Born in the USA? Some Chinese plan it that way

Re:Born in the USA? Some Chinese plan it that way by jordan0day on Monday November 22, 2010 @09:23PM (#1932245)

To be honest, I'm not especially bothered by this. You could (and many cable news and talk radio hosts have) make the case that this is just plain wrong, but isn't there worse things than having the children of affluent foreigners be American citizens? We're still a "nation of immigrants", I say the richer the better!

I'll admit my analysis of this is only cursory, so feel free to correct my reasoning.

Obviously if these children just take advantage of the system, get a cheap(er) education and return to China, it's a net loss for the USA, but it seems to me that a great many would stay here, presumably as "productive citizens".

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Born in the USA? Some Chinese plan it that way by drewse on Monday November 22, 2010 @09:33PM (#1932264)

Yes, I'd assume that most of these immigrants described by the article will become productive citizens and will benefit the USA. I don't find anything wrong with what these people are doing, except for the fact that they have to "work around the system" to achieve their goals. There will be many more people who will move with their children to the US shortly after their births and then live in the US longer than those mentioned in the article. Why should one group of people be able to become citizens immediately while the others aren't able to [until they apply for citizenship]? In short, I feel no hard feelings against those who only come to have their children here, but rather feel that the system needs to be changed in some way.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Born in the USA? Some Chinese plan it that way by RickHull on Monday November 22, 2010 @09:40PM (#1932280)

Yes, and also we expose them to our ideals. It's a win-win. Either they stay here and produce and inform, or they go back home and produce and inform.

[ Parent | on HN ]