News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Vegan No More by dejb on Monday November 22, 2010 @10:35PM (#1932420)
> I never expected this post to get so much attention.

There is nothing more popular than an anecdote that appeals to people's pre-existing biases. Unfortunately there will be many for which this one story will provide the same weight of evidence as the entire China Study.

Re:A Vegan No More by zaphar on Monday November 22, 2010 @10:41PM (#1932429)
The point of the story is that not everyone can do a Vegan diet and still be healthy. While this is just one example it does demonstrate the principle that meat is a necessary and vital part of some peoples healthy eating.

I sometimes wonder if Vegans worry about Lions on the savannah eating antelope. Do they want prevent that as well. Humans are Omnivores. We are built to get nutrients from both meat and plantlife. Our metabolisms work best when we eat both in moderation. A Vegan lifestyle makes it harder to eat healthy not easier and for some it makes it impossible.

Re:A Vegan No More by abeppu on Monday November 22, 2010 @11:51PM (#1932572)
Humans are Omnivores. We are built to get nutrients from both meat and plantlife. Our metabolisms work best when we eat both in moderation.

Please let's not resort to "appeal to nature", because that can certainly be abused both ways (and frequently is). There are certainly all sorts of sketchy vegetarian and vegan bogus arguments about why not eating animals is natural (and certainly eating dairy and chicken eggs isn't natural).

We weren't built for anything, and just because something is natural, doesn't mean that it's good or right. If we ruled our lives by what was natural, we'd die in our thirties, have high infant mortality, and while we would eat meat, we would also chase after it with sharpened sticks, and more of us would die from starvation. Agriculture is unnatural; it's technology. Yes, our ancestors ate meat, but that alone doesn't mean that we need to. The OP's system couldn't handle her vegan diet, so she needs meat, but that doesn't mean everyone needs meat.

If you want to eat meat, eat meat. That's reason enough. If you find that you personally physically need to eat meat, then please eat meat. But neither the omnivore nor the vegan who claims that one diet is universally nutritionally or morally optimal in virtue of being natural is making a solid justification.

Re:A Vegan No More by burgerbrain on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @12:08AM (#1932609)
>We weren't built for anything

Swap out built with adapted and I think you'll have a hard time finding a dentist that agrees with that.

Re:A Vegan No More by dejb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @04:19AM (#1933120)
Swapping 'built with adapted' doesn't avoid the naturalistic fallacy. Just because we have adapted to cope with something doesn't imply it is good for our current circumstances. Any source of calories would have desirable for our early ancestors - now we have the opposite problem. Instead gazing backwards to our primitive forbears for advice, we need to use science to guide us as to what the best foods to eat are.
Re:A Vegan No More by abeppu on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @04:24AM (#1933132)
In line with my point above that nature is irrelevant in a discussion about what's good or right, I'd like to point out that because of such unnatural practices as cooking our food, it kind of doesn't matter what our teeth are adapted to eat. I don't want to eat whatever foods our savanna ancestor ate, because now we have farms and kitchens and supermarkets, and I have better options, and better criteria to guide my choice than some interpretation of what's 'natural'.
Re:A Vegan No More by jwhitlark on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @02:27AM (#1932910)
Agreed. It seems like many people add a "perfectly" to adapted, and that gets them into trouble.
Re:A Vegan No More by colanderman on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @01:00AM (#1932720)
> I sometimes wonder if Vegans worry about Lions on the savannah eating antelope. Do they want prevent that as well.

I think it's safe to assume that you are against rape. Do you worry about dolphins in the ocean raping other dolphins?

Re:A Vegan No More by philwelch on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @02:24AM (#1932900)
Veganism implies a moral consideration for animals; opposition to rape doesn't.
Re:A Vegan No More by colanderman on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @02:46AM (#1932946)
Correction: veganism implies a moral consideration for animals from the point of view of humans. That is, most vegans believe it to be immoral to kill an animal because we as humans are (for the most part) capable of surviving without doing so, and we have the capacity to recognize this fact. True carnivores have neither of these traits and therefore are not morally obligated not to eat meat. Apologies if my analogy was not clear.
Re:A Vegan No More by zaphar on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:09AM (#1933681)
Except that the OP is one example of someone who clearly can not survive without doing so. It may be true that some Humans can do so but it is not true that all Humans can do so.
Re:A Vegan No More by dejb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @12:47AM (#1932700)
> The point of the story is that not everyone can do a Vegan diet and still be healthy.

