Re:(UK) Police to get major new powers to seize domains
by rlpb on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:35AM
(#1942571)
Why do the police need special powers to do this? Why can't they get a court order instead?
Is the reason that the court would not permit it, because doing so would not be just? Perhaps "reasonable grounds to believe..." is not good enough for the courts. Why should it be?
Re:(UK) Police to get major new powers to seize domains
by rlpb on Friday November 26, 2010 @10:38AM
(#1942577)
The article starts off "Police to get major new powers...". Then it says "Police could soon have the power...". Finally "SOCA wants Nominet to change...".
So, in conclusion, they'd like these powers (which we already knew), but nobody has approved anything (which tells us nothing).
Re:(UK) Police to get major new powers to seize domains
by CallMeV on Friday November 26, 2010 @02:04PM
(#1943007)
Didn't Iceland pass a legal power to enshrine the right to free speech on the web, making it a data haven beyond the reach of these kind of power grabs?
Because it isn't criminal activity that Fitwatch was advocating, but making sure that those people being harassed by the cops had the law on their side, not the UK Stasi.
Is the reason that the court would not permit it, because doing so would not be just? Perhaps "reasonable grounds to believe..." is not good enough for the courts. Why should it be?
So, in conclusion, they'd like these powers (which we already knew), but nobody has approved anything (which tells us nothing).
Because it isn't criminal activity that Fitwatch was advocating, but making sure that those people being harassed by the cops had the law on their side, not the UK Stasi.