News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by dragontamer on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @02:57PM (#19434315)
Thanks for explaining your experience!

There's a lot of us out here who are curious how this thing works and the design tradeoffs.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by molecules on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @03:49PM (#19434963)
I also was a participant. It was pretty cool. I did a wireshark and they are using Google's QUIC protocol.

In my experience the game would drop graphics before I would experience input lag. There were a handful of times that I did experience input lag. This was on a wired connection 100mbs down 20mbs up through Xfinity.

I did notice in the Google demo, that when the person was using the game pad, he experienced input lag when he was trying to jump up on top of that steeple on top of the building.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by dragontamer on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @03:55PM (#19435027)
Hmm, I think I like those design choices. A dropped frame or two isn't a big deal in my experience, while a delayed input is a far bigger detriment to the gaming experience. QUIC (and UDP in general) seems about right for the technology backend.

I'm still of the opinion that Google shot themselves in the foot here by having a bunch of wireless controllers in one room. Its like they've never talked to a Super Smash Bros Brawl tournament organizer before: Wii Nunchuks over 2.4GHz Bluetooth have dropped packets / dropped input issues when you get to ~20+ participants.

Don't do mass wireless in one room. It always ends poorly. I'd expect that local wireless in a typical living-room setting would be a better experience actually. After all: the major issue is whether or not the wired-connection / fiber backbone of the typical city is up to spec for this kind of thing. (A typical living room user probably doesn't have to worry about clogged 2.4GHz connections unless they're in an apartment I guess...)

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by gcbw2 on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @04:25PM (#19435406)
> tradeoffs

lag is the least of your worries. Encoding artifacts will get to you and completely ruin the experience on anything that is not a simple puzzle game.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by jsight on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @05:12PM (#19435944)
So basically the same issues as onlive then? I remember thinking that it was pretty good for a while. Then I tried the same game on a decent PC immediately after using the service.

It was night and day, both in terms of latency and graphics quality. I don't have high hopes for this service.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by mikepurvis on Wednesday March 20, 2019 @04:59PM (#19446854)
I feel similarly. I've tried in-home streaming from PS4 to a MacBook— obviously the encoding of the video signal isn't going to be as optimized or speedy as Google's backend, but still, the overall ping is sub-10ms and it's still a way worse experience than playing the same game on the TV, even for relatively slow paced action-adventure titles like HZD or RDR2.

I can't imagine trying to play something like a fighting game this way.

Re:Google unveils Stadia cloud gaming service by jotm on Tuesday March 19, 2019 @07:57PM (#19437462)
It worked great, in my experience. The most awesome thing about it was playing Dirt Rally 3 I believe, on a Motorola Droid/Milestone. A full PC game on a smartphone, pretty mind blowing at the time, and it was quite good even over 3G.