When you hear a story about how some substance 'cured cancer' do you instantly conclude that the claims are necessarily correct - even for the cured person in the story? Would you expect the story to become popular on HN? The problem with one-off anecdotes like this is that they don't even conclusively demonstrate anything.

> I sometimes wonder if Vegans worry about Lions on the savannah eating antelope.

Dude that is a really ignorant and insulting thing to say.

> Humans are Omnivores. We are built to get nutrients from both meat and plantlife.

And here you demonstrate your limited grasp of evolution which a resort to a naturalistic fallacy.

> Our metabolisms work best when we eat both in moderation.

Actually the research demonstrates otherwise.

> A Vegan lifestyle makes it harder to eat healthy not easier

That is trivially true in a society where adding animal products to many foods is routine. If even 20% of the population was vegan it would be trivial to follow a vegan diet.

Re:A Vegan No More by zaphar on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:40AM (#1933778)
> Dude that is a really ignorant and insulting thing to say.

Why? We have it within our power to prevent that particular form of animal suffering. Give me enough money and political power and I could round up all the antelope and lions and keep em seperated. How is ignoring that form of animal suffering any different than ignoring animal farming?

> And here you demonstrate your limited grasp of evolution which a resort to a naturalistic fallacy.

I'll bite. How is it a fallacy? Fact: Humans are capable of digesting and processing meat. Fact: Humans have been eating meat for as long as we've been around. Fact: Humans get a number of nutrients in meat that are not easily found elsewhere in a form we can process.

>> Our metabolisms work best when we eat both in moderation. > Actually the research demonstrates otherwise.

Citation needed

> That is trivially true in a society where adding animal products to many foods is routine. If even 20% of the population was vegan it would be trivial to follow a vegan diet.

Because the market would provide? Either way you still have to work harder and be far more careful with what you eat in order to pull it off so my point still stands.

No where did I say it was impossible. Notice I said in moderation as well. You wouldn't have to eat a lot of meat to get the required nutrition.

Re:A Vegan No More by Tichy on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @10:47AM (#1934024)
"Either way you still have to work harder"

Since the production of meat uses up more resources (energy) than plant based food, I think your claim does not hold up.

It is easier to produce plant based food, so why should it be harder to buy plant based food?

I also doubt that you automatically eat healthy by simply adding meat to your diet.

Re:A Vegan No More by dejb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @08:58PM (#1936198)
>> Dude that is a really ignorant and insulting thing to say.

>Why?

You obviously have absolutely no idea of the range of reasons people have for being vegan do you? Here are a few

- Visceral disgust at the though of consuming animal flesh / produce

- The view that a vegan diet is healthier than a diet with meat. Also a view that meat products are a significant cause of many of our chronic diseases. Both of these views are well backed by a large amount of science for example 'the China Study'.

- The view that plant food is significantly more efficient to produce (5-10 times) and far less harmful for the environment than meat. This is true not just in term of calories but also for protein.

See : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_vegetarianism

- Religious beliefs

- The view that human control of animals represents a kind of slavery.

- The view that it is immoral for humans to knowingly and unnecessarily kill and/or cause pain to another being. The fact that humans are intelligent enough to have a choice and understand the consequences of their actions is the important thing. Many vegans feel especially strongly about factory farming which is often cruel in the extreme.

See : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethics_of_eating_meat

So now do you see how ignorant your point about lions is? Veganism is primarily about humans relationship to animals not about animals relationships with each other.

> I'll bite. How is it a fallacy?

By definition, that's how. Look it up : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Naturalistic_fallacy

> Citation needed

There are so many but I'll just stick with http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China_Study cause I'm lazy.

> Because the market would provide?

Yes there would be numerous vegan options with the nutrient mix customized to suit vegan diets.

> Either way you still have to work harder and be far more careful with what you eat in order to pull it off so my point still stands.

You have to work pretty hard with a meat based diet to avoid the chronic diseases it can cause.

Re:A Vegan No More by SmokenJoe on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @04:10AM (#1933098)
Being a strict vegan and getting all the required nutrients to maintain optimal health is almost mutually exclusive. You can take pills and shots to make up for the missing parts but these use animal products. It can be an insane amount of work for normal people. To say it would be easy if more people do it does not reflect the realities of nutrition. I wish you luck but it is not and can not be for everyone at leat not strict vegetarianism I also think that people who are pregnant and maintain the diet are amoral there is no shortage of research that show it can harm the infant.

Note meat little meat and almost shurly less than optimal for health. I don't like the people that go against research.

