News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by antirez on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:38PM (#19402112)
It almost looks like if it was an error to call this plane 737 MAX instead of, let's say, 738, to communicate that it's quite a different plane because of aerodynamic differences and electronic systems to require a training for the pilots. Aircraft semaver.
Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by cjbprime on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:40PM (#19402126)
Boeing fought extremely hard to avoid doing this because it would introduce new costs in certification and new requirements for pilot training. It wasn't accidental.
Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by SketchySeaBeast on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:58PM (#19402359)
I blows my mind that a naming convention can be used to determine the similarities between vehicles. "I don't need a licence as this isn't a bus, it's clearly a tricycle, look on the side."
Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by Obi_Juan_Kenobi on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:09PM (#19402487)
It's not the naming convention; the name just matches the certification/rating scheme.

The substance of keeping the rating consistent has to do with how the plane operates, the flight controls, etc.

There are potentially perverse incentives here, but it's not as trivial as that.

Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by darkpuma on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:28PM (#19403307)
If Boeing had chosen to name it the 738, would that really have had no psychological impact on the humans involved in the process of determining whether or not Boeing should be permitted to consider it the "same" aircraft for certification/rating?
Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by jcoby on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:53PM (#19403566)
It's not really a psychological question. Boeing had no option to change the name and meet the requests of its customers.

The FAA says you have to have a B-737 rating to fly any 737, regardless of revision [1]. The MAX series is the maximum number of changes the FAA would permit and still allow it to be called a 737. In theory, someone who is type rated and familiar with the -100 series should be able to safely operate the MAX 8.

Most likely the airlines have rules above and beyond that (like requiring sim or right seat time in a particular revision), but this is the motivation behind the aircraft. If they had made a 738, it would have needed to go through certification as if it were a new design. By making it a revision, the certification process is significantly reduced in both time and costs.

1. https://registry.faa.gov/TypeRatings/ (note the MAX isn't present on this list; I assume due to it being grounded)

Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by darkpuma on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:17PM (#19404836)
I presume that if Boeing arbitrarily decided that all new production 737NGs were to be renamed 738 with no engineering changes, on just the whim of some marketing team, the FAA would recognize it as the same airplane despite the different name. Perhaps they'd be quite annoyed with Boeing for doing that, but I can't imagine they'd actually require all pilots to retrain.

That's just my presumption though.

Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by mimixco on Friday March 15, 2019 @05:06PM (#19404296)
Good point, but from what I understand, the big issue is the type rating. Apparently, aicraft with very different names like 767/777/787 and A330/A340, share a type rating so they only require "simplified" training.

Maybe a pilot can chime in on what the real training is like when switching between aircraft of the same type rating and how a manufacturer or the FAA decide on what constitutes a new type.

Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by cjbprime on Friday March 15, 2019 @06:39PM (#19404973)
No, 767/777/787 are three different type ratings requiring separate pilot endorsements. It's the submodels that share the rating.
Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by SilasX on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:59PM (#19403013)
Laws should be written in such a way that it shouldn't matter what provider calls the product, but what objective criteria it meets.

Bad: "Taxis have to meet these standards."

Good: "If you pick up strangers off the street and drive them somewhere for money, locating them by visual signals, you have to meet these standards."

Bad: "If your plane is a new model number, it has to re-certify."

Good: "If your plane exposes an interface to the pilot with incompatible expectations from your existing models, it has to re-certify."

(Not making any claim about whether aviation or taxi law meets this standard, just making the general point.)

Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by cjbprime on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:01PM (#19402393)
I think it does actually reuse the >50 year-old 737 airframe design, as a condition of continuing the same type rating. Just.. not much else.
Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by ams6110 on Friday March 15, 2019 @02:37PM (#19402792)
Yes it's the same basic design, but you might be hard pressed to believe it. Notice especially the engines.

Original 737:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_737#/media/File:D-ABEA_...

Max:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_737_MAX#/media/File:HS-...

The fuselage, tail, wings and control systems are close enough to the original type to stay certified.

Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by callalex on Friday March 15, 2019 @03:29PM (#19403320)
It’s funny that you chose that example. The RV industry has done an incredible job lobbying in this country. You can freely purchase and operate an RV that is the same exact size, and usually the same exact platform as a bus that would require a commercial driving license, because it is called an RV instead of a bus.
Re:Pilots offer insights on Boeing 737 crashes by antirez on Friday March 15, 2019 @01:42PM (#19402147)
Oh interesting, thanks for the background info.