News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:π does not equal 4 by jbapple on Sunday November 21, 2010 @12:36PM (#1927393)
When I first saw a "proof" like this, the explanation of its incorrectness was something like "limits don't preserve curve length". I wasn't satisfied with that answer until I took a first course in real analysis, which explained (some of) the reasons behind calculus.

Real analysis was very satisfying, in somewhat the same way that building low-level software or libraries is satisfying -- I got to understand the guts. It was also fun to learn about erroneous historical assumptions made due to insufficient rigor. IIRC, until at least the 1870s, it was believed that any continuous function must be differentiable almost everywhere, and that in fact this should be obvious. It turns out that one can construct continuous functions that are nowhere differentiable!

This was one of my favorite topics in the class:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Construction_of_the_real_number...

Re:π does not equal 4 by lmkg on Sunday November 21, 2010 @05:01PM (#1928005)
> Real analysis was very satisfying, in somewhat the same way that building low-level software or libraries is satisfying -- I got to understand the guts.

That is exactly the reason why taking a course in real analysis made me switch majors. I was trying to get that feeling from physics, but only found it to my satisfaction in math.

Re:π does not equal 4 by xyzzyz on Sunday November 21, 2010 @02:53PM (#1927710)
What is even more tricky is that the set of functions differentiable in at least one point is first category, and thus nowhere differentiable continuous functions are dense in continuous functions space.
Re:π does not equal 4 by drbaskin on Sunday November 21, 2010 @03:47PM (#1927838)
Not only are they dense, but they are "most" continuous functions! (For an appropriate interpretation of "most", of course)