News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by thinkcontext on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:28AM (#19272514)
Heat pump water heaters have efficiency of 3x+ vs .9 or so for gas or electric resistance. If you have have an electric resistance water heater get a heat pump model. It costs more upfront but will pay for itself in not too many years, especially considering many places have incentives. In the US natural gas is so cheap the economics are not nearly as good, it takes a long time to pay back the difference but does eventually. With even a modest carbon price obviously this would be different.

If you are going to replace your furnace or AC get a quote for replacing with a heat pump instead, either central or multiple mini-split heads. Heat pumps have gotten a lot better in recent years, particularly being able to work in cold weather down to 0F or below, expanding northward the places they are practical.

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by SigmundA on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:53PM (#19273338)
Electric resistance heat is 1.0 or 100% efficient, all electricity put into the heating element is converted to heat. Not sure if your trying to include power plant conversion and transmission losses, but that gets very complicated.

Gas units range in efficiency based on how much heat they recover from the exhaust, 80% is typical, 90+ for a condensing heater with two stage heat recovery. The problem with condensing is the exhaust gases fall below condensation point for the water vapor created during combustion requiring a condensate drain complicating the install location and cost significantly.

Heat pumps are over unity they use some energy to move more energy from the environment into the water, they are basically solar assisted resistance heaters.

The energy cost difference is not as clear when comparing a heat pump tank storage unit to a gas on demand tankless they are both typically more cost effective than tank storage electric or gas.

I have a 80% efficient tankless natural gas, it is wonderful having endless hot water at all faucets concurrently with a family of 4 plus occasional guests. I wanted to go condensing 90+ efficient but it was to complex based on its install location.

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by fulafel on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:15PM (#19275276)
In typical mounting of electric radiator elements, some of the heat might be absorbed in the walls and windows that are facing outdoors. Then the temperature gardient in the wall/window insulation is steeper, leaking more heat outside. So yes, all the energy is converted into heat, but some of it may be heating the outdoors.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by SigmundA on Monday March 04, 2019 @07:50AM (#19300816)
This has nothing to do with the type of heater but rather the placement. When talking about relative efficiency you look at the heater itself and not common factors as they can be eliminated from the equation.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by isbjorn16 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:24PM (#19273033)
Speaking specifically of heat pump water heaters - I will absolutely cede that they are more efficient, but holy _crap_ they take forever to recover.

My previous water heater was a 70 gallon conventional electric. It didn't have quite enough hot water to get everyone through showering when we had extended family over, but it recovered reasonably quickly so that we only had ~ 30 minute gaps or so in waiting between the person who felt it get cold first and the next in line. Pretty reasonable.

Ours was about 20 years old and we also wanted a bunch of other plumbing work done, so we decided we may as well bite the bullet and get a new one. We replaced ours with an 80 gallon hybrid (electric + heatpump). We figured the extra 10 gallons would probably actually completely negate the need to wait between showers for those last people, so we were super stoked.

The reality is it exacerbated matters drastically. The refresh rate on our old water heater apparently was almost good enough to keep up with sustained usage between 7 people. The current one runs out of hot water out of 2 and takes well over an hour to even have enough hot water for a single next shower.

I tend to take pretty long showers in the morning - like 20 minutes or so. I use a CPAP and clean my mask, I brush my teeth, I brush my invisaligns (which is why I do my teeth in the shower - it's impossible to scrub invisalign braces and not fling infinite toothpaste flotsam everywhere), and I wash myself (which honestly is the fastest part - I keep my hair next to non existent and just do a body wash from head to toe, rinse, and leave. The point is that the 20 minutes I spend in the shower, with a low flow water reducing showerhead, still means my wife gets to get a cold shower an entire hour later.

