News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by jrnkntl on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @10:59AM (#1934068)
I don't understand what they did the last days if this is another power outage.

In their posting about the outage on the 20th they said: "At this point all we know is a severe lightning storm in the area caused a power outage and redundant UPS systems failed." http://status.linode.com/2010/11/possible-power-outage-in-fr...

Redundant UPS systems failed? And now it fails again? What kind of data center are they running in Fremont?

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by dholowiski on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:16AM (#1934145)
I worked in a datacenter (serving many companies you've heard of) during a catastrophic power failure that lasted almost 24 hours. It's kind of like a plane crash - it's never one thing failing that causes the problem (that's what redundancy is for) - it's that perfect chain of events, multiple 'once in a lifetime' failures that causes it.

For example, power outage occurs at the same time the UPS batteries are being changed. Bypass fails and Diesel generators fail to kick in. Circuit breakers blow everywhere making it extremely difficult to get the generators back on line. This all happens in the middle of the night in a winter storm (or 'lightning storm) which causes a further delay in response time.

Been there, done that.

Edit: Also, bureaucracy, lack of documentation, and a manager CF added several hours to the outage. Sometimes you just have to STFU and let the geeks fix the problem.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by d2viant on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:49AM (#1934314)
Except, this isn't a once in a lifetime occurrence. As of today it's twice in a lifetime. That's indicates to me they didn't just hit that perfect chain of events, it tells me they have problems in their architecture or implementation that need to be addressed and tested before the next crisis occurs.

I worked in a datacenter as well. The whole point is that you test those scenarios when it's not an emergency so you can be confident everything will operate smoothly.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by dholowiski on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @01:07PM (#1934676)
Don't discount the chance that this was caused by two totally different 'once in a lifetime' chain of events... i've seen it happen.

However, as you point out it is far more likely that there are architecture or implementation issues that caused the repeated outages.

There are so many reasons that I don't want to have servers in California... high costs, dense population vulnerability to earthquakes and a hot terrorism target. Massive bandwidth but massive utilization, somewhat shaky power grid, heck even the state has financial issues. I picked Atlanta for my Linode server which is better (it's still a little close to the coast for me) and I host my WordPress sites at a company in Dallas, TX. Did you know texas has their own power grid - separate from the rest of the USA?

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by jmcnevin on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:43AM (#1934267)
What you've described here would make an AWESOME movie. Granted, I'm not sure how one would work "Datacenter" into the title and still sell many tickets.
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by rryyan on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @03:50PM (#1935298)
Cory Doctorow (of Boing Boing fame) wrote a sci-fi novelette about a datacenter during a crisis: http://craphound.com/overclocked/Cory_Doctorow_-_Overclocked...

I personally didn't find this piece particularly great, but there's an entry in the genre for you.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by dholowiski on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:55AM (#1934351)
What makes it even more exciting is that some of the companies were a bank and a hospital. Lesson learned - a bank gets far more anxious than a hospital when their servers go down.

I'm pretty sure there were Zombies roaming the aisles of servers where the power was out, that might help the box office sales.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by tbrownaw on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @12:35PM (#1934541)
> multiple 'once in a lifetime' failures that causes it.

That reminds me of hearing mention of "multiple six-sigma events" I think it was, when things were crashing in 2008: the only sane conclusion is that the models are broken.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by mrkurt on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:04AM (#1934085)
Linode doesn't run datacenters, they colo with other providers (Hurricane Electric in Fremont).

HE doesn't have the best reputation for resilient datacenter services. However, redundant power is a very complex problem and prone to failure if you can't afford to do it right... which you can't if you're selling colocation for as cheap as HE does.

I really, really wish Linode would launch a sort of premium offering in better datacenters.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by davidw on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:08AM (#1934111)
Incidentally, in some ways it seems kind of odd to run data centers in places like Fremont, where both land and people are expensive. Google and Facebook, for instance, have demonstrated that it's quite possible to build datacenters in rural Oregon, where land is a lot cheaper, and presumably labor costs are as well, even though my guess is that in someplace like Prineville, most of their people are imports...
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by mrkurt on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:18AM (#1934154)
Power is expensive as well (it's usually the big expense), but there are a couple of reasons you might opt for more expensive areas for datacenters, particularly if you're selling hosting.

1) Many companies want facilities that are physically accessible to them, it's very difficult to sell to these companies if they'll have to travel 900 miles to do any work and don't trust the provider to do the work for them, or simply don't want to pay for it. Given the target market for hosting, Fremont's a pretty good option.

