News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by will_brown on Thursday March 07, 2019 @11:27AM (#19329336)
>The problem with a "netflix" model, is that doctors can currently prescribe anything, regardless of cost or efficacy

Unknown to almost everyone in the US is that if you are a Medicare patient, when you go to fill a Rx before the pharmacist fills the therapy, insurance software suggests cheaper generics to the pharmacist and requires the pharmacist to do the leg work of asking the doctor to change the Rx based on what the insurance company wants (ie the cheaper medication).

So the question might be..why would a pharmacist do what the insurance company software tells them... or why would a doctor second guess their initial Rx at the request of an insurance company trying to minimize their costs? Because if the pharmacist/pharmacy doesn’t do what insurance says or if the doctor doesn’t do what insurance says, they get dropped from the insurance network.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by vonmoltke on Thursday March 07, 2019 @12:33PM (#19330035)
> insurance software suggests cheaper generics to the pharmacist

I have never heard of pharmacists using "insurance software". The pharmacy system requests coverage from the patient's insurance, and it is either accepted or rejected.

Additionally, if there is a generic they just fill it, assuming the patient consents. In fact, pharmacists in many states are required to point out generic alternatives if they exist.

> requires the pharmacist to do the leg work of asking the doctor to change the Rx based on what the insurance company wants (ie the cheaper medication)

If a prescription requires modification, the patient is required to go back to their doctor. Pharmacists cannot just ask doctors for prescription modifications.

Where are you getting these ideas from?

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by lostapathy on Thursday March 07, 2019 @01:41PM (#19330792)
>If a prescription requires modification, the patient is required to go back to their doctor. Pharmacists cannot just ask doctors for prescription modifications.

>Where are you getting these ideas from?

This is not strictly true, at least in the US. I have had to wait while pharmacists contact the doctor to modify a prescription to sub something in due to availability issues.

The mail order service through my insurer will also do this to have doctors to order a 90 day supply rather than the usual shorter supply.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by vonmoltke on Thursday March 07, 2019 @02:11PM (#19331123)
You're right, my statement was too absolute. What I meant to convey is that pharmacists cannot just ask for modifications without the knowledge and consent of the patient.
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by ratling on Thursday March 07, 2019 @01:02PM (#19330365)
NexGen will suggest generics when you have a script for a name brand. It’s not coming from the insurance company.

Source: worked for RiteAid for half a decade.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by Pyxl101 on Thursday March 07, 2019 @03:26PM (#19331982)
Some states allow pharmacists to substitute generic drugs for name brand prescriptions. To my knowledge they don't need the doctor's permission, and can make the change on their own unless the doctor specifically requests the name brand medicine for some reason.
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by phonon on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:38PM (#19333311)
Yes, those are "Dispense as Written" (DAW) Laws.

http://beta.aan.com/globals/axon/assets/4698.pdf

In most states, just using the trademark name instead of the generic is not sufficient (which makes sense, since the generic names are usually quite wordy and hard to remember) the doctor needs to specifically write "DAW" if a generic cannot be used.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by Wowfunhappy on Thursday March 07, 2019 @10:07PM (#19334774)
This begs the question, under what circumstance would it be reasonable for a doctor to insist on "Dispense as Written"?
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by Godel_unicode on Thursday March 07, 2019 @10:24PM (#19334846)
Generics are not guaranteed to be identical, especially in the inactive ingredients. It is rare but not unheard of for someone to have a reaction only to one form of a drug.

Edit: I have a friend who has such an allergy, which was confirmed with double blind testing.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by will_brown on Thursday March 07, 2019 @01:24PM (#19330601)
From the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services. But like I said nearly no one knows any of this.

Go into any pharmacy and ask the pharmacist about “MTM” and gauge their reaction.

