Re:Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods
by kscaldef on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @12:44PM
(#1934584)
> quantum theory tells us that gravity arises from the exchange of particles
No, it doesn't. That statement is wrong on two levels:
1) We don't have a confirmed quantum theory of gravity
2) In quantum field theories in general it's not really accurate to say that "[forces] arise from the exchange of particles". In some QFTs, in some situations, you can perform a perturbative expansion which maps onto the Feynman diagram view of particle exchange, but that's not universally possible. They really are quantum _field_ theories, not quantum particle theories.
No, it doesn't. That statement is wrong on two levels:
1) We don't have a confirmed quantum theory of gravity
2) In quantum field theories in general it's not really accurate to say that "[forces] arise from the exchange of particles". In some QFTs, in some situations, you can perform a perturbative expansion which maps onto the Feynman diagram view of particle exchange, but that's not universally possible. They really are quantum _field_ theories, not quantum particle theories.