Re:Ghidra, NSA's reverse-engineering tool
by tptacek on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:13PM
(#19315690)
Leaving the decompiler aside, for core disassembly features, in what ways is modern IDA far ahead of its competitors?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Auto analysis when you have barely any information. Any tool can make nice output if you feed it nice input. Try a partial dump from an exotic device and then you’ll see IDA shine.
See, that's really most of what I ever did with IDA (I don't do a lot of Windows reversing) and I always had to do a lot of binutils munging to get weird architectures to work. But things may have improved dramatically in the last 8 years or so.
Re:Ghidra, NSA's reverse-engineering tool
by XMPPwocky on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:48PM
(#19315824)
Definitely- it's all the years of tweaking and the massive numbers of heuristics to handle, i don't know, code emitted by Microsoft Visual FORTRAN from 1972- that's IDA's moat. Screw the decompiler. If GHIDRA can match that, it's a huge step forwards.
Re:Ghidra, NSA's reverse-engineering tool
by XMPPwocky on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:20PM
(#19315718)
To be fair, without undo, Hex-Rays can only move forwards. This explains their advantage.
Re:Ghidra, NSA's reverse-engineering tool
by simcop2387 on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @08:37PM
(#19315785)
Not sure about everything, but last i looked IDA had a lot more support for different architectures and file formats compared to most of the open source stuff (not sure about other proprietary ones).