News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by reinhardt on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @05:47PM (#1935695)
The problem is that "face" is a quite common word by itself, they didn't make it up or pick it from some obscure source like "google" or "yahoo". It's outrageous to claim ownership of a word on the whole Web centuries after it entered the language, regardless of their popularity at this moment. What's next, YouTube trademarking the use of "you" ?

(On second thoughts that wouldn't be so bad; I'm sick of all the wannabe you*.com trying to piggyback on a silly name)

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by jerf on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:53PM (#1936039)
A lot of people here need to spend some serious time learning about trademarks, for instance: http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/metaschool/fisher/domain/tm.htm

Stop panicking. Trademark abuse is not unheard of, but if anything we technologists grossly overestimate how often it actually happens because we've seen domain names getting "stolen", for various values of stolen, by claiming trademark ownership over domain names. (And for that matter, much of the "trademark abuse" is really ICANN abuse rather than trademark abuse, it's really ICANN's decision. If they take the domain name because of a bribe or even "just because", you still wouldn't be able to do much.) But it's actually an importan aspect of the law, and even if you're of a mind to throw out patents and copyright entirely, you really need to stop and think some more about throwing out trademarks. What a trademark boils down to is a mark that allows you to identify when you are dealing with an entity. Trademark violation is when you mark yourself in such a way as to cause people to confuse who you are. There's hardly a model of society I can think of from the rabid left to the rabid right and all the things that don't fit on that scale where it's actually desirable to let entities falsely masquerade as other entities. Most of them are actually so deeply built on being able to identify the people you are dealing with that you can't hardly even see it any more, it's just part of the background fabric.

And yes, Lamebook and Facebook are very confusable. Don't ask your tech savvy friends, just take a picture of the two websites, go somewhere that isn't a tech hub, stop ten people on the street, and ask them if these sites look like they are from the same company. You'll get your answer pretty quickly, I think. Companies spin off subbrands all the time.

(And read the link carefully for what it says, not what you think you can twist it into if you read certain words in certain ways. Remember, your arguments don't have to convince me, or convince some pathologically stupid AI, they have to convince a human judge, who has spent the past twenty years listening to people trying to twist and bend the text of the law in their favor.)

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by cabalamat on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:55PM (#1936194)
> Lamebook and Facebook are very confusable.

Oh come off it. Next you'll be saying that people think "Microsoft sucks" is an official Microsoft site, or that "Chimpy Bushitler" is the official name of the previous US president. It's called parody, and anyone with two brain cells to rub together gets it.

> just take a picture of the two websites

You don't even need that. Would any company call its own product "lame"?

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by jerf on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @10:47PM (#1936427)
First, a bit of an apology is in order. I had somehow picked up the idea that Lamebook is trying to be a business, not just a blog. (Though selling shirts may turn out to have been a mistake in hindsight, I don't see that as a business.)

That said, even as parody is a defense it's still not a blank check. For instance, see http://www.lfiplaw.com/articles/trademark_parody.htm . And, again, read the whole thing. It's way less clear-cut than you might think; they've got a couple points in their favor and quite a few against.

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by biot on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @02:33AM (#1936780)
> It's called parody, and anyone with two brain cells to rub together gets it.

Or if you throw in a few more brain cells, it's called satire.

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by lwhi on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @05:46AM (#1937019)
.. or chuck just a few more into the mix, and realise that parody is a satirical device :)
Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by run4yourlives on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:14PM (#1936093)
I would seriously hope that HackerNews possesses a deeper sense of business knowledge than what has been demonstrated in the parent comment.

A trademark is not a copyright. It is not "claiming ownership". It doesn't mean that you have to pay facebook royalties every time you utter shock at how ugly you are when you look in the mirror.

A trademark is a brand, and because of all the things that come with a recognized brand, it is imperative that a business be allowed to operate without every two bit imitator confusing customers by making (possibly inferior) products that look and feel like an authentic experience.

My only wish is that the outraged do some reading.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trademark

They aren't restricting the use of the work "face", they are claiming ownership of the exact way that particular brand is represented, hence the image.

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by cabalamat on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:00PM (#1936206)
> It is not "claiming ownership".

facebook are asserting a right to prevent other people using the word "face" in particular ways.

In comparison, copyright is a right to prevent other people using particular words, pictures, sounds, etc, in particular ways. If copyright is "ownership" then so are trademarks too. Furthermore, trademarks can be bought and sold, another indication that they are a form of property.

So, yes, it isn't too much of a stretch to say that facebook are claiming a (limited) form of ownership over the word "face".

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by run4yourlives on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:13PM (#1937898)
No, that is completely ass backwards.

Trademark is saying that a particular look, feel, phrase or whatnot normally represents the company or organization and as such it is owned by the company as an identity. It's the exact same thing as your personal signature, which I'm sure you have a vested interest in.

Copyright is a creation of something new, (or the idea of the intent to create something) that says you aren't allowed to use it period unless you ask for the creator's permission, since it isn't yours. This include copying it exactly.

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by ChristianMarks on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @02:01AM (#1936727)
Incidentally, protecting trademarks is a social program for business. Proponents of smaller government and libertarian ideals seem not to want the government to get out of the trademark business.
Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by patrickaljord on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @05:53PM (#1935711)
How about windows?
Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by alextgordon on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:06PM (#1936467)
The equivalent would be Microsoft trademarking "Win" (come to think of it, they probably have done that).
Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by JimmyL on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:27PM (#1935978)
>> claim ownership of a word on the whole Web

That's not what they're doing - they're claiming exclusive use of the word FACE in the restricted context of online chat and bulletin board applications. While I can think of a few groups that are innocent and may fall under this (bulletin boards that focus on the study of faces), for the most part it seems like anyone who's using that word in this context would be trying to poach off of Facebook's notoriety to increase the value of their brand.

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by drusenko on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:47PM (#1936026)
Dove for soap is another example. It's very clear that Dove soap is a brand name, and should be protected.

It seems likely that Facebook is just trying to go as far as the government will let them.

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by Terretta on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:55PM (#1936049)
Except for your example to be accurate, "Dove" would be trademarking the first half of their name, "Do", and then going around suing anyone using "Do" in their name.

Look out Nike, can't use "Do" in "Just Do It" any more, people might confuse it with "Do"ve.

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by biot on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @02:22AM (#1936758)
Then how about McDonald's as an example of this? Do you think they wouldn't unleash the lawyers if you opened a restaurant and started selling a McBurger with McFries and a McShake?
Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by Terretta on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @08:29AM (#1937243)
Great example. The corner pub called McDougals would have a thing or two to say about it. Their fries are good, too. McDonald's doesn't get to split their name in half and trademark them separately. They can trademark McShake, but not Shake. They can trademark McFries, but not Fries.

Facebook shouldn't get Face or Book. Those are not their name, and the words alone are far too generic.

Microsoft doesn't get to trademark Micro or soft. Dove doesn't get to trademark Do or ve. Facebook doesn't get to trademark Face or Book.

They can try, are trying, but letting them own the word "book" (or even "face") is ridiculous. And it could even be argued that the term "facebook" was in too common a use as a social directory description long before FB made it electronic.

Re:As of today, Facebook is one step away from trademarking ... by ig1 on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @08:40AM (#1937266)
They have infact done so on multiple occasions:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McDonalds_legal_cases

EasyGroup and Starbucks have both been involved in similar trademark lawsuits.