News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by smush on Monday March 11, 2019 @09:33AM (#19358808)
So this meme didn't come from nowhere. Blue collar professions have been given this 'helpful advice' by journalists quite a bit over the years. It was tone deaf then, and still so now. I admit I don't yet see why it's verboten/'toxic' to parrot this same tone deaf advice to journalists now?

I admit I haven't wandered through the more dilapidated internet street corners lately, so perhaps it's become toxic due to the sheer volume of use where its no longer something to be seen in good fun, or perhaps we are running low on goodwill as a society to be able to enjoy a joke?

Setting that entire matter aside, the article has (to me) a somewhat tenuous argument that saying the tone deaf joke of 'learn to code' is disrespectful to programmers and the like. I'm not sure about that, but I don't have a coherent reason to articulate that just yet.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by SilasX on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:27AM (#19359653)
>So this meme didn't come from nowhere. Blue collar professions have been given this 'helpful advice' by journalists quite a bit over the years. It was tone deaf then, and still so now. I admit I don't yet see why it's verboten/'toxic' to parrot this same tone deaf advice to journalists now?

Right. This short, low-effort article doesn't seem to be aware of the context of the meme, and how it's just spitting back the very meme that journalists were promoting. Of course if you're not aware of that context, or didn't take the effort to research it, then the meme will seem more trollish and less poetic than it is.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by 0-_-0 on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:44AM (#19359793)
I agree, the writer of this piece isn't doing a good job as a journalist. Maybe he should learn to code...
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by mc32 on Monday March 11, 2019 @10:42AM (#19359311)
I guess the media don't like getting a clap back [since they stated it years ago when "those jobs ain't coming back" and so on]; they like to be the ones dishing it out.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by onlydeadheroes on Monday March 11, 2019 @10:15AM (#19359105)
> I admit I don't yet see why it's verboten/'toxic' to parrot this same tone deaf advice to journalists now?

Because journalists are better than you. This is the only "reality" the media are interested in pushing forward. It underlies every weird thing coming out of the media in the last few years.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by kristianc on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:30AM (#19359674)
This was also implicit in the way Twitter dealt with it. Tweeting "Learn to Code" was fine, tweeting it at a journalist would get you banned.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by hashberry on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:13AM (#19359532)
I think sexism is also involved. Media professions attract more women (my journalism and marketing classes were filled with women). And the media loves to cover the gender gap in STEM. So now it's a bunch of guys tweeting to women telling them to "Learn to Code" after said women complain about getting laid off or career difficulties.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by leereeves on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:18AM (#19359578)
So what? Women journalists comment on male careers all the time, what's wrong with the reverse?

Unless you're prepared to apply that "sexism" standard equally, you're being sexist by applying unequal standards.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by onlydeadheroes on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:28AM (#19359667)
Actually these people redefined sexism and racism as "doesn't count when applied to the sex/race I dislike". I wish I was joking but this is the state of the art in academia.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by msla on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:42PM (#19360367)
> Actually these people redefined sexism and racism as "doesn't count when applied to the sex/race I dislike". I wish I was joking but this is the state of the art in academia.

This is a great place to talk about something I've observed about academic ideas like these, which I'll call the difference between Academic and Vulgar, by analogy to "Vulgar Libertarianism" and "Vulgar Socialism":

There's a difference between Academic Positions and Vulgar Positions, where Academic Positions are defined as being the ones academics write papers about and Vulgar Positions are the ones average people who support those Positions use in day-to-day discourse, especially in discussions with others. This is a convenient feature: Academic Positions are nuanced and logically defensible, whereas Vulgar Positions are simple, pugnacious, and useful in street-fight debates where you primarily want to shut down the person you're opposed to.

Intersectionality has a Vulgar form: "Check your privilege!" In the Academic sense, that statement is, at most, a gentle reminder to examine the totality of a situation before judging it. In the Vulgar sense, it's a way to shut someone down by stating that they're "privileged" and are, therefore, unworthy of having a judgement at all. In the Academic sense, saying someone is "privileged" is nonsensical, or perhaps tautological, in that everyone has some position where they're privileged and some positions where they're disadvantaged, so saying that a person is privileged is not very meaningful. In the Vulgar sense, "privilege" absolutely does adhere to individuals, and people with "privilege" must never disagree with those without.

Anyway, the Academic form is the only one officially acknowledged to exist, whereas the Vulgar form is the lived experience, the one which drives actions and policies. Therefore, the Vulgar form is never seriously discussed, because when you mention its features, the person you're discussing it with will deny that their philosophy has those features, as, indeed, the Academic form does not.

This isn't motte-and-bailey because there are plenty of people who honestly don't hold the Vulgar position and who would argue against it if someone expressed it to their face. This isn't a tactic, it's the inability of the academic world to communicate their ideas in a nuanced fashion, and the unpalatability of nuanced ideas to people who just want a fight.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by hashberry on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:20AM (#19359595)
Look up James Damore. When men comment on women's career choices, they get fired. And now men are getting banned from Twitter. Probably because "sexism."
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by leereeves on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:23AM (#19359623)
You may be right. It's a a sexist double standard, but in certain circles, it's essentially forbidden for a man to criticize a woman in any way, while it's permissible for a woman to say anything she likes about men, however hateful.

And those circles do seem to have a lot of overlap with the circles that consider the "Learn to Code" meme "toxic".