Look at outcomesMTM they are 1 of the 2 dominate insurance software vendors. Again you can ask nearly any pharmacist and they have an outcomesMTM portal that feeds them automated recommendations on behalf of the insurance carrier. Some of the bigger pharmacies, like Wal-Mart, have even removed the MTM portals from the individual stores already and created nationwide MTM centers. I even know of one company who uses pharmacy students (for free) to do this work for the insurers. Here is another tidbit for every recommendation the portal gives the pharmacist the pharmacy gets a “tip” (ie monetary bonus) to forward that to the doctor and if the doctor makes the change the pharmacy gets another tip. The only reason the insurers link up with the pharmacists to do their dirty work instead of the doctors directly is the insurers can’t pay the doctors the way they pay pharmacists to do their work bc of anti kickback laws.

>Pharmacists cannot just ask doctors for prescription modifications.

Again try asking any practicing family physician, ask them how many faxes they get a day from pharmacies requesting they change the patient Rx.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by vonmoltke on Thursday March 07, 2019 @01:46PM (#19330861)
> From the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services.

Please direct me to citations, not "try asking any X".

> Go into any pharmacy and ask the pharmacist about “MTM” and gauge their reaction.

MTM has nothing to do with insurance.

> Look at outcomesMTM they are 1 of the 2 dominate insurance software vendors.

outcomesMTM is not insurance software, it's pharmacy patient management software.

> Here is another tidbit for every recommendation the portal gives the pharmacist they pharmacy gets a “tip” (ie monetary bonus) to forward that to the doctor and if the doctor makes the change the pharmacy gets another tip.

That you need to substantiate with more than just "go talk to pharmacists", particularly in light of the above.

> Again try asking any practicing family physician, ask them how many faxes they get a day from pharmacies requesting they change the patient Rx.

I've had my pharmacy request changes on my behalf, if it was something simple (like getting the wrong dosage), and they have done so as a convenience, not because they were required to. I have never had them request a change without my consent or knowledge, and I would stop using such a pharmacy if it ever happened.

You have also completely ignored what I said about prescription changes not being necessary for generic substitution.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by will_brown on Thursday March 07, 2019 @02:19PM (#19331206)
You are asking me to cite things but what are you citing? You are simply saying “that’s not true”.

>MTM has nothing to do with insurance.

It’s required by law To be provided by insurers/health plans. If you refuse to talk to pharmacists or doctors about it, fine, you can read the law 42 CFR 423.153. In short insurance companies, must provide MTM services to patient covered in their plans.

It is also the single biggest metric in determining an insurers star rating. How could it possibly be unrelated to insurance if insurance companies have to, by law, provide it and it effects their reimbursement/star ratings?

>outcomesMTM is not insurance software, it's pharmacy patient management software.

That’s funny...the software certainly does manage pharmacists...on behalf of the insurance companies.

Right from the outcomes homepage:

“Contracted with more than 50 U.S. health plans, OutcomesMTM provides MTM coverage to 5.5 million patients. The company links more than 100,000 local chain, independent and health-system pharmacy providers with contracted plans across the country.”

Why does outcomesmtm contract with 50 insurance companies? Why does outcomesMTM “link” pharmacies with contracted plans?

“Targeted MTM services are designed to help plan sponsors improve performance for key Star measures, including the triple-weighted adherence measures. Prompted by TIPs in the Connect™ Platform, pharmacists work with patients to impact adherence and optimize medication regimens.”

As to generic substitutions...there are laws from state to state that allow pharmacists to do it, UNLESS the doctor says the name brand must be dispensed. I’m afraid that’s common practice, so permission is required. Plus when it comes to Medicare patients a pharmacist isn’t going to just change the RX to generic because they know they: 1 get paid by the insurer through these MTM portals to make the recommendation and 2 get paid again through the portal if/when the doctor agrees to the change.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by Wowfunhappy on Thursday March 07, 2019 @10:05PM (#19334762)
> You are asking me to cite things but what are you citing?

GP cannot prove a negative. If this software/system exists, the "burden of proof" is on you.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by will_brown on Thursday March 07, 2019 @11:25PM (#19335071)
He said mtm has nothing to do with insurers and ask “where I got my ideas” I said CMS and cited the Law that Medicare insurers have to provide mtm to patients.

