[citation needed]
Simon Phipps, Sun's Chief Open Source Officer at the time, has stated this is not the case:
* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_Development_and_Distrib...
The only person who has made this claim is Danese Cooper, and she has been directly contradicted by her boss at the time (Phipps).
(Improving bcachefs, or whatever, is independent of the CDDL question.)
Of course he did. There's nothing to gain from admitting it. It's the sort of statement akin to 'Facebook deeply values your privacy', as in of course they're going to say that.
On the other hand, submitting the license to the OSI, but not the FSF to be consulted on compatibility before using it suggests otherwise.
""" > > It would be a critical mistake to underestimate her knowledge on > the CDDL > issues.
Nonetheless she is wrong to characterise the opinion of the Solaris engineering team in the way she does. She is speaking this way because she lost an argument inside Sun, not because her view is representative of the views of Sun or its staff in the way she claims. She, along with many actual engineers, was an advocate of using GPL for OpenSolaris but the need to release rather than wait for one of {GPL v3, Mozilla license revision, encumbrance removal} meant that this was not possible. I am still furious with her for the statement she made at DebConf, which was spiteful and an obstacle to a united FOSS movement. """
* https://marc.info/?l=opensolaris-discuss&m=115740406507420
Cooper is, AFAICT, the only one that made the claim: was it ever corroborated by anyone else? Phipps and Cantrill dispute it: are/were there others?
Edit: it seems that not even GPLv3 (which they considered) is not compatible with GPLv2 (which Linux uses), so even if they did that it would be a problem. One main thing (IIRC) that was of concern was patent license grants.
From your own quote:
> She, along with many actual engineers
The CDDL-GPL drama seems to be one of an attitude of "fuck-ZFS because fuck-Sun/Oracle and their fucking CDDL license".
The validity of the claim that the design of CDDL was 'malicious' is the thing I am skeptical about.
It may have ended up incompatible because of technical-legal reasons, but was that the intent? Cooper says yes, Phipps/Cantrill say no.
Personally, I'd rather see more resources poured into bcachefs[1].
1 - https://bcachefs.org