News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by AnaniasAnanas on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:07PM (#19373552)
Uber's self-driving car killed a person because its driver was playing on his phone rather than doing his job.
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by SilasX on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:19PM (#19373662)
In a sense, I want to agree. That was a big no-no on her part.

But ... for a project like this, it's the kind of thing they should have planned for and could have easily worked around.

First of all, Uber's setup was to have one person do both the analytics monitoring and safety roles. That's ridiculous. The safety person needs to focus on that alone.

Second, for any boring job, it's expected that people will tend to mentally check out, and you should design it so that a single checkout doesn't cascade to death. They could have had a periodic "press this button to prove you're paying attention", or limited the employee from bringing any device except a limited one with no distractions.

So yeah, she shouldn't have been watching a movie, but Uber shouldn't have had better safeguards for the inevitable attention drift.

Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by aaomidi on Wednesday March 13, 2019 @10:17AM (#19378820)
Yep. My local YMCA requires lifeguards to switch every 15 minutes.
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by SilasX on Wednesday March 13, 2019 @10:50AM (#19379173)
Smirking at how YMCA has better safeguards for attention drift around pool safety than Uber does around road safety.
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by ghaff on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:21PM (#19373686)
The (literal) victim blaming on this thread is absolutely astounding. [ADDED: I'm not talking about the driver although they were partially at fault. But the person who was killed.] Anyone with that attitude shouldn't be allowed anywhere near developing or operating a mission-critical system.
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by umvi on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:42PM (#19373832)
The victim is partially to blame for her own death in this case.

I agree that victim blaming is _not_ useful when trying to figure out why a safety critical application failed and should not even be in the equation when developing, operating, or maintaining such safety-critical systems.

But to simply answer the question "Who is to blame for her death?" the blame does _not_ rest 100% solely on Uber, nor the driver, nor the victim. All 3 failed to prevent the accident (and all 3 had the power and indeed responsibility to prevent it).

People are responsible for their own risk management. If I take an unnecessary risk (like jaywalking at night on a freeway) and I get hit by a car (autonomous or not), that's partially on me.

Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by ghaff on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:50PM (#19373890)
There were at least three parties who bore some responsibility for what happened. But some people come across as simply excusing Uber in this case. I expect that many of those same people wouldn't be so quick to excuse a human driver who hits a cyclist or pedestrian who isn't interacting with cars in the safest possible manner.
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by linuxftw on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:18PM (#19373645)
We don't know much about this person, what they were told to expect, what they believed their responsibilities were, what kind of training they had, or whether the person was obviously unfit for the task (eg, they hired a young person with no/little work history, etc).
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by umvi on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:15PM (#19373627)
Uber's self-driving car killed a person because the victim was jaywalking on an unilluminated section of 4-lane highway at night and did not stop, look, or listen before crossing
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by hnuser987654321 on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:16PM (#19373638)
Said person was also high on meth and weed.
Re:Uber’s self-driving car unit was burning $20M a month by CompanionCuuube on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @06:21PM (#19373690)
People not on meth and weed jaywalk without stop, look, or listen before crossing. Or are you saying that this person normally does those things but the meth and weed inhibited them from doing that?