Then he said outcomesMTM is a pharmacy patient management software having nothing to with insurance, but it’s a software for insurers to pay pharmacies to provide mtm to the insurers patients and I quoted from their website. It’s really above and beyond ridiculous like me saying google is a search engine and someone say no it’s not give me a cite.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by patmcc on Thursday March 07, 2019 @12:04PM (#19329717)
While I agree insurance companies do harm, encouraging generics is probably a net benefit. Doctors, just like anyone else, respond to marketing, so they remember 'viagra' more easily than 'sildenafil' and write prescriptions accordingly. There's often no medical reason a generic isn't 100% suitable.
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by munk-a on Thursday March 07, 2019 @02:13PM (#19331140)
This surprised me a bit but generics are not always a de-branded version of a medication or the same formulation manufactured by a different company. Often times generic equivalents are different formulations (sometimes prior generation formulas and sometimes divergent formulas) that are considered to have the same effect.

They nearly always do, but the weirdness of our stupid patent system means that sometimes they can have weird allergenic effects or (especially with neurological medicines that are less well understood) differing efficacy.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by jjoonathan on Thursday March 07, 2019 @02:26PM (#19331282)
And drug companies will stir this FUD so hard your head will spin.
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by GeekyBear on Thursday March 07, 2019 @09:09PM (#19334548)
The inactive ingredients are different.
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by mnm1 on Friday March 08, 2019 @04:13AM (#19336163)
That's great, but in this case even the generic costs $450 to $950 for a typical two week to a month bottle. I can't imagine how much the brand name costs if the generic costs that much. There are some alternatives like blink health (I have no affiliation) that bring that cost down to about $45 by negotiating prices en masse, I assume. If that's not a broken system, I don't know what is. Clearly, these medicines could cost a lot less but they don't because companies' profits are more important than health in America. Or take genetic tamiflu (can't remember the name). $150 for one course. I'd rather risk the flu, which I recently have, than take it preventatively. Can't imagine how much that brand name costs either but it it's unaffordable even on an engineer's salary, what's the use of even having this drug? Even with my insurance it was over $110. What's the use of having insurance in that case? Still unaffordable. Still going to get sick. What a fucked up system.
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by will_brown on Thursday March 07, 2019 @12:35PM (#19330061)
The insurance companies are not recommending generics because it’s cheaper for the patient...they do it because it’s cheaper for them.

There are many reasons generics, especially in the case of Medicare patients with chronic conditions, are worse for a patient.

Generally if you have a Medicare patientwith chronic conditions such as diabeties and/or high blood pressure, and their physician has successfully been managing their conditions using a name brand therapy, it’s not good practice to switch their therapy to a generic because it helps the insurance company. More importantly, it’s only the active ingredients in name brand drugs and generics that are the same. coloring agents, binders, etc... are different and those can have significant negative side effects. There is no shortage of examples of generics having worse outcomes in the case of chronic conditions.

Also it’s not just the therapy the insurance is changing, they also change the quantity. So again say you are a Medicare patient with type 2 diabetes and your doc prescribed 30 day Rx so you come back for the doc to check your blood work between fills, insurance is demanding the doctor change the Rx from 30 days to 90 days, because they don’t want to pay for the additional doctor appointment/blood work. They are watering down care and interfering with doctor/patient treatments.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by throwaway34241 on Thursday March 07, 2019 @06:40PM (#19333782)
Do you think cost should ever be a factor in patient care? Looking it up, generics usually cost 80-85% less than brand drugs. They are tested and contain the exact same active ingredients. Is it worth the patient and/or the insurance company paying 5-7x more to keep the coloring agents etc the same? I understand that sometimes it may make a difference, probably especially for things with complicated delivery mechanisms like time-release drugs, but in those specific cases the doctor can explicitly request brand if it's important.

Usually the patient copays are substantially higher for brand drugs than generic ones. And the insurance company paying obviously isn't free money either, it's from premiums that people pay every month (and/or taxes). At least in the US, people often don't get medical care because of the expense, so anything that inflates the cost further can be expected to cause real negative health outcomes by pricing more people out.

