News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by lemming on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @06:08PM (#1935765)
Great comment, thanks.

former employees can be written right out of the deal

Can you elaborate on this? How does this work? As a holder of a lot of common stock in an increasingly VC-dominated company, this is interesting to me - surely if I buy my shares, I have that proportion of the company with the same rights as any other common stock holder? What about a "normal" acquisition deal could change that?

Re:How much startup stock options are worth by URSpider94 on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:31PM (#1935987)
Key phrase: tyranny of the majority.

You can bet that the founders and VC's (or other institutional investors) own a super-majority of the shares. Therefore, they can simply write the rules to give themselves whatever they want. For even more fun, sub-groups of VC's can team up to force out founders or other VC's.

One way this is typically done is to increase the share count by 10X, then sell these new shares for 10 cents on the dollar to a sub-group of new investors.

As an existing shareholder, you MAY have the right to buy into such a deal, but only if you are a "qualified investor", meaning that you have substantial liquid wealth. Otherwise, you'll be left sitting on the sidelines.

Even in a "normal" acquisition, the current shareholders will have to vote on the deal, so it's not uncommon for the large shareholders to cut lucrative side deals with the buyer that give them much more profit than the average shareholder.

Re:How much startup stock options are worth by tptacek on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:17PM (#1936245)
This all sounds plausible but note that the owners don't even have to intend to screw you out of your equity to screw you out of your equity. All that has to happen is for the company valuation to come in under the value of liquidation preferences, or for the deal to be so tight that much of the return is structured as an earnout for existing employees.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by danshapiro on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:33PM (#1936271)
One mistake in the above: the right to participate in future financing rounds has nothing to do with qualified investor status, and everything to do with whether your agreement guarantees it. Good CEOs will often make sure all their investors are given a chance to participate (because it's the right thing to do and reduces the chance of one class of lawsuits) but it's only a guarantee if your documents say it is.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by tptacek on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:42PM (#1936294)
I was locked out of an investment round at one company because of qualification status. I'm pretty sure being meeting the accredited investor standard actually does matter, at least if you're not an employee and the round involves an exchange of money for financial instruments.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by danshapiro on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @04:26AM (#1936923)
If your agreement had guaranteed you investment rights you would have had them. Since it didn't, it was at their discretion, and they could have used many different criteria to make that decision. Now as a general rule, when you have an option in the matter, you don't want non-accredited investors in your deal. But assuming that accredited status grants follow-on investment rights (or that lack of them prevents it) as a rule is wrong.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by skinnymuch on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:12PM (#1936091)
Did Facebook's Eduardo Saverin get 5% of Facebook back because he was singled out? If more stock holders were pushed out, would Saverin not have gotten 5% back?
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by tptacek on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @06:59PM (#1935891)
VC and founders, holding preferred shares, take money off the table first. If things get tight, later VC's may take 2+x preferences. Deals can be structured that return cash to the VC, wipe out the rest of the equity, and leave existing employees grants or bonuses for retention; this latter deal element is an incentive extended by the acquiring company, not an entitlement owed shareholders.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by timr on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:32PM (#1935990)
Concrete example -- Slide's acquisition:

http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/g/a/2010/08/06/...

The later investors just barely made their money back, so the employee options were (probably) worthless as well. Google issued new retention to make up for the fact that the employees got squashed, but not every acquirer is so generous.

Re:How much startup stock options are worth by lemming on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:24PM (#1935968)
Is it normal for founders to have preferred shares? In our case the founders all have common stock (albeit a lot of it), and in fact it came with more restrictions than normal common stock, namely a 3-year restricted stock period similar to an option vesting period.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by tptacek on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:35PM (#1935998)
Dunno, but note that founders often hold board states, and VC has an incentive to make sure they can take some money off the table, else they can make it harder to complete the best deal VC thinks they can get, in the name of holding out for an actual return.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by danshapiro on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @04:27AM (#1936924)
That's very normal; founders usually have mostly common, and sometimes have extra restrictions. The other commenter is right, though - anyone with influence in a transaction typically comes out better, and founders are often in such a position.
Re:How much startup stock options are worth by trotsky on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:04PM (#1935906)
I can't tell you the best or even the most modern ways, but one of the simpler ways I've seen this done is a massive dilution where key owners (investors, founders) have anti-dilution clauses coupled with new grants and acceleration for current employees. This works even if the liquidity event is so massive everyone involved is recouping well past their preferences.

My impression is that options agreements and grants that offer any real protection against being screwed once the company lacks any incentive to keep you happy are few and far between. If you don't _know_ you're protected from such things, you're undoubtedly not.