The way I see it, the people that are actually doing their homework wouldn't even be tempted by it..because they are actually doing their homework.
"Remember that this is homework, not a test. Yes, presumably the problem is doable without any reference material. The students don't necessarily know that, though. They do know that they've been prodded in that question to at least check their thinking or work against external information....which isn't available to them through the channels they've been permitted to use."
Checking your work against the correct answer and Googling the answer (and just writing it down) are two different things.
Especially:
"Checking your work against the correct answer and Googling the answer (and just writing it down) are two different things."
And you can tell the difference based on a server log...exactly how?
Are you here all week? Do you always get this many laughs?
"And you can tell the difference based on a server log...exactly how?"
If you can't see that googling answers isn't cheating, I'm sorry.
ETA: Or, charitably, you didn't recognize that the big UPDATES at the top of the blogger's post indicate that since my original post, he thought to clarify the context and indicate that he'd actually misremembered the phrasing of the question.
Or maybe both?
I wouldn't consider the actual professor's question from the linked exam to be entrapment, as it happens. That in mind, I'll save my disgust for the people who thought the scenario of entrapment originally described was so terribly clever.
"Commonly referred to as The Glorblar Problem"
That phrasing is a cue that the student is expected to either look something up or to refer back to notes or memory of lectures or discussion of the Glorblar Problem in class. Why else mention it, if it were an honest homework problem?
We know they didn't hear about the Glorblar Problem in class - it doesn't exist. For the same reason, we know that hitting the books, either back at the dorms or in the library, wouldn't have turned up anything.
Remember that this is homework, not a test. Yes, presumably the problem is doable without any reference material. The students don't necessarily know that, though. They do know that they've been prodded in that question to at least check their thinking or work against external information....which isn't available to them through the channels they've been permitted to use.
So, the professor deliberately tempted people to look up something online, then amused himself by busting the people who did. Cute method, but it proves nothing other than "schmuck bait works".