News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by GHFigs on Monday November 22, 2010 @02:10PM (#1930926)
documents about the U.S. torturing people

Do you have a specific example of this? Every instance I have seen or heard about refers to the actions of Iraqi security forces.

hasn't had any adverse affect on the support for the war. It's proof that people just don't care.

At the risk of being mistaken for some kind of right-wing buffoon, I have to say that what I've gleaned from the Iraq war leak has had an adverse effect on my opposition to it. The sketch of what Iraq will be after the US withdraws is there and I'm not convinced it's any better. I still don't know what to do with that, but perhaps it's a sign of why many or most people don't care: there is no simple answer. That is, you can't just release a bunch of documents and end a war, because such documents will only give you a higher resolution picture of a complex reality.

I think that Wikileaks has sort of hobbled itself by relying on document bombs and overt political objectives instead of just focusing on sensemaking. They get a lot more attention this way, but much less capacity to change minds.

The need by governments to keep everything secret is a bit irrational. People don't care.

You're basing that on the mistaken assumption that the intent of all military secrecy is to withhold information from the citizens it serves and not enemies current and potential. The widespread appeal of that assumption is what WIkileaks depends on for donations but it's still bonkers.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by yequalsx on Monday November 22, 2010 @02:41PM (#1931011)
Long before the Wikileaks report there was the report by Major General Taguba which included in it the fact that a man was forced to rape his son while under U.S. custody. In the Wikileaks documents we come to know that the Iraqi forces routinely torture. Our leaders knew this and yet did little to stop it. They refused to allow Red Cross personnel to have access.

One can hide behind the fact that it was Iraqis doing this but given our sway over their forces this doesn't hold water with me. We did nothing to stop these abuses. We turned over detainees to people we knew were going to torture. It makes us just as guilty as the ones who were doing the torture. Getting other people to do the dirty work is no less reprehensible.

The leaked documents show that our forces deliberately killed people while in the process of surrenduring. Our forces have executed civilians. The picture painted by these document is indeed a bleak one. It also demonstrates that we, as a nation, have no moral authority. The meme that we are good and they are bad is a false one that has been destroyed by our actions in this war in the minds of the rest of the world. It just hasn't sunk in with the average American.

I don't advocate that we leave Iraq right now. It's a mess. I do advocate that generals and former Presidents be arrested for war crimes though. It's sad to me as an American that we have sunk so low so fast.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by GHFigs on Monday November 22, 2010 @06:03PM (#1931642)
...there was the report by Major General Taguba which included in it the fact that a man was forced to rape his son while under U.S. custody.

There is no such finding in the Taguba Report.

One can hide behind the fact that it was Iraqis doing this...

Being accurate is not "hiding". The assertion that I read was that Wikileaks had released "documents about the U.S. torturing people". That assertion is false. The distinction is absolutely crucial to what can and should be done about it.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by yequalsx on Monday November 22, 2010 @06:12PM (#1931668)
Sorry. My mistake. General Taguba's report showed that a man was forced to have sex with a teenage boy. The boy wasn't his son.

Delivering prisoners to people who you know will torture them is the same as conducting the torture yourself. The distinction is meaningless.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by GHFigs on Monday November 22, 2010 @07:22PM (#1931855)
General Taguba's report showed that a man was forced to have sex with a teenage boy.

It did not. Please do not mistake me for someone unwilling or unable to do my own research, or someone interested in being lied to. This will be my final comment.

The finding that you are misreporting is on page 17, item I, under the heading "I find the intentional abuse of detainees by military personel included the following acts": "Writing "I am a Rapest" (sic) on the leg of a detainee alleged to have forcibly raped a 15-year old fellow detainee and then photographing him naked;"

If you believe that events transpired differently, that is your right, but it is not supported by the report you cited.

The distinction is meaningless.

Let me reiterate with different emphasis: The distinction is absolutely crucial to what can and should be done about it. Having a clear picture of the problem and being accurate and precise about what is actually going on is essential to finding a solution. Obscuring the problem under a blurry haze of blame is not a solution and doesn't get you any closer to one. It's like trying to untangle a knotted mess of cables by trying to decide which cable's fault it is and then pointing at it harder and harder in the hope that it will resolve itself.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by yequalsx on Monday November 22, 2010 @07:51PM (#1931959)
My mistake again. I misread what was meant by "forcibly rape". I took forcibly to mean he was being forced. However, there are many other things in the report detailing out torture and abuse of prisoners. The point I made stands and is correct. We torture people and the nation, for the most part, doesn't care.

The distinction is meaningless in a moral sense. Our actions are morally reprehensible. I wasn't proposing a solution. I was merely stating facts. We send people to Iraqi security forces knowing they will be tortured. This is reprehensible.

Using your analogy, one must first determine the cables are tangled before a solution is sought. Americans aren't demanding a solution because they aren't aware of it or just don't care.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by cabalamat on Monday November 22, 2010 @02:59PM (#1931063)
> One can hide behind the fact that it was Iraqis doing this but given our sway over their forces this doesn't hold water with me. We did nothing to stop these abuses.

Realistically, I'm not sure there's a lot the USA could do. When US forces arrest an Iraqi within Iraq, then it's a violation of Iraqi sovereignty not to hand him over to the Iraqi authorities. Given where Iraq is now (a history of repression, just becoming democratic), it would be extremely naive to expect Iraqi forces never to violate human rights.

Unless the USA wants to stay in Iraq forever -- which would be unacceptable to both the American and Iraqi publics, and would make the situation worse anyway -- they have to accept that some torture and other human rights violations will occur.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by yequalsx on Monday November 22, 2010 @03:08PM (#1931095)
"...then it's a violation of Iraqi sovereignty not to hand him over to the Iraqi authorities. "

Ha. Funny.

"...they have to accept that some torture and other human rights violations will occur."

I'm reminded of Bush writing, "Let freedom ring" on the memo he got after the new Iraq government was instituted.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by nubian on Monday November 22, 2010 @07:29PM (#1931877)
I'm not sure if you're only referring to WikiLeaks, but as for torture:

The CIA's waterboarding regimen was so excruciating, the memos show, that agency officials found themselves grappling with an unexpected development: detainees simply gave up and tried to let themselves drown.

http://www.salon.com/news/feature/2010/03/09/waterboarding_f...

"Finally, to keep detainees alive even if they inhaled their own vomit during a session – a not-uncommon side effect of waterboarding – the prisoners were kept on a liquid diet. The agency recommended Ensure Plus."