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by apacheCamel on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:56AM (#19359899)
I think these certain circles are quite small but the emphasis is put on them and many people, whether they agree or not, are put into the circle for viewing the "Learn to Code" meme as toxic. I agree that telling blue collar workers to learn to code originally was tone deaf and these journalists should be scolded for it but I also assume that not every journalist was on the "holier than thou" train.

We should just be better to each other. Don't fight their ignorance with the same ignorance, it is just making the world a meaner place in my opinion.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by hellllllllooo on Monday March 11, 2019 @02:53PM (#19361723)
> When men comment on women's career choices, they get fired.

James Damore circulated a long unscientific document critical of female engineers as a whole at his place of work. This is far more than just "commenting on career choices".

He made a frankly stupid choice to be unprofessional and it cost him his job. Beyond anything else his judgement was poor. It's fair as is dismissal for other unprofessional behavior at work or for incredibly poor decision making.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by forgottenpass on Monday March 11, 2019 @02:34PM (#19361513)
>the article has (to me) a somewhat tenuous argument that saying the tone deaf joke of 'learn to code' is disrespectful to programmers and the like

Yeah, seems off to me too. If there's anything about the whole thing that's disrespectful to programmers, it's that journos think programming as a career path is beneath them.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by msla on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:34PM (#19360287)
> So this meme didn't come from nowhere. Blue collar professions have been given this 'helpful advice' by journalists quite a bit over the years. It was tone deaf then, and still so now. I admit I don't yet see why it's verboten/'toxic' to parrot this same tone deaf advice to journalists now?

Because you're taking a meme meant for low-income low-prestige men and applying it to members of a high-income high-prestige mixed group.

You are, in short, reducing the status of the journalists to those of unemployed coal miners. Hell, you might as well slap a paper hat on their heads and tell them to man a fryer. It's "problematic" and "toxic" to be reminded that you can fall in the class structure like that.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by 0815test on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:45PM (#19360399)
I don't think it has anything to do with income - journalism is not an especially "high income" career path. It's all about culture, cliques and good-old-boy networks - here as perhaps in other cases, journalists are relying on a rather context-specific sort of "prestige" in an effort to escape this sort of attack/criticism.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by etg34525 on Monday March 11, 2019 @10:22AM (#19359165)
Did all the journalists being targeted by this actually tell blue collar workers to learn coding? I've searched on my own and found articles about "this company in west virginia that's training coal miners to code" or "jobs that will be automated in 10 years - is your's next?", but I don't specifically see or recall journalists telling displaced workers that coding would fix their problems. If anyone here can provide examples of that, I would appreciate it.

If this was a widespread thing that many journalists spouted, I understand the outcry. If only a few journalists spouted this nonsense, then I don't think it's fair to punish an entire industry over some bad apples.

What I suspect is that the "learn to code" push was more of a society-wide meme trafficked by politicians, economists, and tech CEOs. And I have to imagine that some journalists gave those people a platform. But perhaps I'm looking at the wrong evidence?

EDIT: dexen's post found maybe one example: A Buzzfeed quiz that suggests coding could become the next blue collar profession. That kind of fits the "learn to code" meme. The other articles dexen posted were actually counter to that - An article where Michael Bloomberg said learning to code is unrealistic for many displaced workers, and another article about coal miners proving him wrong.

Is that it? Or are there more examples?

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by leereeves on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:17AM (#19359567)
Whether it was journalists pushing it, or "politicians, economists, and tech CEOs" pushing it, and journalists merely repeating it, I don't know.

But I definitely remember hearing that message in the media for the last 20 years, and I don't recall anyone calling it "trolling" until it was directed at journalists.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by etg34525 on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:34AM (#19359712)
Well it's important to know what was actually said and who said it. If, by and large, journalists did not actually advocate for displaced workers to code their way out of unemployment, then harassing them with #learntocode is unjustified.

I've wasted the entire morning looking for sources of this by now. Like you, I sort of remembered hearing that message over the years. But now that I'm looking, I'm not actually finding many examples where news outlets are seriously suggesting this.

Have you ever thought you knew something, but end up misremembering it? There are lots of people who swear they remember a movie called Shazzam staring Sinbad as a genie, but there is no such movie. There was a movie called Kazaam staring Shaquille O'Neal, and Sinbad once dressed up in similar garb when hosting a movie showing. But people conflated the two things.

I think that's whats going on. And if so, we should not be harassing journalists who had nothing to do with this.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by onlydeadheroes on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:30AM (#19359678)
> punish

The whole point is that it wasn't a punishment when some journalists did it, but it's a punishement when some journalists hear it. So, they are full of crap.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by etg34525 on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:37AM (#19359735)
> it wasn't a punishment when some journalists did it,

But when did they do it? and who? Please send me any evidence you have. I feel like I'm going crazy here. Not finding anything.

Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by hellllllllooo on Monday March 11, 2019 @01:33PM (#19360888)
Retraining is one of the options when an industrial sector shrinks. Suggesting a growing industry like software development as an option doesn't deserve a "punishment" unless it was spiteful in some way. Mocking journalists, or anyone else, who has lost their job is the toxic part of this.
Re:Why the “Learn to Code” Meme Is Toxic and Shouldn't Be Used by apacheCamel on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:59AM (#19359929)
I agree with your sentiment. I don't recall this being such a widespread thing. I think it is fine to scold the people who originally made these remarks (I myself do not remember who particular started the "Learn To Code" platform) but we should leave it at that. Just getting more upset about it and involving journalists who were never originally involved is a bad idea to just keep upsetting more and more people.