I agree it would be better to not change even minor things if a drug is working. But I think that problem would be better solved by (as a condition of drug approval) requiring companies to disclose coloring agents, binders etc to generics makers once the patent expires, so they can make the exact same drug that was used in the initial clinical studies, rather than overpaying for drugs by 5-7x.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by will_brown on Friday March 08, 2019 @09:09AM (#19337569)
>Do you think cost should ever be a factor in patient care?

Should the insurers costs be a factor in patient care? No.

Should pharmacists be paid by insurers to contra to cold call patients and interfere with the doctor patient relationship? No.

Should the pharmacists be financially incentivized to get patients to consent changes to therapies on the basis those changes lower insurers costs? No.

Should pharmacists be forced to do the bidding of the insurers under threat of being dropped from the insurance network? No.

Should doctors be forced to accept the insurers recommendations for changes to patient therapies under threat of being dropped from the insurers network? No.

It’s great to lower patient costs...and that’s what insurers and pharmacists on hanging their hat on, as I said almost no one knows the reality of how and why it’s being done. It’s no secret insurance companies are dropping pharmacies and doctors who don’t play ball (it’s worse for a patient to lose their network of doctors than pay for name brand drugs if the doctor feels that’s in their best interest). It’s also no secret that insurance companies are consolidating the market (buying pharmacies, buys hospitals and buying doctor offices) and forcing thei patients to the insurance owned doctors/pharmacies.

It can’t be ignored that patients are now often seeing a doctor owned by the insurer, filling their drugs at an insurance owned pharmacy...and decisions about patient care are made by the insurance company to lower their cost, not patient costs.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by patmcc on Friday March 08, 2019 @08:03PM (#19343774)
>>Should the insurers costs be a factor in patient care? No.

This is a very odd view to take. I live in a single-payer system (Canada), although we don't have a similar system for prescriptions (yet). I have supplementary medical insurance through my work. Of course I want my insurer to keep costs low; that means more money to pay for important things, and lower costs for my employer (and by extension, me).

I take two regular prescriptions, and I happily accept generics, because they're cheaper and they work. If they didn't, and the name-brand would for some reason, then yes, I'd expect my insurer to pay for that. But to default to the lower-cost one is not a bad thing for patient care.

If you think the insurance companies are taking too much money from this relationship (I do) or if the whole idea of barely restrained medical capitalism is immoral (I do) or if insurance companies should have much less control over medical decisions (I do), I can understand that, but especially in the current system this is one of the few good ways to keep costs slightly lower.

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by jazoom on Thursday March 07, 2019 @03:40PM (#19332126)
In Australia pharmacists can automatically switch to the generics unless a doctor says they can't on the prescription. I am totally okay with that for almost all scripts I write because it's the same drug and it saves the patient money.
Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by will_brown on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:01PM (#19332976)
well you may not mind if a pharmacist changes your Rx from name brand to generic to save the patient a little money.

But this is more of the pharmacist interfering with your relationship with the patient...

So imagine you write a therapy, and the patient gets a call from the pharmacists to the extent:

1. Your Doc Wrote the expensive drug, but if you agree we can save you $x by contacting your doc and encouraging them to change it;

2. Your Doc only wrote a 30 day fill, do you want us to ask for 90 days? (Consider these are your sickest patients, only your patients with chronic diseases, so you probably give them 30 days on purpose to get them back into the office to check their blood).

It may sound reasonable on its face but: 1. Your patient loses faith you are acting in their best interest; 2. It’s framed in a way that the pharmacist knows more than you; 3. It’s not disclosed to the patient or to you as the doc, that the pharmacy getting paid bonuses by the insurance company to do it; and 4. If you disagree with the request for change (it doesn’t matter why, it will harm your rating with the insurer and you will potentially be dropped from the insurance network and lose your patients with that plan/insurer).

Re:Treat Medicines Like Netflix Treats Shows by jazoom on Thursday March 07, 2019 @05:22PM (#19333160)
I wasn't at all saying the way it's done in USA is good. I was suggesting that making it allowed unless explicitly disallowed might be a better way to go.