Re:The Electoral College Is the Greatest Threat to Our Democ...
by dragonwriter on Friday March 01, 2019 @06:50PM
(#19286438)
> The democratic republics that score the highest/best in things like quality-of-life, income equality, incarceration rate, crime rate, access to healthcare, life expectancy, etc., all have forms of government where the executive is not elected at all by popular vote, but is instead chosen by the legislature.
They also have systems where the electoral system for the national legislature produces substantially more proportional results than the US system, which seems to be a more significant factor, as it both means law is more likely to reflect the preferences of the people and the evidence suggests it also creates a more multidimensional space of public discourse and, therefore, considered policy options. In fact, a lot of systems with Presidential and Semi-Presidential systems are better than the US on these measures, and they tend to have more proportional systems for electing the national legislature. (Also, usually the President as well, though that, again, doesn't seem to be as important.)
Also, the US executive isn't elected at all by popular vote, either—at least no more than ones in which the executive is chosen by a parliamentary majority—though the body by which they are elected isn't the legislature and has no other function than electing the President and Vice President.
The US executive is separately elected, but neither directly or popularly elected.
> The only other countries that have a form of government like the US's (a presidential republic) are ones like El Salvador and Turkey
That's...only true if you take “like El Salvador and Turkey” absurdly broadly. There's a pretty wide diversity of Presidential systems (and even more if you include Semi-Presidential systems.)
They also have systems where the electoral system for the national legislature produces substantially more proportional results than the US system, which seems to be a more significant factor, as it both means law is more likely to reflect the preferences of the people and the evidence suggests it also creates a more multidimensional space of public discourse and, therefore, considered policy options. In fact, a lot of systems with Presidential and Semi-Presidential systems are better than the US on these measures, and they tend to have more proportional systems for electing the national legislature. (Also, usually the President as well, though that, again, doesn't seem to be as important.)
Also, the US executive isn't elected at all by popular vote, either—at least no more than ones in which the executive is chosen by a parliamentary majority—though the body by which they are elected isn't the legislature and has no other function than electing the President and Vice President.
The US executive is separately elected, but neither directly or popularly elected.
> The only other countries that have a form of government like the US's (a presidential republic) are ones like El Salvador and Turkey
That's...only true if you take “like El Salvador and Turkey” absurdly broadly. There's a pretty wide diversity of Presidential systems (and even more if you include Semi-Presidential systems.)