Re:Sweet-expressions: A readable format for Lisp-like languages
by raganwald on Friday November 26, 2010 @07:49AM
(#1942263)
Of course familiarity by way of similarity to previous experience is a valid question for debate. My claim is that it is just one of several considerations for judging the merit of an overall design, and not necessarily the most important one.
Intuitiveness is indeed highly correlated to previous human experience. But aside from pre-existing interfaces, an interface designer has available the whole of an average person's real world experience - the mouse is intuitive because it mimics a person's experience of moving a physical object - it doesn't mimic exactly but closely enough that a person can use their existing experience to extrapolate. And an interface designer who wanted to improve a standard interface may be able to find a different facet of human experience analogous to the task at hand and thus (contrary to the link) it is possible to create interfaces which are new and intuitive (but I'll admit it's damn hard and you should have a reason).
Most computer languages leverage human experience with natural language - not exactly, but partly. That's why Ruby's "return 5 if done" syntax seems really nice. Thus I'd argue you can make a reasonable study of what constitutes an intuitive interface.
So I claim the intuitiveness of Lisp's parentheses is a valid question for debate.