This is not correct. Insurance is a very valuable service to prevent high-risk events, and applying insurance is a very hard problem. You need to do economics, operations, fight fraud, etc.
What does create price insensitivity (and thus doesnt allow for the competition that drives down prices and increases value to happen naturally) is that you use healthcare for menial transactions like annual checkups or sick visits. I find it incredible when people complain about the 150U$S annual fee on OneMedical, when a basic check-up visit is billed between 300 and 500 dollars. Or when people get surprised that a cancellation fee for a primary care visit is 100 dollars, when "their copay is only 20 bucks".
In addition, another thing is that its tied to the employer, which means that you dont get to choose the insurance you want. If people had to choose their own insurance, insurances would cater to patients not to companies. This is probably the single most important change to do on healthcare reform, and one thing both Bernie Sanders and Republicans could agree with.
Given a choice between death and bankruptcy, most people will choose bankruptcy. There is no downward pressure on the cost of medical care because there is no alternative. It's a situation that capitalist market dynamics are just not equipped to address.
A state-run apparatus is the only thing that seems to work.
> Given a choice between death and bankruptcy, most people will choose bankruptcy. There is no downward pressure on the cost of medical care because there is no alternative
This is a common trope in this debate, but its not an economically sound argument. First of all, people choose this all the time: a european person does not sell their home and get indebted to pay for a trip to the us to get bleeding-edge 1% rate of success medical care for his unique condition. Second, its not medically sound. Medicine is absolutely practiced with economic considerations in mind. Care is not the same in the U.S. than say, an African country with hospital shortages. The doctors recommendation changes based on the patients sensibility to prices (for example, a doctor will not recommend highly expensive vitamins to the unemployed, or wont indulge in expensive out-of-coverage procedures for people who would find great economic suffering for the test alone).
This latter part is a key missing education link that for some reason the public seems to misunderstand. Its strange because in actual education people understand that prices give different qualities, but someone reject the idea that healthcare doesnt behave that way.
I have other counter-arguments to this notion of downward pressure, but fundamentally what makes prices low is competition. Any one would prefer bankrupcy to starvation, but thats not a problem with food isn't it.
People should be getting insurance from insurable events - i.e. accident, heart attack, etc. Not from routine vaccination, annual checkup, seasonal cold.
High-deductible plans are a hack to get people to pay for more of routine stuff and I think it moves into the right direction.
There is no up-front price. There is no market pressure. You still don't know what you will need to pay until weeks or months later.
In this way the insurance is actually an insurance like a car insurance, and not some bastardized medical payment plan where incentives of different parties aren't aligned.
I feel like you lump in a lot of preventative care in that statement. If your routine checkups / vaccination prevent necessary emergency care and thus save money down the line, not incentivization people to do so seems stupid to me. The insurance company would have to pay for it regardless, unless they manage to cut those cases from the body of their insured. That would feel a lot like preexisting conditions to me...
Having individuals pay for vaccinations also ignores the value of lost herd immunity, due to a prisoners dilemma like situation. But this mean vaccinations have to be provided by insurance. Directly funding it though tax money might be a better option.
"When the time came for his second round of DTaP, doctors talked with the family about the need for vaccinations. Surviving tetanus, unlike some other diseases, does not offer immunity in the future.
But despite an “extensive review” of the risks, and the benefits of vaccination, the article said, the family declined the second vaccination — or any other recommended immunization."
You need to be up to code to the last detail, you will be under scrutiny for your documentation, you have no bargaining power and medicare pays 20-50% less to providers than private insurance.
It is also not the same as PPO's (which most employees in HN must have) you will have a lot fewer options for care. (remember, you can only get a doctor that collects a much smaller fee, so forget about swanky offices and convenient locations)
Edit: not sure why the downvotes, that’s the reality of things. If you want a more fully fleshed out thought, here you go:
We would all contribute to the payment of expensive operations via taxes in a single payer system. In the current system we have insurance payments. It’s effectively the same, paying a small fee regularly, to subsidize the costs for expensive procedures for yourself and (surprise) others. What do you think happens if you pay into insurance your whole life and never need an expensive operation? You’re subsidizing others. Otherwise the insurance companies would be out of business.
