News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by Wowfunhappy on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:32AM (#19280902)
> but in that case you shouldn't be using their OS. To borrow a phrase: They have root. If you don't trust them then you don't trust your PC.

Is this really an option? I'd posit that even many hardcore Linux folk keep a Windows partition, VM, or secondary PC around.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by linuxftw on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:04AM (#19281214)
Nope. I don't use Windows at all. If it can't be done on Linux, I simply don't do it. I don't even bother with wine.

There's a whole planet out there. Your computer doesn't need to be the only thing that occupies your time, it doesn't need to be perfect, it doesn't need to do everything.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by chrisBob on Friday March 01, 2019 @12:25PM (#19283064)
My customers often use Windows so my options are:

1) Don't bother testing what I write

2) Quit

Occasional Windows use seems like a great compromise.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by PascLeRasc on Friday March 01, 2019 @12:42PM (#19283326)
3) Find new customers
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by AstralStorm on Friday March 01, 2019 @12:59PM (#19283536)
You mean in the 2% or less that do not use iOS, Mac OS, Windows or Android, right?
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by mr_overalls on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:23AM (#19281413)
I find these two sentiments very strange in conjunction (complete abstinence from Windows, and the call to get away from your computer.) Did you mean for the second to be the opposite of the first?
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by linuxftw on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:34AM (#19281520)
I don't use Windows; if something can only be done on a Windows PC, I simply don't do it. I find literally anything else to do with my time.

Everyone would love to switch to linux, except "I can't do X on linux, and I must have X". People are literally addicted to PCs, I think it's unhealthy.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by nickjj on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:55AM (#19281757)
> Everyone would love to switch to linux, except "I can't do X on linux, and I must have X". People are literally addicted to PCs, I think it's unhealthy.

It's not just about spending all your time using computers or addiction.

I would like to switch to Linux but there's no screencast video editing tools that are comparable to Camtasia that run on Linux.

I wouldn't call that an unhealthy addiction for sticking with Windows. It's a necessity for my line of business.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by sdfgsd3fgsdfg on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:17AM (#19282093)
Did you try OBS Studio?

https://obsproject.com/

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by tombert on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:29AM (#19282259)
I'm not sure what you're trying to do, but OBS is pretty OK, while it takes a bit of a learning curve, Lightworks is pretty rad for video editing. If you haven't played with them, they're worth checking out.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by nickjj on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:43AM (#19282459)
OBS is amazing for streaming and recording but it's not equipped for editing previously recorded content.

I have hundreds of screencasts I recorded where I record my desktop and sometimes a webcam in the corner. These screencasts are put together to create a video course, so they need to be super polished.

With Camtasia it takes seconds to add really really nice looking tooltip pop ups, various text styles and arrows, smooth zoom / pans and even really neat animations that can be applied to anything.

For example check out the intro video on https://diveintodocker.com/. That entire animation (and video) was made in Camtasia in a few minutes without needing to do anything other than drag a few sliders around until the speed was right and it looked reasonable. Camtasia is an all purpose screencast editing tool but they have no Linux port.

I tried everything. Kdenlive, Lightworks, Shotcut, Open Shot, DaVinci Resolve and even Blender. They are all much much worse than Camtasia for editing screencast style videos (which are mostly around adding context related popups, dimming areas of the screen, adding text overlays, zooms, etc.). Worse as in, after 8 hours of trying to reproduce that Docker intro in Kdenlive I still didn't have anything that looked good with nothing in sight that would hint that I could do the things I could do in Camtasia. That was as of 2 months ago too.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by linuxftw on Friday March 01, 2019 @02:52PM (#19284616)
That's a really nice video and your quippy narration is quite pleasant.

I'll admit, my experience with video editing is quite minimal. I understand your reasoning for choosing the software you choose. My position is still don't use Windows.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by linuxftw on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:04AM (#19281888)
There are screencast and video editing tools available for linux and they cost $0.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by eropple on Friday March 01, 2019 @01:18PM (#19283722)
"Existing" and "being worth the aggravation to use" are significantly different things.