However, from what I was told, there are new regulations regarding electric hot water heaters; namely, you can't get over 60 gallon tanks with a conventional hot water heater. Apparently people are getting around this by buying light industrial ones, which don't have this limitation. I wanted to try to cut down on energy usage AND I was keen on the idea of having a heat pump in my garage, transferring the heat in said garage into the water, thus leaving the garage cooler. It's like a really inefficient air conditioner for my garage, but given how hot that gets in the summer and how little I spend time in my woodworking shop, I wanted to leap at the chance to maybe make it a better environment.

All of this is a long winded way of saying it may win on efficiency, and it does have a number of compelling secondary features about it, but it also still suffers from poor refractory performance. If you have one as well - do you notice issues like this? Perhaps the one I got is faulty or just ... not good.

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by ip26 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:35PM (#19273158)
Have you heard of drainwater heat recovery? One of the side benefits is dramatically improving the recovery rate of your water heater.

(Unfortunately it doesn't work well with certain plumbing layouts, and the rising price of copper has reduced the cost effectiveness)

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by mrclark411 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:32PM (#19273731)
Just moved into our "forever" home and our setup is very similar to isbjorn16's (7 in the family, HPWH "80G", but I have an 8" PowerPipe from these folks: http://renewability.com/#learn-more. (It's a monster - plumber wanted to give me a clean out at the bottom - but that meant some jackhammering to set it low enough.)

So far so good - we do a bunch of baths/showers at bed time and no one runs out of hot water. Also - I'll add that we accidentally had the plumber remove all the low flow "plugs" from the showers so there's a lot of water flowing.

The pipe is pretty fun - not only is it fun to look at - but when someone is taking a shower it's fun to feel the heat at the top of the pipe and as you move down the pipe it gets colder until it reaches the temp of the cold water coming into the house.

Since it was new construction - we'll never know how much of a different the drainwater heat recovery pipe is making - but it is definitely doing work.

I can imagine these pipes becoming more popular (though rising prices will kill off any efficiencies real fast). Maybe code?

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by isbjorn16 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:43PM (#19273872)
I have not! https://www.energy.gov/energysaver/water-heating/drain-water... seemed to make a fair amount of sense for me, so if anyone else is curious, there's a link!

My plumbing layout actually might be darn near ideal for this. I'm not super keen on spending another thousand or so on getting it installed - at least not prior to the "planned but not scheduled" bathroom remodel, but that is at least worth considering when we do do the major remodel and complete bathroom reconfiguration. Our master bath is on the first floor and we don't have a finished basement so making something like this work should be comparatively easy. Thanks for the idea!

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by ip26 on Friday March 01, 2019 @07:46PM (#19286708)
FWIW they aren't difficult to do yourself, as long as you can sweat pipe. It's a very simple device after all.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by caf on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:43PM (#19276576)
Is it possible that the setpoint on your old water heater was higher than the new one, so that you used less litres of heated water for the same shower (since it mixed in more cold water)?
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by isbjorn16 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:28PM (#19273070)
Actually, come to think of it - it might just be that it's pretty cold in my garage right now, ~ 40F: maybe it just isn't getting much help from the heat pump and the conventional electric heater isn't doing a great job on its own?

I'll have to pay attention into summer when it's like 95 in my garage. Maybe I can presume raging hot showers -for days- at that point :D

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by cmurphycode on Thursday February 28, 2019 @04:01PM (#19275145)
That's definitely part of it. I'm actually surprised it's working in heat pump mode at all. We have a hybrid and it will run pure-resistive if the ambient temperature is below 50. Now, it's in our basement, so even in the winter that's a reasonable cut-off - not sure if you got a specific model for being "outside".

Speaking of which, does your model not have a resistive backup? Ours has several modes:

- only use heat pump, unless not safe to do so (ambient too cold) - use heat pump normally but fall back to resistive to recover - use resistive only

We only have 2 people in the house so we are able to leave it on the first mode, but in the second mode it would, presumably, be the same performance as our old resistive-only heater.

