Re:High-tax states like California and New York make it hard...
by dragonwriter on Monday March 04, 2019 @12:25PM
(#19303017)
> Why should anyone pay less federal tax than a person living across the border just because you pay tax to your state?
Because state taxing and spending decisions are part of what creates the opportunity to earn income, and if state taxes aren't deductible than federal taxes distort those decisions and artificially promotes lower tax policy even when the higher tax policy expands the production possibilities curve and yield more income.
The federal thumb should be off that scale and the only way to do that is full deductibility of state and local taxes.
It's a lot like why business expenses are deductible, why you are only taxed on the net proceeds of capital (whether it is used as regular income or long-term gains), or why even hobby expenses are offset against hobby income.
Because state taxing and spending decisions are part of what creates the opportunity to earn income, and if state taxes aren't deductible than federal taxes distort those decisions and artificially promotes lower tax policy even when the higher tax policy expands the production possibilities curve and yield more income.
The federal thumb should be off that scale and the only way to do that is full deductibility of state and local taxes.
It's a lot like why business expenses are deductible, why you are only taxed on the net proceeds of capital (whether it is used as regular income or long-term gains), or why even hobby expenses are offset against hobby income.