'nickjj has eloquently described the problems with pretty much everything available on Linux and I agree with him. I use Resolve, which does run on Linux, for video editing--but that's not the same thing he's talking about and I too use Camtasia on that dreaded, dreaded Windows for recording and editing down those sorts of presentations. Because to not do that would probably take half again as long, make for a worse end result, and have a direct impact on the likelihood of those clients buying from me or hiring me again.

Sneering zealots are weird, man. Don't be That Guy.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by nickjj on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:43AM (#19282472)
Yes but none of them are close to being comparable to Camtasia.

Check my other reply at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19282459.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by squarefoot on Friday March 01, 2019 @01:06PM (#19283607)
"I don't use Windows; if something can only be done on a Windows PC, I simply don't do it."

As a 99% Linux user (do very rarely used Wine and some VMs count as Windows installs?) I find this wrong when applied to real life scenarios. "Normal" users, the ones who would neither dare nor enjoy recompiling their kernel to squeeze out a few megabytes of free RAM, treat a PC just like a tool to get some work done (think a pair of scissors or a screwdriver, could anyone imagine someone wearing a black t-shirt showing their favorite screwdriver brand?). Those people are forced to use a PC because not doing so would mean being slower than other people, which in this society equals to lose a job or not meeting the requisites to get one. I'm pretty sure very few of them would waste their time at the PC if they could get the same results by themselves.

The right approach to help people abandon the Windows world is making their Linux experience as much painless as possible, which requires compromises on our part. I've converted some people in recent years (thanks also to the UI nightmare MS themselves created from Windows 8 and beyond) And never ever abandon them when they're initially lost because they're used to do something "the windows way": all my Linux installs for previous Windows users have a Windows (XP/7) like UI [1] and all Libreoffice installs save documents in Office 97-2003 format by default. I always offer them to evaluate Linux for a while, then if they find it unsuitable I'll install Windows back for free, no questions asked. So far I had only one person asking to go back to Windows, but he needed to use a proprietary software that didn't even work under Wine (more likely it was its copy protection). We need to adapt our approach to them, and not the way around, for we know both worlds while they have been exposed to a digital monoculturalism during their entire professional life.

[1] please, XFCE developers, consider changing the horrendous default look: it makes no sense having two panels eating space on a light DM that often is being chosen for laptops with limited vertical pixels. I know it takes a minute to correct that, but we want to help new users. Willing to help on that if anyone tells me how to turn a customized setup into a .deb package that might also pull a few dependencies (mostly themes). Having a nicer look as a third option when starting it for the 1st time would be even greater IMO.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by linuxftw on Friday March 01, 2019 @02:58PM (#19284685)
"Normal" users aren't what you think they are. They basically just use facebook at this point. You can give the bulk of society a modern linux distro with Chrome installed and they would never know the difference.

I no longer install or support Windows in any way for friends and family. If all the 'computer people' in everyone's lives quit helping them, Windows would finally die off because it's a crap product.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by PascLeRasc on Friday March 01, 2019 @12:46PM (#19283376)
I love this comment so much I might print it out and frame it. I've always had the same feeling but you put it into words so much better than I could. I'm perfectly ok with "missing out" on software that's Windows only. I really don't think I'll be on my deathbed wishing I had used my computer more.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by linuxftw on Friday March 01, 2019 @02:14PM (#19284274)
Thanks. I totally agree about that deathbed wish thing!
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by jessaustin on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:06AM (#19281238)
I can't remember when I last had windows installed on equipment that I owned. At some point I did, e.g. in college in the 90s, but it ceased to be the case a long time ago. Of course I occasionally help others who have windows, but I don't find that I need it.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by 13of40 on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:51AM (#19281717)
I'm the same. I was heavy into Linux when it first came out, but I've been pretty much 100% Windows for about 20 years. I still help my kid out when he has to use Linux for a project or whatever, but I could never see myself using it as my "daily driver".
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by PascLeRasc on Friday March 01, 2019 @12:48PM (#19283408)
For values of "same" approaching "not the same at all".
[dead]
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by jessaustin on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:38AM (#19288794)
I like a hilarious put-down as much as the next person, but your contributions here could be better motivated. Everyone here understands how somebody could be linux-only, but how on earth can you live your entire life on windows? It's just very difficult to understand...
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by intarga on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:52AM (#19281115)
The "hardcore Linux folk" run any windows apps they need in wine. It works pretty well. Also if you're running a VM, Microsoft obviously doesn't have root access to the host, which is what's in question.