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by isbjorn16 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @05:44PM (#19276089)
Solid questions - I'm going to take a peek at it tonight. I honestly haven't given it a lot of thought, but literally just this morning my wife went off on a rant about it for a good 15 minutes. It suddenly bubbled up my priority queue pretty quick - and then out of nowhere, this thread on heat pumps and water heaters! Crazy coincidences sometimes.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by Johnny555 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:44PM (#19273249)
I use a showerhead shutoff valve -- when I'm shaving in the shower or doing anything that doesn't require a steady shower of water, I turn off the water at the showerhead, then I can flip it back on when I want water, and it continues at the same temperature/pressure it was before.

I also use a 1.5gpm low-flow showerhead (many "low-flow" heads are 2.5gpm).

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by isbjorn16 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @01:40PM (#19273831)
That would be a mitigation strategy, but my main point is my old conventional had significantly fewer and less lengthy hot water outages compared to my new fancy hybrid with a larger tank. To be clear, we make this work - it isn't a catastrophe by any stretch, but it is a marked surprise when you expected superior hot water uptime and you get distinctly WORSE hot water uptime, you know?
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by heatpumper on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:43AM (#19272648)
I can tell you that my heat pump set up at my condo is absolute trash here in Northern Ohio. Running 24/7 it is unable to get my condo above 62 deg F. It blows cold-ish air under an outside temperature of 40 deg F. Windows are new, doors are weather stripped. I'm having it run it in supplemental mode just to get it above 65 deg F.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by ethagknight on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:16PM (#19272953)
My HVAC is utter crap ≠ HVACs are crap. This is a great example of a worthless anecdotal comment that distracts from the point. Give us some more detail like model number or install date? Is it a modern unit not coming close to its advertise performance? Is it appropriately sized for your condo?
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by jandrese on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:04PM (#19272858)
Your heat pump is probably about 20 years old and on its last legs. Newer ones are amazing. We lopped $40 off of our electricity bill each month in the winter and $20 in the summer after we replaced ours. It pays for itself after a few years.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by Robotbeat on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:46AM (#19272676)
There are some very bad heat pumps out there. The difference in usability varies dramatically. Some heat pumps will produce heat even below 0F. Others are crappy at anything under 40F.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by dashundchen on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:16PM (#19272945)
From what I understand, cold weather air source heat pumps are relatively new to the market, at least in the US. Previously they were designed more for cooling loads and were essentially space heaters with an COP of 1 in cold weather.

Many manufactuers seem to offer warm and cold climate models. For example, pulling a random manufactuerer, Mitsubishi brands their cold climate line "Hyper" and specs out much better efficiency down to -13F temperatures.

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by mr337 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:48AM (#19272689)
Something must be wrong. My heatpump will run you out of the house at 40F outside.

Below 20F it puts out so so heat but can maintain. Below 10F electric heat is needed from time to time to maintain. Below 0F heat pump is worthless.

Edit: Wanted to add my is air heatpump, not ground source. Also reading other comments looks like heatpumps range from amazing to utter crap.

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by czechdeveloper on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:52AM (#19272731)
Your heat pump just does not have sufficient capacity. It's not problem of heat pump per se.
Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by toomuchtodo on Thursday February 28, 2019 @11:51AM (#19272727)
1. Have an HVAC tech inspect it (~$100-150).

2. If it's not a coolant or compressor issue, you might need to replace it (either because it is undersized or end of life). Your local government or utility might have energy incentives for replacing it. There are also federal tax credit incentives [1].

[1] https://www.energystar.gov/about/federal_tax_credits/air_sou...

Re:Heat Pumps Work Miracles by bluGill on Thursday February 28, 2019 @12:20PM (#19272994)
A heatpump blows warm air not hot. Most people expect hot air from their vents and so are confused by not getting it.

My heat pump in Iowa worked just fine to keep the house comfortable down to 14F (the system automatically switched to backup heat colder than that). Something is wrong with your system if it can't do that. I couldn't begin to guess what though.