Re:A Vegan No More
by pyre on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @01:25PM
(#1934771)
> Your accusation of strawman doesn't hold. It is a valid point that
> if you claim your movement is about health, but you ignore the
> biggest health problem there is (because it does not fit the
> ideology), the claims to health should be, if not entirely ignored,
> certainly not taken at face value. It's perfectly logical.
You seem to be arguing against the validity of vegetarianism/veganism as
a whole based on the statements of a few vegetarians/vegans. You also
seem to be under the impression that vegetarianism/veganism is some sort
of singular 'movement' that has extreme solidarity and a singular
purpose.
None of this is the case though. People decide to become
vegetarian/vegan for a variety of personal reasons ranging from health
to animal welfare (aka 'animal rights') to religion.
There are a number of movements that advocate a vegan diet (e.g.
Peta) but that is a lot different than what you seem to want to imply.
Your 'strawman' is the idea that vegetarianism/veganism is some sort of
'movement' where everyone believes the same thing and has the exact same
goals. [ What are 'vegan thought leaders' anyways? ]
None of this is the case though. People decide to become vegetarian/vegan for a variety of personal reasons ranging from health to animal welfare (aka 'animal rights') to religion.
There are a number of movements that advocate a vegan diet (e.g. Peta) but that is a lot different than what you seem to want to imply. Your 'strawman' is the idea that vegetarianism/veganism is some sort of 'movement' where everyone believes the same thing and has the exact same goals. [ What are 'vegan thought leaders' anyways? ]