyle business.