Re:Lessons Learned: A non-designer's attempt at a redesign
by jamesbritt on Sunday November 21, 2010 @08:25PM
(#1928427)
Gradients and drop-shadows require space to be effective.
Pages also need white space to help organize content and avoid crowding.
So, if you go with gradients or drop-shadows (or effects in that realm) know that you're doing so at the expensive of a resource that adds readability and overall usability.
That's not an argument against using these things, just an argument against gratuitous application. (Consider that Amazon, for example, manages to get a good deal of content on their pages while still being fairly easy to grok.)
This can work in some situations, but you should also be careful of over-using these accents. If you look at a site like amazon.com, for example, you'll see that they use solid colors and "flat" text more than gradients and drop shadows.