News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by patio11 on Thursday November 25, 2010 @09:56PM (#1941527)
I was considering writing one of these for Frontierville, since it was scarily effective at sucking me in. I have been playing it for mental breaks during the coding for AR, and have spent... crikey... $140 on it.

One taste of this: they had a Thanksgiving mission, which required (as the fifth stage of the mission) you to gather 40 of item A, 40 Bs, 40 Cs, 40 Ds, and 40 Es. ABCDE are all not available through gameplay : the only way to get them is to get your friends to give you one or to give one to a friend (gifts are symmetrical). "Giving" means sending them a Facebook request.

Each of these items was available for 2 horseshoes (the scarce currency which can be bought for real money), plus there was a final item which cost something like 30 horseshoes. So, if you didn't spend a few weeks spamming everyone you knew on Facebook, but you still wanted to complete your Thanksgiving quest, you just had to click the buy-for-Horseshoes button a few hundred times, and bam, quest complete.

I did that. Only afterwards did I do the math: I had bought 1,000 horseshoes for $70. 350 horseshoes is... $24.50. I just spent twenty five dollars to close a dialog box and get a brief flash of text on my screen inviting me to spam my friends with the fact that I had closed the dialog box successfully.

(The rewards for the quest are immaterial -- FrontierVille doesn't tell you what they are in advance. It turn out to be stuff much, much less good than what you could otherwise acquire for 350 horseshoes.)

It isn't a good game. But it is compelling.

Still, I have taken one lesson from Zynga that I am almost certainly going to use: they show a progress bar on the first screen, with progress totally based on taking actions which benefit Zynga. (Installed app, get updates, bookmark app, Like app.) Your reward for filling the bar is to have a full bar. This is brilliant. I'm stealing it to make my signup page shorter -- I'll just defer the non-critical parts until later and make successful completion a requirement for filling the bar.

Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by starpilot on Friday November 26, 2010 @05:05AM (#1942049)
Your progress bar comment reminds me of the satirical RPG Progress Quest: http://progressquest.com/. I've got to admit, just watching your character gain experience as you "play" is weirdly satisfying.
Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by maushu on Friday November 26, 2010 @06:29AM (#1942160)
It's not as weird as you think, most people have jobs where it's hard to get a medium to convey the progress of their work.

This usually leaves the person with a unfulfilled need to see stuff getting finished.

Try this one http://progresswars.com/ too.

Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by tomjen3 on Friday November 26, 2010 @12:47AM (#1941723)
You are a smart person, and generally have the admireration of most people on this board. Given that you knew you where a recovering WoW addict, how could you start playing anything like named *ville? Wouldn't all sorts of old habits just resurface?
Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by AndyKelley on Friday November 26, 2010 @05:12PM (#1943501)
Admiration. Hopefully he has a timer that he set for a specific date, and once that date rolls around, he's not allowed to play any more.
Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by m_myers on Thursday November 25, 2010 @10:37PM (#1941582)
Have you tried Progress Wars (http://progresswars.com/)? It's a slightly cheaper way to get one's fix of filling progress bars.
Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by ambiate on Thursday November 25, 2010 @11:16PM (#1941618)
I learned the progress bar element from eZine Articles. Watching my article never move but always sitting at 33% made me come back to the site day after day. I really had no intention of writing more articles. I was already there though, so, why not write 3-4 more?

Another great example of my willingness to give in to hypothetical progress bar and waiting lines was callgraph.biz. I signed up and was placed #2500 in queue. The first few days were manic refreshes and F5 key slamming. After those initial days, I gave up. Later on I was accepted, but I had lost my immediate thunder which I found while I was 'struggling' in a queue system. Luckily, being bombarded with "new test files available" in my inbox everyday convinced me to give them a try. It was a really interesting service and actually landed me a cheap part time job at my university. Who would have guessed "transcribing skills" was something people need? :D

I think a pseudo-queue system or a progress bar is actually quite heroic in the first few days. Later on, you lose that immediate faith and interest. You have to utilize it properly in those first few moments! Convince your user they're #25,000 in waiting list. Send them an email saying they've been bumped to #10,000 later on that evening for some random word in the signup form, etc. You'll have them craving your service.

Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by henrikschroder on Friday November 26, 2010 @07:00AM (#1942198)
I also played Frontierville for a bit, but never spent money on it. I even got a lot of fake Facebook friends that were Frontierville players so I could have more neighbours without spamming my actual Facebook friends.

The one thing that suckered me into it was the sound effects and sparkles whenever you do something "good" in the game, like gather coins or hearts or wood. They are absolutely brilliant and complement the progress bar very nicely. For me, they just hit the reptile brain button labelled "good boy!". Clingeling cling cling caching... Oh yeah...

Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by brianmeidell on Friday November 26, 2010 @03:09AM (#1941865)
Yeah, the progress bar is also a good mechanism - I'll add that to the document. Thanks.

The distinction between compulsion and fun (or "good game") is something I spend a lot of time thinking about.

Compulsion is like a spice - a little of it can make a good game even better, but if you use it too much, it will ruin everything :)

Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by icegreentea on Friday November 26, 2010 @06:13AM (#1942144)
Penny-arcade has a relevant comic:

http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2010/3/12/

Re:What I Learned From FarmVille - So You Don’t Have To Play It by ebrenes on Friday November 26, 2010 @05:10PM (#1943494)
I recently signed up on OkCupid, thanks in part to some of the OkTrends posts and the string of posts regarding the site a while back. And for the first few hours I was on the site I stuck around mostly to fill in the 100% completion progress bar for my profile. It's an incredibly compelling mechanism, at least more so than I would have imagined it to be had someone told me about it without these examples to back it up.