Re:Democrats Unveil New Bill to Fully Restore Net Neutrality
by bduerst on Thursday March 07, 2019 @04:59PM
(#19332961)
All analogies are inexact by nature, which is why it's splitting hairs to nitpick them to death.
These are fringe use cases that still don't justify an ISP charging more for Netflix streaming over NBC.
Re:Democrats Unveil New Bill to Fully Restore Net Neutrality
by Junk_Collector on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:23PM
(#19333164)
So I'm genuinely curious. What legislation would you propose to solve the issue?
Another question you might ask. Is it OK to prioritize data that is destined for the 911 network over data that is heading to Pornhub? What about a university? What about Khan Academy? What do you do with encrypted data where you can't tell the type or destination? What if the encrypted data is malformed such that it is causing detrimental performance to the broader network?
Management of a modern network like the internet is an amazing challenge that requires all kinds of work to find optimal solutions. We need real technically nuanced discussion and consideration to craft legislation that actually solves problems and doesn't create significant new ones. We don't need badly flawed analogies designed to garner public support that only apply if you don't know about the topic.