The only sizeable groups of Linux users I know of to keep a windows partition are newcomers who want to be able to retreat to it, and previously gamers, though the latter is not really the case anymore since proton appeared.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by vonmoltke on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:56AM (#19281149)
> The only sizeable groups of Linux users I know of to keep a windows partition are newcomers who want to be able to retreat to it, and previously gamers, though the latter is not really the case anymore since proton appeared.

Over half my Steam games do not work properly with Proton.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by checkyoursudo on Friday March 01, 2019 @02:30PM (#19284425)
Only 2 of my 80-ish games don't work either natively or with Proton. One requires Uplay and the other requires something like Games for Windows Live, neither of which I can get to work in Wine.

Otherwise, I've had pretty good luck. A couple have required some tweaks, but otherwise it's been pretty easy.

Anyway, yay to no more VFIO/passthrough.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by everdrive on Friday March 01, 2019 @03:10PM (#19284791)
But the average steam user only plays 5% of the games he owns, so this may not be so bad!
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by tachyonbeam on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:35AM (#19280922)
I’ve been windows-free for 10 years. It’s really not so hard if you use a common distro like Ubuntu. Yes there are occasional glitches but, I’ve had to install windows 8 for my mom recently, and windows update was broken out of the box...
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by martin_a on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:47AM (#19281067)
> It’s really not so hard if you use a common distro like Ubuntu.

I hate this "argument". I am running Ubuntu myself for half a year now but there is no chance to get Adobe Creative Suite/Cloud to run smoothly on Ubuntu. You will absolutely need macOS or Windows for that.

And lots of people need professional applications like those to earn money. Not everybody can be happy and good to go with $texteditor and a bash.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by ryukafalz on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:36AM (#19281545)
This is a bit like saying "there is no chance to get iMessage running on Windows". The application developer hasn't given you that option; if it works at all, it's usually thanks to volunteers reverse-engineering things to get them to work.

If you absolutely need an application that isn't available on Linux, maybe Linux isn't right for you, at least not all the time. But there are tons of applications that are available on Linux. If you're not dead-set on Photoshop for example, GIMP is there. If you don't specifically need Acid, Ardour exists.

And plenty of people aren't musicians or artists and can get by pretty well with just a web browser, hence the popularity of Chromebooks. Browsers work just as well on Linux as on Windows or MacOS.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by martin_a on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:10AM (#19281983)
Well, no. OP took a broad stand and said that being Windows-free is not hard. That's just not reality for some professions.

Glad if it works for you, because you might not need some specialized software, but it is not an universal rule and people tend to forget that and treat non Windows-free users like they are too stupid to see the alternatives.

There are just no good alternatives for media professionals when it comes to things like Photoshop, Illustrator, Indesign. Other solutions lack compatibility or generate quirky output. Sometimes you need the real deal and it's no question of "liking" Windows.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by checkyoursudo on Friday March 01, 2019 @02:39PM (#19284495)
As someone who has no idea what media professionals require or why Photoshop/etc are so good, what makes programs like that so much better? I have occasionally watched videos of people using Blender or Krita or Gimp or ... Ink(spot?scape?), and they seem to be fine. Though, again, I don't use them professionally in the least bit.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by Wowfunhappy on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:15AM (#19282065)
And if your profession depends on access to iMessage, you're going to have to use macOS or iOS, regardless of whether or not you trust Apple.

