News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods by michael_nielsen on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:34AM (#1934224)
The "force" of gravity is not a fundamental concept in general relativity.

Here's a way of thinking about what's going on.

Consider a large mass, like the Earth. That mass curves spacetime in the vicinity of the Earth. A small object, like a satellite, simply moves completely freely in a "straight line" (i.e., geodesic path) according to that curved geometry. The curved geometry is such that those geodesics are just the satellite orbits that we see. In other words, the satellite isn't affected by any "force", it's just moving in a straight line in a geometry that happens to be curved, so we see it doing circles around the Earth.

It's exceedingly neat: in John Wheeler's great phrase, matter tells spacetime how to curve, and spacetime tells matter how to move. No forces required! Of course, after the fact you can tack on a notion of "force", but it's in no way fundamental.

Same thing is going on with projectile motion here on Earth.

Once you internalize this point of view, the statement about holding your arm in place becomes a lot clearer. The "natural" force-free thing your arm wants to do is to move along geodesics of spacetime, which means falling toward the Earth at an acceleration of g. But if we exert a (muscular) force to keep it up, then we can hold it in place. In short, in this point of view, forces are things which cause deviations from geodesic motion.

Re:Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods by zach on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @01:58PM (#1934916)
As far as simple visual illustrations go, this is the best I've seen:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O-p8yZYxNGc#t=6m31

Re:Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods by natep on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @01:03AM (#1936649)
What's always bothered me about these kinds of animations is that there is a grid of straight lines, but none of the objects actually follow these grid lines. Instead, the geodesics they follow are determined by the topology of the deformed surface, invoking the viewer's intuitive understanding of gravity...in order to understand the unintuitive formulation of it.

But, as you say, I haven't seen better.

Re:Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods by iwr on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @03:38PM (#1935256)
While the notion is simple, the math is not.
Re:Wrong scientific beliefs that were held for long periods by tel on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @12:19AM (#1936580)
Actually, the math is wonderfully simple deriving a great deal of benefit from tensor theory and the power of coordinate invariant arguments. It's a non-trivial concept in full, the shape of space and time, but considering the wild opportunity for it to be complex, the formulae are exceedingly simple.