News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by CPLX on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:50PM (#19292240)
Why are they using medieval Europe as some kind of tool for speculation about legal sex work in the U.S.?

It’s a bizarre line of discussion given that for the most part sex work is legal today in Europe.

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by leoh on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:06PM (#19292298)
It's just an interesting historical perspective, they don't have a heavy-handed agenda or anything. Augustine's perspective is interesting:

> Remove prostitutes from human affairs and you will destroy everything with lust.

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by licebmi__at__ on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:20PM (#19292336)
It's an interesting topic but I also find bizarre the relation with modern policy.

I'm both amused and horrified with the idea on the full sentence where your quote is portrayed: >Theologians followed the teachings of Saint Augustine, who wrote that it was better for sinful men to frequent brothels than to “corrupt” their wives or other respectable women with nonprocreative sex: “Remove prostitutes from human affairs and you will destroy everything with lust.”

It's kinda silly to imagine a group of "celibate" men suggesting the practicals of prostitution instead of corrupting virtuous women with non procreative sex, and at the same time horrible to consider that in the context of bad contraceptive methods, the advice was to subject some of the women to be second class citizens.

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by mobilefriendly on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:04PM (#19292439)
Given how dangerous child-birth was, there's a something of a tradition going back to at least the Romans of protecting a wife by using prostitutes for base sex
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by watwut on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:25AM (#19293383)
It was less dangerous for those prostitutes? The chilbirth and childcare was more disastrous and difficult for them as they were single mothers and breadwinners as a result.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by mirimir on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:32AM (#19293405)
True, but they were considered ~disposable.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by watwut on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:40AM (#19293440)
Yes, and that is why the "both amused and horrified" comment makes perfect sense. Other thing that makes perfect sense is the characterization of it all as "the advice was to subject some of the women to be second class citizens" - yes, in exchange of other women being more protected.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by Farradfahren on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:02AM (#19293700)
They where implicit expected to murder the newborns/ abort the embryos. That is why it was a "low" profession and those who worked in it where outcasts.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by Spooky23 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:31PM (#19292733)
St. Augustine wasn’t a celibate by any means. He struggled with the moral and philosophical nature of things, and certainly got plenty of action during the struggle.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by dmckeon on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:11AM (#19293029)
> I had entreated chastity of thee and had prayed, "Grant me chastity and continence, but not yet." For I was afraid lest thou shouldst hear me too soon, and too soon cure me of my disease of lust which I desired to have satisfied rather than extinguished.

Book 8, Chapter 7, p. 139

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by azeotropic on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:24AM (#19293750)
I was thinking the opening of book three:

"TO CARTHAGE I came, where there sang all around me in my ears a cauldron of unholy loves. I loved not yet, yet I loved to love, and out of a deep-seated want, I hated myself for wanting not. I sought what I might love, in love with loving, and safety I hated, and a way without snares. For within me was a famine of that inward food, Thyself, my God; yet, through that famine I was not hungered; but was without all longing for incorruptible sustenance, not because filled therewith, but the more empty, the more I loathed it. For this cause my soul was sickly and full of sores, it miserably cast itself forth, desiring to be scraped by the touch of objects of sense. Yet if these had not a soul, they would not be objects of love. To love then, and to be beloved, was sweet to me; but more, when I obtained to enjoy the person I loved. I defiled, therefore, the spring of friendship with the filth of concupiscense, and I beclouded its brightness with the hell of lustfulness; and thus foul and unseemly, I would fain, through exceeding vanity, be fine and courtly. I fell headlong then into the love wherein I longed to be ensnared. My God, my Mercy, with how much gall didst Thou out of Thy great goodness besprinkle for me that sweetness? For I was both beloved, and secretly arrived at the bond of enjoying; and was with joy fettered with sorrow-bringing bonds, that I might be scourged with the iron burning rods of jealousy, and suspicion, and fears, and angers, and quarrels."

