News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by paultopia on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:20AM (#19358370)
Um. "I don't keep a calendar" means "I consider my time more important than yours, so we'll meet at my sole convenience." I would love to do that, but everyone else in the world would rightly understand it that way and would treat it as a refusal to do core elements of my job.

A: "Let's schedule a committee meeting."

B: "I don't keep a calendar."

A: "So what you're saying is everyone else on the committee has to find time just for you? Fuck you, do your job."

Arnold Schwarzenegger could get away with that crap because he's a fabulously wealthy A-list movie star. The rest of us, not so much.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by coldtea on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:51AM (#19358545)
>Um. "I don't keep a calendar" means "I consider my time more important than yours, so we'll meet at my sole convenience." I would love to do that, but everyone else in the world would rightly understand it that way and would treat it as a refusal to do core elements of my job.

The advice is for free persons, not for us salaried workers.

(Not to mention that TFA already covers this: "I'm totally serious. If you pull it off -- and in many structured jobs, you simply can't" and again later: "Clearly this only works if you can get away with it. If you have a structured job, a structured job environment, or you're a CEO, it will be hard to pull off.").

See also: https://medium.com/incerto/how-to-legally-own-another-person...

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:36AM (#19359725)
So basically it's for the already affluent. "If you're rich and have no obligations only work when you want to" doesn't seem that novel. It's productivity when there's little value on said productivity.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by coldtea on Monday March 11, 2019 @04:46PM (#19362643)
You don't have to be affluent. You can be e.g. a freelancer graphic designer making at most 50-60K a year and do that. Or have a small company and do that. Or be a farmer and do that.

But the conclusion seems wrong "It's productivity when there's little value on said productivity." -- the productivity of the affluent has even more value (at least monetarily) than the productivity of some office worker.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 11, 2019 @04:55PM (#19362731)
You can be a designer whose willing to burn bridges and don't need to pay a mortgage, but yeah, you could be someone who doesn't need stuff. I'd love to see a farmer put off feeding the animals or not keep a schedule. "I'll just harvest the crops next month."

>Want to spend all day writing a research report? Do it!

>Want to spend all day coding? Do it!

>Want to spend all day at the cafe down the street reading a book on personal productivity? Do it!

These are not things someone who needs to work for a living can do, picking and choosing activities at their leisure.

Regarding "little value on said productivity", I meant value to the individual, not to society as a whole. If you can afford to squander opportunities clearly whatever you're producing isn't as vital to you as for others who need the productivity to continue be able to afford to live.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by coldtea on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @03:22AM (#19366057)
>These are not things someone who needs to work for a living can do, picking and choosing activities at their leisure.

It's not what someone who needs to work on somebody else's spec can do.

A writer living off his books, for example, even if they make just 50K/year, can shape their days however they want.

Or, to return to the freelancer, if you have a specialty, and people can to you, you can be picky about what jobs you do and when.

I know people that are like that and they are by no means rich.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by SketchySeaBeast on Tuesday March 12, 2019 @09:53AM (#19368104)
Do novelist never attend meetings by their publisher? Same with freelancers - can you just blow off your client and commit to nothing?
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by muzani on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:54AM (#19359881)
I think the idea here is to minimize scheduling. Take note that this advice comes from a top VC; meetings are his bread and butter.

Not committing to a schedule greatly cuts down on the number of meetings. Most meetings are unnecessary, a huge cost to productivity. He also doesn't advice avoiding them, more like if it's important and high priority enough, everyone can agree to do one now.

It cuts out the fat of scheduling an important meeting 3 days later because a bunch of execs had 3 days of not so important meetings already scheduled.

Also one part of how Andreessen-Horowitz operates is that they absolutely cut out the wait time for founders trying to meet them. This is a part of that efficiency. They have to leave the rest of their hours open.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by paultopia on Monday March 11, 2019 @01:35PM (#19360919)
Hmm. It seems to me, but I'm not sure so please correct me, that a top VC is someone to whom others mostly come as supplicants, and hence can demand scheduling on his convenience rather than theirs.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by muzani on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:59PM (#19363274)
To be a top VC, the VC has to land the top deals (Uber, Airbnb, etc). They land top deals by being attractive to top founders. The best startups often move very rapidly, having 10% week on week growth and such. Every hour is valuable to them. Partners are fined $10 for every minute they are late to a meeting, which gives an idea of how strongly they hold to the principle.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by operakadabra on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:01AM (#19359442)
Good point, but actually, to you, your time is more important than everyone else's. You need to put yourself first.

When the oxygen mask falls from the ceiling of the airplane you're instructed to put yours on before helping others. You're not going to be helping anyone if you pass out.

