News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by tptacek on Monday November 22, 2010 @01:54PM (#1930874)
The Wikileaks Iraq leak (apparently) predominately documented torture by Iraqis. If anything, it enhanced the US narrative, in part by documenting belligerent activity by Iran, and in part by creating a contrast between our professional military and their abusive militias.

Part of the US narrative about Iraq (a part that I completely believe) holds that however bad Iraq is now, it's got to be better than decennial waves of genocide punctuated by monthly feedings of dissidents through industrial paper shredders.

I'm not a supporter of the Iraq war, but I'm not naive enough to think that Iraq was a playground before we got there. I have a hunch I may speak for a fair portion of the "depressing" majority of people who are not outraged by this last disclosure.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by grandalf on Monday November 22, 2010 @04:33PM (#1931370)
It did enhance aspects of the US narrative, and diminished others. This is a good thing, since it added to the overall truthfulness of the narrative.

US strategy has been to hide the proxy war it's fighting with Iran from the American public, while increasing the rhetoric/rancor against Iran, so that eventually if/when there is more open conflict, the American people already view the Iranian people as barbaric subhumans.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by tptacek on Monday November 22, 2010 @05:47PM (#1931599)
Your second paragraph doesn't make any sense to me. It seems to suggest that Americans would look more favorably on Iranians if we knew they were helping kill American teenagers.

I feel bad for taking even a baby step further into this political tar pit, but my nerd brain lacks an exception handler for the weirdness it just encountered.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by grandalf on Monday November 22, 2010 @09:14PM (#1932224)
That is not the intended implication. The US is not currently powerful enough to add a full-fledged war against Iran to its docket of wars.

Military power = technology * money * public will

Since the public would not accept the sacrifices necessary to engage in an all-out war with Iran, the US is hamstrung. How to fix this? Simple, increase the public will toward war with Iran. Since the American public is growing skeptical of warmongering claims, and Iran actually has the moral high ground in this case, the US has no choice but to keep from the American people information that would cause some parties to demand a war that could not actually happen.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by yequalsx on Monday November 22, 2010 @02:52PM (#1931044)
Iraq was a mess before we invaded. Saddam was brutal. We, apparently, have been less so but not by too much. It's a pretty low standard to have that we just be better than Saddam. We should also keep in mind that in the 80's it was we who supplied Saddam. It was we who turned a blind eye when he was using chemical weapons to gas Kurds.

Our whole involvement with Iraq over the past few decades has been revolting.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by glenstein on Monday November 22, 2010 @06:07PM (#1931655)
Politico called it a "devastating portrait of apparent U.S. indifference to a pattern of murder and torture." BBC said the memos "Show U.S. 'ignored torture'". I only remember the New York Times anything that could be construed as favorable to the U.S. and I'm guessing that your impression was shaped by the NY Times article by Sabrina Tavernise and Andrew W. Lehren.

Anyway, the reports of U.S. indifference and maybe even complicity in Iraqi acts of torture is not enhancing to the U.S. image, which isn't to say misleading reporting couldn't enhance our image after the fact.

Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by tptacek on Monday November 22, 2010 @06:26PM (#1931705)
You're addressing a different issue than the one my comment addresses.
Re:Wikileaks promises release 7x bigger than Iraq War Logs, ... by glenstein on Monday November 29, 2010 @01:53AM (#1949621)
Our comments both address the issue of whether the wikileaks release "enhanced the US narrative."