This was my initial point. It's not so easy as "if you don't trust Microsoft you shouldn't use Windows." If that's an option, great. But it often isn't an option.

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by ChrisSD on Friday March 01, 2019 @12:40PM (#19283292)
In that case allow me to amend my original statement: If you don't trust Microsoft you shouldn't use Windows for your personal data.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by AstralStorm on Friday March 01, 2019 @01:02PM (#19283565)
Any data is personal, and business data is often even more valuable. And also liable.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by ChrisSD on Friday March 01, 2019 @02:08PM (#19284205)
Sure but if the company forces you to use a particular OS then they're the ones who are liable for the results of that decision.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by larrik on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:12AM (#19281308)
It's funny, Adobe's Suite is so bad for your computer. Every time I build a computer for my wife, it runs amazing until I install that shit on there. Then, nothing ever works quite right on it again.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by martin_a on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:32AM (#19281493)
Sounds like you don't know how to do it. Lots of systems run perfectly well with Adobe CS/CC.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by qrbLPHiKpiux on Friday March 01, 2019 @05:52PM (#19286101)
Compartment your work. I have a different machine and OS for what I need to do. At work, I can’t get away from MSWin. For other things, photo editing, video processing, it’s my MBPro. And for other things, my Debian box. Not one machine fits my workflow.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by martin_a on Monday March 04, 2019 @02:56AM (#19299561)
That's what I'm doing, too. Got two SSDs and choose whether to boot into Windows for Adobe CS, and nothing else, or boot my Ubuntu disk. Nevertheless I would prefer if I could just skip the windows disk.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by Wowfunhappy on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:38AM (#19280961)
Note I said "many", I know there are exceptions! It also largely depends on what you use your computer for. If you need even occasional access to Photoshop, for example, you're going to need Windows or macOS (or maybe iOS, I guess). GIMP might work sometimes, but not always.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by EngineerBetter on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:52AM (#19281118)
Anecdata point: I managed to make a commercial 2D platform game with GIMP. It's pretty powerful, even if the usability is not as good.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by LinuxBender on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:49AM (#19281700)
I have one old Windows 7 machine for playing World of Warcraft. I would (and have) run it on Linux, but the frame rate and object loading is a bit worse due to the CPU instruction latency from wine. GPU model doesn't even matter. I have begged Blizzard to make an unsupported linux elf binary, but they just won't.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by sten on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:59AM (#19282682)
I came across this when I attempted to run wow in linux after upgrading my gpu and ram. This was this month, and last time I logged in was in Legion. Exactly as you describe but you can fix it with Vulkan.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by LinuxBender on Friday March 01, 2019 @12:41PM (#19283303)
I've never tried Vulkan. I will look into it. Thankyou. :)
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by 51lver on Friday March 01, 2019 @01:04PM (#19283588)
Sure, but my XP and 98 boxes are not on a WAN connected network.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by Wowfunhappy on Friday March 01, 2019 @01:48PM (#19284024)
This is actually a really good, practical solution. Use the platforms you don't trust, just don't give them internet access. It won't work for every case, but probably a lot of them.

I think I'd get overly frustrated transferring files, but if you have a good solution for that...

Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by 51lver on Friday March 01, 2019 @07:16PM (#19286571)
Yeah, I occasionally connect a linux laptop on both networks (ipforwarding OFF) with an http port open that exposes my fileserver mounted on the laptop via NFS. If that's too hard, I just pull the hard drives out and connect to my workstation with USB, also good for imaging the machines since they crash so dang often.
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by lobotryas on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:41AM (#19281598)
Mac/Ubuntu covers all my bases. For personal or development use, what can Windows do that these others can’t?
Re:Does Windows 10's telemetry include sending *.doc files i... by colejohnson66 on Friday March 01, 2019 @12:48PM (#19283409)
Most AAA games?