News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breaking News: Girls don't become engineers because they... by nostrademons on Monday May 19, 2008 @12:29PM (#194182)
Chances are, "un-enrolling" about half the graduate students would improve a department no matter how big it is. Sturgeon's Law - "90% of everything is crap".

But if you have a bigger pool to draw from, the 10% that's not crap will amount to more engineers. And the 0.01% that's really spectacular will be more spectacular. That's the way a bell-curve works - if you raise the area under the curve, the tips spread out as well.

There're a lot of smart people in finance whose talents are being wasted making sure that the market reflects all information within microseconds instead of within minutes. If the economic incentives were such that they started companies or did basic research instead, I bet you'd see quite a few more breakthroughs.

Re:Breaking News: Girls don't become engineers because they... by cdr on Monday May 19, 2008 @12:48PM (#194199)
Un-enrolling the /bottom/ 50% would probably improve a department, sure. But how do you get that bottom 50% without enrolling all of those students in the first place?

Your second point assumes that the relative percentage of "not crap" remains constant as enrollment increases, which is highly dubious.

And there's a lot of smart people being wasted at Google and Microsoft, too.

Re:Breaking News: Girls don't become engineers because they... by aggieben on Monday May 19, 2008 @12:43PM (#194195)
I can't say I agree. We have increased our pool by accepting sub-par students, and it seems to be shifting the entire curve backwards, rather than "spreading the tips".

I don't know what the right answer is (or if there is one); what feels right is to raise the standards of admission.