News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by dexen on Monday March 11, 2019 @10:05AM (#19359029)
>Currently (...)

Way to start with a false premise. The meme died out by now[1].

> The phrase “Learn to Code” was initially posted on Twitter after the layoffs at BuzzFeed and the Huffington Post.

Way to continue with a false premise.

The phrase was used literally [2], and the subject was referenced [3] by numerous newspapers and other media outlets back when the economy was tanking, as a helpful suggestion to laid off workers - miners, autoworkers, and so on. "Those jobs aren't coming back" and all that. The only concern back then was of practicality, and nobody in their right mind considered it to be a put down of the workes, or of programmers.

Yes, the phrase may seem insensitive from our, programmer's, POV. Nonetheless, there's a historical precedent to it, based off of much wider segment of society than just programmers.

I find it shameful that Twitter, in its infinite wisdom, decided to suppress the accompanying hashtag, and later on even went as far started penalizing the posters. It used to be understood as a good idea back then, it's still considered a good idea now-a-day. I think it was shot down only for the expediency of keeping the journalists a-buzz on Twitter.

--

[1] https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=today%203-m&q=...

[2] https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/katienotopoulos/should-...

[3] https://gigaom.com/2014/04/09/michael-bloomberg-you-cant-tea... and https://www.wired.com/2015/11/can-you-teach-a-coal-miner-to-...

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by lm28469 on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:06AM (#19359480)
> Way to start with a false premise. The meme died out by now

Change the dates and look at the graph, I don't think you can say such a trend died by looking at the last 90 days.

https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&q=%22learn...

We still see articles about teaching kids to code, either at home or in school almost weekly on HN.

[dead]
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by TheShrug on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:01PM (#19359945)
I appreciate your diligence, but I'm having a real tough time following any argument you are making. I feel like you are receiving downvotes because you come off as sounding secure in your perspective but your arguments appear rather aimless.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by pxc on Wednesday March 13, 2019 @11:49AM (#19379841)
You're right— I wasn't really building up to an argument. I criticized my parent post and then essentially made an assertion that the ‘#learntocode’ meme is essentially bad faith, and gestured at what seems to me to be the obvious motivation for that.

Part of the reason is that I haven't done a comprehensive historical investigation of the meme. What I have done is actually read the handful of articles that I've seen used to support it (here and elsewhere), and examined who have been involved in propagating it, and drawn a conclusion that I think is pretty obvious if you know the terrain.

Like a lot of HN comments, it was something that I hastily typed at work in between other tasks. I'll think about returning to the subject for a more thorough examination if I have time. :)

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by dexen on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:05AM (#19359472)
>no, no, no, edgelords and /pol/tards

Please consider providing a positive narrative - "this started a trend, this expanded it, that was the result, here's where we are at presently, that's the expected future". Picking apart a succinct and sourced (even if weakly) post is much less convincing.

Having been part of the "culture war"[1], I nonetheless couldn't just post my lived experience here, as it wouldn't stand on its own. Thus I went out of my way to build up narrative from supporting sources. It's not exactly how I perceived it personally, but that's the closest version I could support with sources, i.e., as close to objective as I could provide in under 15 minutes or so.

--

[1] I'm using different moniker for the purpose, due to the high tensions and the mudslinging involved.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by etg34525 on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:24AM (#19359632)
I'm also looking for sources... and finding none that justify harassing journalists like this.

I had this vague recollection of "learn to code" being spouted by different publications. But the more I look into it, the more I think we're just mis-remembering news stories from the time.

All I'm finding are articles about Rusty Justice. That's not a journalist telling miners to code. At least not directly. Maybe that's the implicit message. But I think that's reading into it too much. It's a human interest story, not a prescription.

I think a lot of people are angry at the media, and looking for anything to validate that anger. There's no shortage of media scandals you could point to. But in this specific case, I'm not seeing evidence. Maybe journalists deserve more credit.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by pxc on Wednesday March 13, 2019 @11:45AM (#19379804)
I'd be more interested in the experience that you mentioned, if you're willing to share it. Individual personal experiences aren't compelling in the way that certain arguments can be, but there's also some inherent validity (and for me at least, interest) to them even when if they're not necessarily representative.