Re:A Vegan No More by dejb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:18AM (#1933458)
Dude you've mostly just stated a bunch of unsubstantiated opinions which I assert are factually in error. You specifically mentioned 'there is no shortage of research that show it can harm the infant'. If there is no shortage of this research then you should easily be able to provide at least one reference.
Re:A Vegan No More by zaphar on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:51AM (#1933820)
Rather than list all the studies here I'll just link you to a page with that lists them.

http://healthpsych.psy.vanderbilt.edu/2008/VeganDiets.htm

That page lists studies showing B12 deficiencies, bone density issues, and elevated Homocystein issues.

Also there is a very strong link to issues with pregnant and nursing women and their babies due to B12 deficiencies. The opinion of most researchers in this area appears to be that pregnant and nursing women should not follow a strict Vegan diet.

Re:A Vegan No More by dejb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:39PM (#1936004)
So the basic conclusion of this study is 'The evidence surrounding veganism appears to be mixed'. And further 'Overall, veganism is healthier than an omnivorous diet with respect to chronic diseases'. Did you manage to read these parts?

With respect to B12 it seems that there is clearly good evidence for vegans to take a supplement.

With regards to pregnant and nursing women the evidence seemed a bit less clear. There doesn't seem to be any mention of actual problems with vegan children, only correlations between them and children that did have problems. Despite the uncertainly It certain seems good enough evidence to take b12 supplement for vegans.

So the takeaway I get from this is that

(Vegan diet + b12/multivitamin) >> Omnivorous diet

Re:A Vegan No More by Tichy on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @09:29AM (#1933745)
Just as well there are probably people who can not eat a meat diet and be healthy, for example if they are allergic to eggs, milk or some meat variants. In fact the percentage of people who can't deal with milk is very high. If you go into a normal supermarket, it is actually very difficult to find any foods that don't have milk in it (Lactose being used for lots of dirty tricks).

The symptoms she describes (bloated belly, increased heart rate after eating) sound to me more as if there were some other problems - maybe she couldn't deal with some parts of the food very well. I've just read a good book about those problems (it is not allergies, I don't know the proper translation), and for example up to 17% of humans in the western world have problems digesting fructose. So naturally stuffing themselves with vegetables might cause problems. In that book it is also explained that those problems can often be cured in a matter of weeks. Few doctors are knowledgeable about those, though.

Re:A Vegan No More by oops on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @07:08AM (#1933435)
> I sometimes wonder if Vegans worry about Lions on the savannah eating antelope. Do they want prevent that as well.

I think vegans are more concerned with how animals are treated, not simply that they are killed and eaten.

Re:A Vegan No More by alone on Monday November 22, 2010 @10:47PM (#1932439)
And there are many people who will wrongly think the China Study is something to pay attention to: http://www.google.com/#q=debunking+china+study
Re:A Vegan No More by anthonyb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @01:47AM (#1932829)
"debunking" is a rather loaded term, don't you think? I would imagine that you're more likely to pull up crank sites than normal with a search like that.

In any case, there are (claimed) responses from the author of the China study which might be worth reading:

http://www.30bananasaday.com/group/debunkingthechinastudycri...

http://www.vegsource.com/articles2/campbell_china_response.h...

I haven't been able to find these on any "official" site though, so beware ;)

Re:A Vegan No More by dejb on Tuesday November 23, 2010 @06:20AM (#1933344)
If a link to google search is what you think passes as debate then why not also check out

http://www.google.com/#q=debunking+evolution

The standard of debate is likely to be at a similar level. If you actually have an confidence in any of these 'debunkings' then why not point out one that you think will stand up to scrutiny?

Re:A Vegan No More by abeppu on Monday November 22, 2010 @11:34PM (#1932526)
I concur. It bothers me that at the top of part 4 she says she regrets having decided to become a vegan through being swayed by graphic images of factory farms rather than having "adhered to the rigorous academic standards" that she claims to use in all other decisions -- and yet this anecdote turned polemic will surely be used by others in hastily making up their minds that veganism and possibly vegetarianism are not viable or beneficial to either the individual or society.
Re:A Vegan No More by burgerbrain on Monday November 22, 2010 @10:42PM (#1932430)
The purpose of the post very clearly is to make the point that veganism is not for everybody. Not to suggest veganism is not viable for all people.

edit: s/some/all/. english/logic fail.

Re:A Vegan No More by araneae on Monday November 22, 2010 @11:40PM (#1932542)
I guess it all depends on whether you'd prefer to be miserable and slowly starve to death starting in your 20s or be happy and energetic before dying at cancer at 60.