And by the way, both you and Arnold Schwarzenegger are human beings and able to have some of the same experiences. Putting yourself down is not helpful.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:39AM (#19359748)
Arnold Schwarzenegger can afford to lose a job, and his personal productivity can't make or break his ability to pay this month's mortgage.

You have to be willing to work with people, and you have to work with more powerful people on their terms.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by glitchc on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:55AM (#19359891)
Hmmm.. Are you secretly hoping that these powerful people will raise you to their level someday? Give you a just reward for your serfdom?
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:30PM (#19360251)
No, I'm saying if my boss tells me to be at a meeting everyday at 10 and I'm not there for 2 weeks I'm probably going to get fired.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by glitchc on Monday March 11, 2019 @03:53PM (#19362189)
Punctuality is overrated in general, and especially in software. Most meetings are a waste of time because no decision is made in them.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by SketchySeaBeast on Monday March 11, 2019 @04:27PM (#19362486)
Wearing pants are overrated in general and a waste of time as well, but I'd be in trouble for forgetting them when going into the office as well.

One day we may need to call a meeting that no one thinks is worth their attention. There's plenty of hoops that one must work through in one's day to day that we just have to put up if we want to keep the business moving.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by dragonwriter on Monday March 11, 2019 @04:07PM (#19362292)
> Most meetings are a waste of time because no decision is made in them.

Most meetings are a waste of time, true.

No decisions are made in most meetings, also true.

But the former is not caused by the latter; making decisions isn't the only productive reason to have a meeting.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by lazyasciiart on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:13PM (#19360065)
Where did that come from?
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by meuk on Monday March 11, 2019 @01:28PM (#19360836)
That's like the first point he makes:

  I'm totally serious. If you pull it off -- and in many structured jobs, you simply can't -- this simple tip alone can make a huge difference in productivity.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by paultopia on Monday March 11, 2019 @01:33PM (#19360897)
"Structured job" apparently means "job," though. Frankly, anyone who doesn't have a so-called "structured job" or any obligations to anyone else entitled to demand some of their time is probably rich enough already that they don't need "productivity advice."
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by blastbeat on Monday March 11, 2019 @08:46AM (#19358512)
Fully agree. Also the rest of the article has questionable advice. I doubt the helpfulness of later lists and anti todo lists. Not answering the phone or pretending to be incompetent sounds like an idiotic idea too.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by operakadabra on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:10AM (#19359506)
Nobody is promising that every suggestion will work for you. Try everything until you find something that does work.
Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by BeetleB on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:51AM (#19359859)
>I doubt the helpfulness of later lists and anti todo lists.

Before I break down some of the advice, keep in mind that he is talking about productivity. There are some jobs where his advice will not work. But I contend those jobs are designed in a way that necessarily limit your productivity. As an example, SW developers complain about context switching. I assure you, there are jobs where context switching is more or less necessary. I wouldn't criticize Marc's advice because it won't work for that kind of a job. I'd point out that the job is fundamentally one where productivity is limited.

Getting to the details:

Later lists are essentially Someday/Maybe in GTD, so it's not a radical concept. Personally, I've treated it as a dumping ground of things just to get them out of my head. If I'm not going to do it any time soon, I want it somewhere that is not my head. Now I've never found the contents of the list useful. It's usually so huge that it's not worth my time to go back to it.

As for Anti-Todo list, it's a psychological hack, so I'm not sure how you can say it is useful or not. It's strictly not a productivity technique. If it eases your mind, it works. Otherwise not.

I'm not anti-phone as he is, but if I substitute phone calls with texting and IM's, I fully agree. They are usually productivity sinks. I've found phones to be good for things where one cannot reasonably wait. Obviously, this is not going to work for projects that require continual, quick decisions. I think he is merely self selecting: He does only projects where phone calls are not as important.

As for strategic incompetence, he makes the criterion clear:

>Of course, this assumes that there are other things that are more important at which you are competent.

Look around your workplace. In mine, this is what more senior people do all the time. They have more important work to do, and they'll first try to convince managers the annoying work they're being asked to do is not a good use of their time (takes time away from more important work). 70+% of the time, this is enough. When it isn't, it's not unusual to see them do a poor job, at which time managers assign the work to a more junior person.

It does work, as long as their is a junior person who can do the work.

Limiting email time is effective. Whenever I've interviewed, I've asked whether I can do the job if I check email only three times a day. In reality, I check it a lot more often. But I've been burned by having a job where too much work was done over email with an expectation to respond quickly (e.g. within an hour). Having to drop all your work several times a day to answer lots of questions is not good for productivity.

Re:Pmarca Guide to Personal Productivity (2007) by 0x262d on Monday March 11, 2019 @11:27AM (#19359655)
difficult to believe the article isn't satire