Consider, would you rather spend a career with a single 1-year blemish where you had to live on the dole because you couldn't find work after changing career paths or whatever, or one where you were laid off four times for three months at a time? Those don't seem as symmetric to me as they do to the author.
That said, I think the points raised are valid. It does seem like in 2009 the market of academic economists was too bearish on the long term US unemployment situation.
Therefore I have little doubt that if you looked it up, you would indeed find that it's true that employment leads to increased happiness.
Source: I was just laid off.
18 years, 4 layoffs (and 1 walkoff) later, I can reflect back and say that he was only being emphatically honest. Each departure led to generous advancement, the sort that does not seem to come, these days, from loyalty to one's company or present role.
> Most of the harm of unemployment is psychological, not material. Holding income constant, the employed are much happier than the unemployed. Hence, no sensible person would want to see U.S. workers’ wages rise by 10% if the unemployment rate rose 3.5 percentage-points as a result. And psychology aside, remember that the welfare state forces active workers to support the idle. So when regulation forces wages up, even the lucky workers who keep their jobs ultimately forfeit much of what they gain.
If the goal is to improve happiness through applied economics then you should measure happiness, not make ad hoc justifications based on some other metric