2) Depending on the service, a datacenter is only as useful as the transit providers you can access. We do all our hosting at a Chicago facility where we can get a cross connect to any bandwidth provider you can think of. Our services are also targeted at end users, so we're better off being centrally located and using providers with extensive peering agreements (less latency, woo!). If we had serious computation requirements rather than delivery requirements, one of those spiff Icelandic datacenters might be a good choice. I'm unsure of what Google and others stick in their rural datacenters, but I doubt it's anything that slows down your experience.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by amock on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @01:32PM (#1934801)
Power is not the big expense and neither is land. See http://perspectives.mvdirona.com/2010/10/31/DatacenterNetwor... for a breakdown of expenses.
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by mrkurt on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @02:36PM (#1935045)
I may be missing something, but that post doesn't address the expense of power, it talks about the relative consumption of networking equipment compared to the rest of the facility. Power is expensive, and James Hamilton generally spends lots of time talking about it, his Velocity keynote (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHW-ayt_Urk) about datacenter innovations focused primarily on power and cooling (heat being a biproduct of power consumption).
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by amock on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @09:32PM (#1939164)
Slide 3 says that power, power distribution, and cooling account for only 31% of the monthly cost. So while power related expenses aren't trivial they're significantly less than the cost of servers. I think land would be counted under other infrastructure so it's hardly worth considering.
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by scalyweb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:21AM (#1934165)
Locations are selected often due to proximity of a target market for reduced response latency. Also getting transit Tier I transit/backbone providers to lay a network in smaller markets is quite a hard sell. Google and Facebook benefit from being able to commit to large monthly bandwidth usage.

It is probably going to be almost impossible to have a "carrier neutral" hotel in rural Oregon but you might get a single ATT or Level3 or if you're really sucking it, a Cogent line.

HE Fremont is specifically great for reaching markets in APAC and HE itself is pushing IPv6 quite hard and so is one of the few providers that make it widely available.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by davidw on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:27AM (#1934194)
> It is probably going to be almost impossible to have a "carrier neutral" hotel in rural Oregon

Fair enough, but there's plenty of middle ground between Prineville and the Bay Area. The latter is expensive - it makes sense to have the really high-end things there, like Google R&D, not commodities like data centers and factories.

IMO. I'm certainly not an expert in that sort of thing though.

Incidentally, as a native of Oregon, I still think it's pretty funny that Facebook is building a center in Prineville, heretofore best known as the home of Les Schwab "Free Beef!" Tires.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by scalyweb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:40AM (#1934247)
Definitely I agree. But some clients will pay more for proximity such as monitoring or DNS providers. Chicago(350 Cermak) and NY are an example because of the financial trading markets. Clients pay "through the nose" for a colo spot there because every millisecond counts. If XYZ Trading Company sets up in the suburbs of Chicago, that 5milliseconds makes a huge difference.

But you are definitely right that most people don't need that kind of silliness.

I came from North Carolina where Google and Apple saw the lower power/employee costs as a reason to open datacenters. In the western part of the state is a beautiful city called Asheville which was never known as a network hub. But because of the geographic location halfway between Atlanta and DC a company(uberbandwidth.com/netriplex) decided to create a datacenter there. Lower costs...but the only way IN and OUT of their network was a backhaul through Atlanta or through DC. If one of those backhaul lines go down they've basically lost their single selling point.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by davidw on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:51AM (#1934331)
Sure, I understand about the financial companies, but, going back to HE, that's definitely not the business they're in: they'd be in SF proper if they wanted to be close to that world.
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by jrnkntl on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:07AM (#1934102)
I wasn't explicitly referring to Linode but to the people running the datacenter (which is, in this case, HE).

I wouldn't so much wish for a premium offering, just better datacenters in general for Linode's racks.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by bdonlan on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:59PM (#1936202)
Or you can keep a backup linode in a different datacenter. Or better yet, have redundancy with a completely separate provider, so you can deal with a complete failure of either one provider.
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by davidw on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @11:03AM (#1934081)
Wow, a "severe lightning storm" in the bay area? My friend mentioned that on facebook too. Not an every-day occurrence.
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by gojomo on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @01:29PM (#1934788)
In SF proper, we saw the 'lightning', but not the 'severe'.

It could have been worse in Fremont, I suppose, or that might just be a bit of puffery being used to explain the outage.

Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by updog on Wednesday November 24, 2010 @02:46AM (#1936796)
Nope, I was in Fremont, and saw maybe 1 flash all night. Heard no thunder.
Re:Within 3 days another power outage at Linode (Fremont) by nenolod on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @12:54PM (#1934621)
you're expecting competence from HE?

i colo'd at HE until last year when they ran ~400V through my racks which had 110V circuits, several PDUs and servers were damaged. that was the cherry on top of the sundae though, there had been 2 power outages at that point and 2 other outages after that point.