Re:π does not equal 4
by jaf656s on Sunday November 21, 2010 @02:44PM
(#1927692)
Here is another way to see what is happening, that may be more clear from an intuitive sense:
From the puzzle, name the square object S and the circle inside it C_1.
Imagine another circle C_2 that circumscribes the square S from the puzzle. i.e. the corners of the square lie on the circle C_2. Then for each step, when we invert the outer-most corners of the square, we constrict C_2 such that the circle lies on the new outer-most points of S.
What happens is that as you repeat this process more and more the outer circle C_2 gets smaller and smaller, approaching the size of the original circle inside the square, C_1.
Also you can infer that the area of S is equal to the area of C_1 and C_2 since (area C_2) -> (area C_1) and (area C_1) <= (area S) <= (area C_2). Which makes sense intuitively, too, since they all enclose the same space.
This tells you nothing about the relationships between the circumference of the objects, though.
From the puzzle, name the square object S and the circle inside it C_1.
Imagine another circle C_2 that circumscribes the square S from the puzzle. i.e. the corners of the square lie on the circle C_2. Then for each step, when we invert the outer-most corners of the square, we constrict C_2 such that the circle lies on the new outer-most points of S.
What happens is that as you repeat this process more and more the outer circle C_2 gets smaller and smaller, approaching the size of the original circle inside the square, C_1.
Also you can infer that the area of S is equal to the area of C_1 and C_2 since (area C_2) -> (area C_1) and (area C_1) <= (area S) <= (area C_2). Which makes sense intuitively, too, since they all enclose the same space.
This tells you nothing about the relationships between the circumference of the objects, though.