But with single payer, we cut out companies in the middle pulling a heafty profit for effectively the same system as we could get via taxes.
Better?
That's just insurance, managed by the state.
> But with single payer, we cut out companies in the middle pulling a heafty profit
Oh boy. Lets say I concede, for the sake of argument, that government can run a private business with the same efficiency, and that the profits it would make as private are given back to its consumers (healthcare.gov cost almost 2 billion dollars to make, remember that. Or Blue shield is actually a non-profit, and its not gobbling up the space by reinvesting its supposed profits).
To add to that, the profits of healthcare insurances companies are not that large: they have a 6% operating margin, lower than other insurance companies. Cumulatively, the big companies must have around 20~30 billion dollars a year in profits. It's a staggering number, but in the healthspace thats nothing: only the subsidy of tax-exemption for insurance benefits is estimated to be 260 billion a year. You could eliminate that benefit and expand medicaid: but that would help the poor, and wreck the rich and the middle class together, which is often politically unfeasible.
https://www.axios.com/profits-are-booming-at-health-insuranc...
https://www.verywellhealth.com/health-insurance-companies-un...
As Steve Jobs said about Dropbox, you’re a feature (insurance companies) not a product.
Thats perfectly reasonable, but no need to make a single payer system for that. Just allow medicare to compete in the open market. Thats a much smaller program with a lot less risk.
Unfortunately the chances of such a plan to succeed are nil. Thats why big healthcare reform proposals want to strong-arm the position, with single-payer proposals. Its true medicare is popular, but remember it's free insurance for its patients today. If you eliminated the medicare payroll tax and made it a monthly payment, I assure you old people will not have the same opinion on the topic.
Unsurprisingly, private health insurance is not very popular here. It’s mostly just something people get through work.
And I’ll remind you that we spend less per capita on our healthcare than the US does. I’m sure that if there was actually demand to meet that spending, private insurance here would happily eat it up - but there just doesn’t seem to be.
Given that we spend less money on healthcare than countries that do have healthcare “on the open market” like you suggest, I’d say this is a system that obviously works.
If there were an imbalance between what those countries provide and what we provide, and people were willing to pay for it, you’d see private healthcare providers successfully taking more money (up to what Americans spend) to make up the gap in service - but they’re not. Do you have an explanation for why that’s not happening?
> Given that we spend less money on healthcare than countries that do have healthcare “on the open market” like you suggest, I’d say this is a system that obviously works.
Sorry but this is a ludicrous claim. Argentina spends 2% less of GDP than the UK, and 70% of its care is private. And not only that, it gives free healthcare services to other countries, including organ transplants.
I know this because I’ve already heard HR complain about too many pregnancies in a year caused the company contributions to go up.
Everyone pays because everyone should pay.
But if everyone pays the same you just conceded the entire victory to adverse selection: people that do not participate in a risk pays for the risk in someone else. The most obvious demonstration of this effect is double-paying in countries that have both private and public healthcare services: you pay twice, once for the public you don't use, and then for the private one.
Most countries with public healthcare have a private supplement that build on top of what the national system already provides: in home care, private hospital rooms, dental and vision, and concierge service. I've yet to see a private system attempt to replace a functional public system.
Most that I know of. Unless the state has absolute monopoly on primary care providers/General practitioners, you will have both systems in place.
Yes, that is what single-payer means. There is no parallel payment. You pay for basic service through taxes. You pay for better service through private. Private insurers like BUPA can only extend healthcare options. They don't replace it.
I dont think its palatable in the US to make policies that could increase national healthcare spending.
From my point of view, lowering the expense is the #1 priority. Expanding coverage, and adding new layers of taxation for it will increase expenditures.
There are also many alternatives to adverse selection, my favorite is high deductible plans.
A type of Medicare health plan offered by a private company that contracts with Medicare to provide you with all your Part A and Part B benefits.
The same thing is happening in education: universities know that a large percentage of students are getting financial aid, so the true costs are buried in a layer of bureaucracy.
Fees and administrative fees continue to go up and the universities will always get their money.
The students are then on the hook to pay the loan back. If the Universities actually had to worry about students defaulting, they would be forced to reduce costs or they would go under.