News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by newnewpdro on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @03:12PM (#19434503)
How exactly is Patreon a monopoly?
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by rcthompson on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @03:44PM (#19434891)
They are a monopoly in the sense that pretty much every one of the 20-ish people I support on Patreon has said something along the lines of "Patreon's recent actions make me want to switch to an alternative, but there isn't one, so my only choice is to hunker down and pray they don't keep doing more things to chase away all the people who are generously giving me money."

Also, note that when they express a desire to migrate to another similar service, they know full well that such a migration would involve losing a significant fraction of their patrons who don't go with them for a range of reasons. So in a very real sense, they are willing to pay to move off of Patreon, if only they could find somewhere to move to.

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by Applejinx on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @05:21PM (#19436045)
This. I literally live off my Patreon and am one of the success stories, have been to Patrecon etc, talked to Jack Conte.

I wish he understood that he could do the Amazon model. Go 'screw you, investors: we own the entire sector and that will be your return, to have a piece of the only game in town'. I don't know if he can be that arrogant but we need him to be.

Moving from a regular payment processor to Patreon involved knocking a decimal place off my revenue and slowly recovering (in a way that was more predictable and consistent). These proposed changes in commission don't alter that underlying fact: the business model is better for an independent creator than much higher but spikier revenue off direct sales. Doing a migration throws all that away.

I don't even want to switch to an alternative. I want Patreon to be the Amazon of frictionless-caring-through-money, and my patrons do NOT come from Patreon anyway so there isn't anything really to lose.

If they pull a 'Kagi' and blow up, vanishing one day and owing me hundreds or thousands of dollars, that's when I'll be pissed. So far they have not done that and I'm not convinced they will. They don't have to: they're earning shitloads of money quite legitimately. It is only investor logic that has ANYBODY saying they are doomed, and you could have said the same about Amazon all this time.

They're Amazon for indie creators. Deal with it.

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by stcredzero on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:06PM (#19437073)
I want Patreon to be the Amazon of frictionless-caring-through-money, and my patrons do NOT come from Patreon anyway so there isn't anything really to lose.

Patreon wants to be a politically/culturally aware brand-crafted payment platform for "the creative class." It doesn't quite want to be "the Amazon of frictionless-caring-through-money."

What if someone else was trying hard and executing well on being "the Amazon of frictionless-caring-through-money?" Would you switch?

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by nkkollaw on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:04PM (#19437508)
A cable company is a monopoly.

It's extremely easy to create a website, add a PayPal button, and ask your supporters to donate that way. A lot of people have been doing just that after Patreon's recent deplatforms.

Or, there is also SubscribeStar.

Patreon are just a middleman, but their arrogance of thinking they are more and their crazy spending will make them go bankrupt pretty soon.

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by zanny on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @09:58PM (#19438177)
They are displaying the same arrogance Google, Facebook, et al show in regards to their platform lock in and market capture mindshare. They expect to get away with a lot of user hostile behavior because they have network effects forcing anyone who wants to use something like those platforms to use their platform because thats where everyone else is.
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by microcolonel on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:17PM (#19435306)
> They are a monopoly in the sense that pretty much every one of the 20-ish people I support on Patreon has said something along the lines of "Patreon's recent actions make me want to switch to an alternative, but there isn't one, so my only choice is to hunker down and pray they don't keep doing more things to chase away all the people who are generously giving me money."

Reminder that SubscribeStar is back up and running. They are a good alternative, at least in the interim, if your supporters are leaving Patreon.

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by duskwuff on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:28PM (#19435433)
I've heard good things about Ko-Fi (https://ko-fi.com/). Significantly different revenue model from Patreon -- creators accept payments directly through Stripe or PayPal, and Ko-Fi provides services on top of that for a low, flat monthly fee.
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by cronix on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:09PM (#19435199)
Jordan Peterson and a few others have quit Patreon and are building a competitor after they banned Sargon.

https://www.businessinsider.com/jordan-peterson-says-hell-la...

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by josteink on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @05:01PM (#19435833)
They have left, but been explicitly clear about there being no real alternative, and that there’s no immediate cure coming from them any time soon.

In effect, they’ve stopped accepting donations on purely ideological ground.

While that’s certainly admirable, they are well off enough to be able to afford it.

Most patreon-based content creators probably aren’t.

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by cronix on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @06:34PM (#19436780)
He has discussed building an alternative several times, and as recently as yesterday: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CfQZcpaBqo4&t=175s
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by josteink on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @06:03AM (#19440537)
Sure. But it’s not here now. It’s not a viable alternative to patreon for people who wishes to leave today.

So until that is all sorted out, content-creators are stuck with what they have.

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by wmil on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @05:24PM (#19436078)
Well Peterson and others have switched over to Donorbox. Not quite the same thing, but they still take donations.
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by SilasX on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:08PM (#19435185)
What about accepting donations directly via Paypal?
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by manigandham on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:42PM (#19435602)
It's a lot more work for both creator and contributor. Patreon also aggregates payments so you can fund small amounts (like $1) to several contributors without it all being eaten by processor fees, although they're removing that now and other channels are starting to build better UX so maybe it'll change.
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by delecti on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:24PM (#19435391)
It's just not realistic to expect the level of dedication from supporters making manual monthly donations that it would take to match what automatic pledges accomplish.
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by tapland on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @05:36PM (#19436218)
PayPal does monthly payments and have done so for ages.
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by nkkollaw on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @08:07PM (#19437524)
PayPal has been doing subscriptions for years.
Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by zanny on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @09:56PM (#19438169)
Besides what others have said a lot of Patreons success comes from the value add pledges have on the platform. When you go to a creators page on Patreon you have pledges on right, recent posts in the middle, and info on the left. Half those recent posts probably say "patreons only" or "$15+ tier only".

Like it or not getting sustainable patronage like that requires that the donor get something in return to capture audiences the way Patreon does. It doesn't necessarily have to be what Patreon gives you - usually exclusive posts on the Patreon page, maybe recurring rewards that cost a lot less than the pledge tier - but independently implementing that outside of the website would be at best expensive and at worst ineffective because Patreon has the patronage "mindshare" and people "trust" it now.

Re:Patreon ups its revenue cut, but grandfathers in old crea... by zanny on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @10:00PM (#19438190)
If the answer to the question "I want to create a business funded through patronage online" is "the only place you can sustainably do that is on Patreon" than its a monopoly in online patronage.

A lot of people for decades have tried self-hosted websites with Paypal, Bitcoin, Ko-fi in recent years, etc links. They might even have perks the way Patreon does. But Patreon has mindshare and network effects now and in the same way the only place to get video ad revenue is on Youtube the only place to find recurring sponsors is on Patreon.

Those effects are probably not as strong because people aren't looking for things to sponsor on Patreon, they find projects with Patreons and pledge through that, but the familiarity of Patreon versus unfamiliar alternatives dissuades enough contributors to make most alternatives nonviable or at best extremely risky to try.