Re:High-tax states like California and New York make it hard...
by jrs235 on Monday March 04, 2019 @05:02PM
(#19306038)
>Additionally, the Senate does not represent the people, it represents the states.
While that is how is was originally designed, the 17th Amendment kinda of took that away. Originally the state legislatures elected their state's representatives (Senators) in the federal government.
With the passing of the 17th Amendment, the direct election of Senators has contributed to the ridiculousness of our federal government.
I would bet few state elected Senators (who actually represent their state governments) would ever pass federal laws/mandates that would punish a state and withhold funds if they didn't comply with the federal governments demands such as the National Minimum Drinking Age Act of 1984.
After all, the people do not choose the President, the states do. Each state has a certain number of electors in the electoral college and they can allocate those electors to the candidates as they see fit. In most states that happens to coincide with state's election in which the popular vote of the state determines all the electors (some states split electoral votes) but it doesn't have to be that way (see National Popular Vote Interstate Compact).
Additionally, the Senate does not represent the people, it represents the states. That's why there's huge power imbalances among people in the Senate living in California vs. Wyoming, for example. The supreme court is chosen by the President and confirmed by the Senate. The only branch of federal government chosen by and representing the people is the House.
So if the people are not even directly choosing the major branches of the federal government, they should not be directly paying taxes to it.