Why wasn't ElastAlert used / built upon for alerting? https://github.com/yelp/elastalert
Or why wasn't ElasticSearch SQL used / built upon for SQL? https://github.com/NLPchina/elasticsearch-sql
Or why wasn't SearchGuard used / built upon for Security? https://github.com/floragunncom/search-guard
All of them have Apache 2.0 license.
According to the release blogpost [0], "SQL Support [...]is an improved version of the elasticsearch-sql plugin."
Sounds like they are building on it, as you suggested.
[0] https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/aws/new-open-distro-for-elastic....
Looks like it was. https://github.com/opendistro-for-elasticsearch/security-ssl...
floragunn GmbH Copyright 2015-2018 floragunn GmbH
https://github.com/opendistro-for-elasticsearch/security/blo...
More generally: why should AWS get to leverage its near-monopolistic position in the SaaS market to perform essentially hostile takeovers of the software projects it packages and runs? Simply because they have the resources to do it?
The code was open, and the company decided to close it for the new versions, so it forks. Forks are common when people don't like the corporate direction of an OSS project - It's a strength, not a weakness. Openoffice/Libreoffice, Hudson/Jenkins etc.
Imagine if Linus said that the next version of Linux would be paid-only.
Within 15 minutes there'd be a new librelinux repo that people could contribute to instead.
Someone was going to make a new fork anyway - This is Amazon putting their money where their mouth is to fund and support that new fork.
Would you feel the same if AWS built a drop in/api compatible system from scratch?
[1] https://www.elastic.co/blog/elastic-stack-6-5-4-released
>>This means that the majority of new Elasticsearch users are now, in fact, running proprietary software. We have discussed our concerns with Elastic, the maintainers of Elasticsearch, including offering to dedicate significant resources to help support a community-driven, non-intermingled version of Elasticsearch. They have made it clear that they intend to continue on their current path.
... maybe I'm misreading your comment, but it sounds like AWS tried to find a compromise, including contributing to upstream, and were shut down (and all their content about future contributing seems to say "we'll send it upstream, but it depends on whether Elastic accepts it," so seems to corroborate). It honestly seems like you get more certainty that everything you're using from AWS is open and will remain open, and Elastic is going to keep creating uncertainty / drive to proprietary source-available.
That said, I also totally understand disagreements with Elastic’s decisions on charging for security, etc and why that causes concern. As a user I wish I wasn’t staring a fork in the face and I’m hopeful things get back to equilibrium here soon as a single community.
By forking on an earlier instance of the codebase for ES and Kibana they're not only creating an open source version of the code but also attempting a fork of the community - plugin developers, user groups, etc. It's extremely frustrating. EDIT: If folks actively building plugins have felt pain here because of decisions by Elastic, then my view on this point changes considerably, obviously.
I find it very hard to believe there was no compromise to be had here between the current Elastic roadmap for their product and their previous work.
How is this good for users of the current tools? How does this help create better capabilities on a common platform? Will this encourage users to build businesses on elasticsearch open source elements?
I'm not sure where the community ends up after this, so I'm not sure I can support by using AWS' elasticsearch tools.