News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods by arethuza on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @04:43AM (#1936943)
I think it's the term "wrong" is what I object to - Newtonian mechanics is still perfectly "correct" for a large number of circumstances. Just because a more refined, and rather more complex theory, comes along a few centuries later doesn't invalidate the fact that if you stay within the boundaries of the where it is known to be perfectly valid it is the best thing to use.

When you model some physical system you do it with and end in mind and a lot of assumptions have to be made (e.g. that gas flow is non-turbulent, heat flow is uniform) which are all wrong in some sense because reality isn't like that but if you didn't make these simplifying assumptions then you'd never get anything done.

Mathematical models aren't reality - they are an attempt to create structures that allow us to explain and predict and the assumptions underlying the mappings between these structures and reality are just as important as the contents of the theories themselves. It's possible to model the same system in umpteen different ways - indeed as there is no all encompassing theory-of-absolutely-everything you have to make some important decisions when you model something as to what is relevant. Trying to model plate tectonics in terms of string theory is unlikely to get you very far - that doesn't make string theory "wrong".

There are no comments on this comment yet.