News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2019 @02:03PM (#19423427)
I deliberately chose the restaurant comparisons I did to avoid this bogus response. It's not my contention that you're unfamiliar with fine dining. I'm saying something different, and if you reread my comment, I think you may find it.

A good clue that your response is out of line is that you started it with "LOL". I do that too, all the time (more often, the single-word sentence "What."), and have learned to notice it as a tell that I'm writing something I'm not going to be happy having said later. The edits I make when that happens always improve my writing.

Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by lisper on Monday March 18, 2019 @02:19PM (#19423588)
Then I'm sorry, but you're going to have to be more explicit about the point you were trying to make because I don't see it.

> You are probably not eating at the kinds of restaurants that are Tock's mainstay. In San Francisco, that's places like Atelier Crenn and Saison.

Atelier Crenn has two stars. Saison has three. (And I have in fact been to Saison.)

> The Publican or Zuni Cafe

Neither of these has a star and both of them use OpenTable, not Tock. I have not been to either one.

So I'm sorry, but I am utterly at a loss as to what point you were trying to make.

Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2019 @02:30PM (#19423716)
Dusek's, Entente, Parachute, Sepia, and Roister† have stars in Chicago, and I stand a pretty good chance of getting a same-day reservation at any of them, and a walk-in at some of them. Michelin stars have nothing to do with my point, which you seem to have taken as "I think you eat at Burger King", which I do not.

My point is that lots of fine-dining restaurants can metabolize a no-show in ways that restaurants like Atelier Crenn and Alinea cannot. Kokonas claims that a single no-show at Alinea is the difference between a profitable and unprofitable day for them. That's obviously not the case at Zuni. That's why Atelier Crenn is on Tock, and Zuni is on OpenTable. Which is the point 'DannyBee was making.

† Roister, which is in the Alinea group, is on Tock, and is an a la carte restaurant and, like all a la carte restaurants, can't possibly charge the meal up front because they're not prix fixe. Once again: plenty of a la carte restaurants are also on Tock, presumably because Tock is a better partner for restaurants than OpenTable is and is certainly a more pleasant experience for customers.

Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by lisper on Monday March 18, 2019 @03:00PM (#19424011)
OK, but I still cannot tell what the distinguishing characteristic of "restaurants like Atelier Crenn and Alinea" is supposed to be if not that they are high-end restaurants by some metric. The idea that all of these restaurants are on Tock because there is no other way for them to survive is manifestly untrue because some of them were open and thriving before Tock existed.

(BTW, since you offered a critique of my writing style, let me reciprocate: you are playing a game where you are making me guess at the point you are trying to make, and then giving me a hard time when my guess turns out to be wrong. That is childish, and more than a little annoying.)

Also, FWIW, I don't dispute that the restaurant business is extremely difficult. I certainly understand why restaurants want to charge up front, just as I understand why software developers would rather sell subscriptions than licenses. All I'm saying is that I don't like it, and I will not do business with anyone who adopts either of those models if I can avoid it (and in the case of restaurants, I can). I'm not saying anything about what anyone else on either side of the transaction should or should not do.

Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2019 @03:15PM (#19424180)
I just wrote out what the distinction is. One kind of restaurant has every seating planned out weeks in advance and may be driven into an unprofitable night by a single no-show; the other has reservations available on much less notice and can metabolize a no-show without altering the overall economics of the restaurant. It is the case that all the former restaurants happen to be prix fixe fine dining restaurants. It is not the case that all prix fixe fine dining restaurants are in the former category.

I can get a same-day table at Momotaro or Kai Zan in Chicago. I can also pre-pay for an omakase seating at Kyoten. Stipulate that they're places of comparable quality. Momotaro and Kai Zan are traditional restaurants. Kyoten is a 9-seat omakase-only restaurant that does two seatings a night. Momotaro and Kai Zan are on OpenTable; Kyoten, for obvious reasons, won't be.

Things sucked for restaurants before Tock, and suck somewhat less now, so the fact that restaurants sucked it up and ate the costs of no-shows before Tock existed is not a persuasive argument.

Because you've made a moral argument out of it, I'm going to keep pointing out that Tock hosts a la carte restaurants just like OpenTable, and, for obvious reasons, doesn't demand prepayment for them.

Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by lisper on Monday March 18, 2019 @03:35PM (#19424380)
> you've made a moral argument out of it,

No, I don't believe I have. I've just stated my personal opinion.

Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2019 @03:37PM (#19424394)
Tock's pay-up-front business model destroys that trust. The not-so-subtle message to the customer is, "We don't trust you to pay."
Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by lisper on Monday March 18, 2019 @03:47PM (#19424480)
OK, I think we'll just have to agree to disagree about this. I think that's a statement of fact, not a moral judgement about Tock.
Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2019 @03:52PM (#19424530)
OK, but you're clear now that Tock is not actually premised on the idea that you have to pre-pay for all the restaurants you go to. To a consumer, it's just like OpenTable, except that it has better restaurants on it, including some that won't use OpenTable because their economics work better pre-paid.

I understand not going to Kyoten or Atelier Crenn because you don't want to pre-pay (also, because you don't want to pay $450/person before drinks). I don't understand not going to Roister or Petit Crenn Brunch, both of which are a la carte and neither pre-paid, simply because they're on Tock.

Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by lisper on Monday March 18, 2019 @04:06PM (#19424668)
> you're clear now that Tock is not actually premised on the idea that you have to pre-pay for all the restaurants you go to.

Yes, but I didn't actually know that before. Every encounter I have had with Tock has been pay-ahead, and so I assumed that was their business model.

BTW, w.r.t. passing moral judgement, I'm surprised that you didn't pick the more low-lying fruit:

> Not even FaceBook is 100% evil.

That was a moral judgement, but about Facebook, not directly about Tock. I don't like Tock because they (AFAICT) enable and encourage the pay-ahead model, which I don't like. But I wouldn't call them evil.

> I don't understand not going to Roister or Petit Crenn Brunch, both of which are a la carte and neither pre-paid, simply because they're on Tock.

I had never heard of either of these places before you mentioned them, but no, I would not boycott them simply because they're on Tock.

Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2019 @04:27PM (#19424891)
I think Facebook is pretty evil! I just think Tock is a lot less evil than OpenTable. :)
Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by lisper on Monday March 18, 2019 @05:02PM (#19425271)
You may well be right about that. One of the things that makes FB evil is that it is not immediately apparent that they are.
Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by idlewords on Monday March 18, 2019 @03:01PM (#19424021)
I hope that in a distant future, when the world is encased in ice and the alien archaeologists have landed to gain some clue about the extinct species that put up the satellites and left some landers on the moon, the one remnant of human civilization they find is this Hacker News exchange.
Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by tptacek on Monday March 18, 2019 @03:17PM (#19424202)
This is why we take you to the goat-soup-only restaurants.
Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by kasey_junk on Monday March 18, 2019 @05:50PM (#19425692)
Be fair. They had homemade tortillas & you could bring in beer.
Re:Who Controls Diners’ Data? OpenTable Moves to Assert Control by akerl_ on Monday March 18, 2019 @04:09PM (#19424697)
Allegedly put landers on the moon.