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by nine_k on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:39PM (#19292373)
OK, replace "non-procreative" with "non-consensual".
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by bitwize on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:11PM (#19292313)
Indeed. Even in the middle ages they knew prudishness was counterproductive.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by pjc50 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @04:28AM (#19293594)
Important to note that while the work itself is not illegal it's usually surrounded by a minefield of things that are illegal, such as "running a brothel" or "soliciting". In extreme cases two women sharing a flat posessing condoms could be deemed a brothel and prosecuted.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by stallmanite on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:01PM (#19295760)
Brilliant! Much better that they don’t use condoms? Prohibitionists seem to me to be shockingly stupid so I assume I’m misunderstanding them. Can anyone here articulate the reasoning behind such a law for me?
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by pjc50 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:16PM (#19295863)
I think it's similar to the lab glassware / "drug paraphenalia" situation - once you've tripped the prejudices of the police they assemble evidence that you're the wrong kind of person.

https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/crime/unsafe-sex...

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by benj111 on Sunday March 03, 2019 @03:21AM (#19293373)
I think its useful for taking the emotion out of it, and to be reminded that this is an issue we've been dealing with for a long time.

Also this is when red light districts originated, a model still common in Europe today.

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by licebmi__at__ on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:27PM (#19292345)
I might be wrong, but it was my understanding that sex work was a legal and regulated activity in only some parts of Europe, but it's indeed not illegal on most of the countries.

Something like cannabis in Amsterdam, where the police just turns a blind eye that most people even think is completely legal.

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by ekianjo on Saturday March 02, 2019 @09:57PM (#19292418)
As far as I know cannabis is completely legal in Amsterdam at least in smoking parlors.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by gotocake on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:01PM (#19292427)
That’s just not true, but the truth is complicated.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drug_policy_of_the_Netherlan...

While recreational use, possession and trade of non-medicinal drugs described by the Opium Law are all technically illegal under Dutch law, official policy since the late 20th century has been to openly tolerate all recreational use...

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:22PM (#19292504)
Technically, or de jure, not true.

I think it’s fair to say it is legal in the softer sense of the word, or de facto legal.

I also don’t believe that it’s complicated to understand such a state of affairs.

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by gotocake on Sunday March 03, 2019 @01:10AM (#19293024)
Technically nothing, the correct response to As far as I know cannabis is completely legal in Amsterdam at least in smoking parlors. is just what I said. It is not de facto legal either, it’s tolerated and police still retain the power to arrest you for it. The fact that it’s not aggressively policed or prosecuted changes its social status, not the legal status.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday March 04, 2019 @06:03AM (#19300342)
One of my all time favourite HN, and general, comments can be found here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6033481

You seem obsessed with laws, as if they possess value and worth in and of themselves, when really they are a very high latency sidechannel of society and power.

Changed legal status tends to follow social status.

Do you think, for example, slavery, universal suffrage, women's suffrage, or homosexuality, are about to be made illegal again?

In some areas it took decades for the laws to reflect reality.

It should be noted, too, that, generally speaking, the police retain retain the power to arrest you. Period. They don't need a reason. They'll just arrest you and charge with whatever they want. Roll a dice. You can get arrested for crossing the street, or cycling home, or holding your tongue the wrong way on a Tuesday. They don't need drug laws for that.

It's usually up to some government prosecutor to decide whether they will go ahead with the case. And in my experience, at least here in Australia, the public prosecutor tends to have their head screwed on way more than the kids in blue. Who for some reason feel it necessary to take guns to the bakery to get their lunch. How insecure do you have to be.

Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by ekianjo on Tuesday March 05, 2019 @11:18PM (#19316369)
OK, you are correct in the legal sense, but if a law is not enforced, it ceases to have any meaning. That's just like prostitution in Japan being illegal while having extremely obvious places with prostitutes in plain sight everywhere.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by roel_v on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:03PM (#19292438)
Cannabis has never been 'completely legal' anywhere in the Netherlands. It depends a bit though on how you define 'completely legal'. Wikipedia has the details.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by hellofunk on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:14AM (#19293731)
This is incorrect. Cannabis is decriminalized, but still illegal in Amsterdam.
Re:Regulating Sex Work in Medieval Europe by deanalevitt on Sunday March 03, 2019 @02:30AM (#19293255)
This was my first thought too.

> medieval examples suggest that what’s important is not just legal status but how regulations affect workers’ ability to control their working conditions.

Do we really need medieval examples? Surely this is evident in modern examples too?