News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by godelski on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:02PM (#19292640)
Depends how you define "stable". Is it "less likely to fall over" or "less wobble"? That's basically the difference here.

A 4 legged chair is much less likely to fall over because it has more points of contact with the ground (yes, this extrapolates). While you're correct that a 3 legged chair isn't going to wobble, many would call it less stable because it is more likely to fall over. The force is distributed only across 3 points and if you sit at an edge that force is going to be highly concentrated along two points. In fact, those two points are always going to create a lever. In a 4 legged chair there are many edges that you can sit on where the weight will be distributed to three points, you have to be specifically on the edge where two legs create a plane to distribute the force to 2 legs (see why this extrapolates? More legs and it is harder to distribute force to only 2 legs).

Why 4 though? Well, I don't have a scientific answer. But it is pretty well balanced, doesn't increase cost much, nor weight. So probably just a compromise. Though in a lot of rolling chairs you will see that they typically have more than 4 points of contact with the ground (notice how much harder it is to tip these over?).

tldr: 4 is actually more stable in the sense of "you're less likely to fall out of the chair and bonk your head".

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by creatornator on Sunday March 03, 2019 @12:05AM (#19292835)
It's not exactly more legs -> less chance of falling, but rather it is larger footprint -> less chance of falling. The footprint is basically the shape made by the outermost points of contact. If the net force vector (generally just project center of mass in direction of gravity) goes outside the footprint, the system is unstable. You could absolutely have a chair with more legs be less stable than one with fewer legs, if the footprint is smaller.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by godelski on Sunday March 03, 2019 @02:02AM (#19293176)
You are correct, but I assumed that when people are creating their mental model that they envision regular polyhedra. Especially given the context. I felt that the distinction might make things more convoluted and I could leverage the likely mental model to my benefit. But you are technically correct.