There’s no burden on anyone to refute anything from this piece, as the piece itself has not met any basic requirement of presenting facts or evidence in the first place.
It’s merely a matter of fact to point out this deficiency of the article. The premises of the article could still be accurate (though I think that is fleetingly unlikely), but even if so, this article does not justify any of those claims, so nobody could know one way or the other from this article. Again, this is just a matter of observation of the justifications given.
This author would personally find it more convenient if the skillset of data scientists and data platform engineers coexisted in one person who also happened to have the drive to undertake employment spanning all those skill sets, and wouldn’t become unhappy if the employer did not respect specializations. So this author has decided to read tea leaves out of economic principles and superimpose this wish as if it was justified by some first principles analysis.
In fact, this wishful thinking seems exactly in line with the flawed perspective that executives or director level employees will have. They don’t want to have to care about motivation and intellectual curiosity required to keep certain kinds of knowledge workers happy & productive, and spend lots of time trying to justify how their business units embody corporate platitudes about customer-driven passion. It’s quite easy to see why they would fall victim to this sort of naive wishful thinking. It’s quite similar to CTOs getting suckered by turn-key consulting solutions. It’s not even surprising that VPs & C-suite executives would be very wrong about this type of work.
This is what I was referring to when I said argument from authority :)
From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority : a fallacy to cite an authority on the discussed topic as the primary means of supporting an argument
PS: Thanks for pointing out ad hominem :)
[1]https://medium.com/@pblanken/considering-believability-cf604...
[2] I don't know the experience of the person I was responding to, so I'm making an assumption.
It is a lot more common that a data anomaly is caused by a bug in implementing a web framework.
If you’re trying to do reverse image search or machine translation or creating custom embeddings unique to your business problem at hand, then deep learning is hands down better.
This bolsters my point as well. If you only hired “full stack” data scientists and you’re trusting them to correctly tell you if / how deep learning is applicable to a new problem, instead of hiring specialists who actually know how to systematically diagnose that situation, you’re setting yourself up to fail. You may already be too biased towards believing simpler things “should” do better, and you’ll take the full stack person’s inability to outperform with deep learning as if it is confirmatory evidence, when really all it is telling you is that you need a specialist.
It takes at least a decade just to study the prerequisite materials in vector calculus, linear algebra, advanced statistics, classifier algorithms, convex and gradient-based optimization, matrix computations and numerical methods, and associated software engineering skills. That’s all just to get to “base camp” of deep learning.
On the flip side, it’s pretty low effort to just use plug-n-play network components from popular libraries and follow a few tutorials or open source projects.
That’s why there’s effectively zero employment demand for the skill of naive keras or pytorch lego building. It’s as easy as it is meaningless.
Given that you’d already have been spending a decade+ of your life on advanced math if you planned to work on deep learning to solve real problems, there’s a huge impedance mismatch with this idea that you’d somehow also magically just be happy ignoring that specialized skill and the time investment sunk into it to then instead be happy writing throw-away little Flask apps or optimizing routine ETL queries.
On a flip side, TensorFlow 2.0 and AutoML are coming ;). And generic RL agents that do not require reward hacking are also on the horizon. Who cares, if a researcher spend 10000 hours reading articles AND 10000 hours building products, if a more general algorithm obsoletes it all ;)
Yes, same for me. This builds in nearly a decade of preparatory work into the timeline... so it seems we agree.
> “On a flip side, TensorFlow 2.0 and AutoML are coming ;). And generic RL agents that do not require reward hacking are also on the horizon.”
I work professionally in deep learning for image processing. This quote reads like parody to me. I cannot imagine anyone familiar with the realities of AutoML or deep reinforcement learning talking this way. It’s like an excerpt from the script of Silicon Valley.
Using AutoML in practice is beyond foolish, given the pricing, except for a really small minority of customers. Let alone that neural architecture search is not a silver bullet and frequently is totally not helpful for model selection (for example, say your trade-off space involves severe penalty on runtime and you have a constraint that your deployed runtime system must be CPU-only.. you may trade performance for the sake of reducing convolutional layers, in a super ad hoc business-driven way that does not translate to any type of objective function for NAS libraries to optimize... one of the most important production systems I currently work on has exactly this type of constraint).
No. Even these people haven’t been doing it for a decade.
No. None of these people have the math background you think, nor do you need it.
This reads like a desperate business person wrote it, who wishes that one full-stack set of drives made sense and coexisted in a single person to make that labor cheaper and more commidity, despite the reality that it’s simply not true.
The person who spent the time to master web service frameworks, query languages and product engineering necessarily did not also master professional level knowledge of deep learning or MCMC sampling or natural language processing.
The two types of people need to coexist and work symbiotically, but it’s just asinine wishful thinking to pretend like they are the same person, let alone to write a baseless essay full of assertions that if they aren’t the same person it somehow results in first principles economic inefficiency.