News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by ex3ndr on Sunday March 03, 2019 @07:09AM (#19294089)
Selling weapons to ISIS is not a crime then?
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by Aegaeus10111 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @10:43AM (#19294960)
Good point.

If I was a purist I'd say "no". Using those weapons might be.

Not being a purist I'm happy to make exceptions for probable use or effect of the activity. So:

Selling weapons to people likely to commit crimes is a reasonable exception to the simple version above. and Prostitution, where the probable outcome is a mutually satisfying service involving ONLY the parties involved is not a reasonable exception.

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by gumby on Sunday March 03, 2019 @07:53AM (#19294225)
That’s a great example, but consider the framing of the last sentence of the gp’s post:

> But in cases when it's a choice freely made by all parties concerned ...

Presumably the targets of isis’s weapons are “parties” and don’t want to be shot at.

Then again, what about hiring police: the robber is a “party” too and presumably does not consent to being caught!

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by Aegaeus10111 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @11:25AM (#19295199)
"...the robber is a “party”..." yes, but by definition a party that has already broken the law and mutual consent - the interaction with police would be a direct result, or an extension of that non-consensual act.

:-)

I can imagine lots of extreme edge cases and semantic word play on this - and I guess phrasing things to take in every conceivable situation is why lawyers make so much.

I'll stick with "the spirit of the notion".